Tandem time of flight mass spectrometer and method of use
Abstract
To provide comprehensive, i.e. rapid and sensitive, MS-MS analysis, the invention involves a time-nested separation, using two time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometers 13 and 15. Parent ions are separated in a slow and long TOF1 13, operating at a low ion energy (1 to 100eV), and fragment ions are mass analysed in a fast and short TOF2 15, operating at a much higher keV energy. A low energy fragmentation (CID) cell 14 between TOF1 and TOF2 is tailored to accelerate fragmentation and dampening steps by shortening the cell and employing a higher collision gas pressure. Since separation in TOF1 takes milliseconds and mass analysis in TOF2 takes microseconds, the invention provides comprehensive MS-MS analysis of multiple precursor ions per single ion pulse. Preferably the second time-of-flight mass analyser TOF2 is of the orthogonal acceleration type (oa-TOF).

Term
Term ended
Expired 29 April 2023, 3.4 years ago.
- Priority
- Filed
- Granted
- Expired
- Today
39 claims: 2 independent, 37 dependent
- 1A tandem mass spectrometer comprising a pulsed ion source (12), a parent ion separator in the form of a first time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF1) (13), a fragmentation cell (14), and a second time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF2) (15), the tandem mass spectrometer being characterized in that it comprises a time nested data acquisition system (16) acquiring fragment mass spectra for multiple parent ions, and in that said tandem mass spectrometer is configured so that the time between arrival of adjacent parent ion species in said TOF1 is sufficient to fragment said parent ion species in said fragmentation cell (14) and to mass analyze the resulting fragments in said TOF2.
- 23A method of comprehensive tandem mass spectroscopy analysis, comprising the steps of:(1) ejecting a plurality of parent ions having various mass-to-charge ratios from a pulsed ion source;(2) separating said parent ions as a function of time within a first time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF1) (13);(3) fragmenting the time-separated parent ions;and (4) analyzing the fragmented parent ions within a second time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF2) (15), wherein the method is characterized in that it further comprises the step of: (5) time nesting the fragmented parent ion spectra acquisition corresponding to multiple parent ions per ion pulse without mixing fragment spectra of different parent ions, wherein, to improve sensitivity and throughput of MS-MS analysis, the time of said parent ion separation significantly exceeds the time of both fragmentation and fragment mass analysis.
Independent claims2
95 paragraphs, as filed
<u>FIELD OF THE INVENTION</u>
0001The invention relates to the area of mass spectrometry and, more particularly, is concerned with a method of high-throughput, comprehensive tandem mass spectrometry in apparatus, including two time-of-flight mass spectrometers.
<u>BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION</u>
0002Mass spectrometers are devices which vaporize and ionize a sample and then use static or dynamic electric fields to measure the mass-to-charge ratios of the ions formed. Tandem mass spectrometry is used for structural analysis and the identification of compounds in complex mixtures. In substantially every application the MS-MS procedure adheres to the following sequence of operations: mass selection of parent ions of a single mass-to-charge ratio (m/z); fragmentation of those ions; and mass analysis of the fragments. Though there is a large variety of tandem MS-MS instruments with their own strength and weakness, all of them have one common feature - all of them use one parent ion at a time. The rest of ion species are removed out of the primary ion beam and lost.
0003Triple quadrupole instruments are the most common MS-MS instruments. A continuous ion source, like e.g. electrospray (ESI), introduces ions into a first quadrupole mass filter, which is tuned, such that only ions-of-interest pass the mass filter. The rest of the primary beam components are rejected and lost. Selected ions are transmitted into a so-called 'collision induced dissociation' (CID) cell, filled with gas at pressures of few tens of millitorrs and equipped with a radio frequency (RF) quadrupole guide. The kinetic energy of the injected ions is controlled by an electrostatic bias on the mass filter and is adjusted to induce ion fragmentation via gas collisions. Fragment ions are collisional dampened in CID cell and then introduced into a second quadrupole for mass analysis. Since mass scanning in a second quadrupole takes time and causes additional ion losses by factor of c.a. 1000, triple quadrupole instruments are mostly used for detection of known species with known masses of parent and fragment ions.
0004The introduction of quadrupole-time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometers (Q-TOF) strongly enhanced throughput of MS-MS instruments (see<nplcit id="ncit0001" npl-type="s"><text> Morris et al. Rap. Comm. Mass. Spectrom. v.10, pp. 889-896, 1996</text></nplcit>). The triple quadrupole was modified, such that the second quadrupole mass filter was replaced by an orthogonal TOF MS (o-TOFMS). This substitution gave an advantage of parallel analysis of all fragment ions at once and, hence, higher sensitivity and faster acquisition in a second MS, as well as enhanced resolution and mass accuracy of second MS. However, the quadrupole is still used for parent ion selection, accompanied by rejection of all ion species but one. The idea of parallel analysis has not been extended onto parent ions.
0005Another common MS-MS device is a Paul ion trap mass spectrometer (ITMS), well described in March, R.E., Hughes R.J. Quadrupole storage mass spectrometry, Willey-Interscience, New York 1989. Ions, produced in the ion source, are periodically injected into an ITMS and are trapped within the ITMS by a radio-frequency (RF) field. 'Unwanted' species are removed by e.g. applying a broadband resonant AC signal, so that only ions-of-interest remain in the trap. Selected parent ions are then excited by a separate AC field, resonant with the secular motion of the precursor. Parent ions gain kinetic energy and fragment in energetic collisions with a buffer gas. Fragments are mass analyzed using a resonant ejection technique. The amplitude of an RF field is ramped such that ions leave the trap sequentially according to their m/z values.
0006It also has been known to couple a 3-D Paul trap with a TOF analyzer for more accurate mass analysis of fragment ions. See <nplcit id="ncit0002" npl-type="s"><text>Quin and D. Lubman, Rap. Comm. Mass. Spectrom. 10, 1079, 1996</text></nplcit> and <patcit id="pcit0001" dnum="WO09939368A"><text>WO 099/39368 by Shimadzu</text></patcit>. A linear ion trap (LIT) has been coupled to a TOF analyzer in <patcit id="pcit0002" dnum="US5847386A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 5,847,386 by D. Douglas</text></patcit>, in <patcit id="pcit0003" dnum="US6111250A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 6,111,250 by B.A. Thomson and L.L. Joliffe</text></patcit>, in <patcit id="pcit0004" dnum="US6020586A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 6,020,586 by T. Dresch et al.</text></patcit> and in <patcit id="pcit0005" dnum="WO0115201A"><text>WO 01/15201 by B. Reinhold and A. Verentchikov</text></patcit>. All ion trap tandems are mostly oriented on multiple stage MS-MS analysis. Parent ions are selected with a loss of other ion components.
0007Recently introduced tandem time-of-flight mass spectrometers (TOF-TOF) are the closest prototypes to the below described invention by similarity of employed hardware. Examples of TOF-TOF are described in <patcit id="pcit0006" dnum="US5032722A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 5,032,722 by Schlag et al.</text></patcit>, <patcit id="pcit0007" dnum="US5464985A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 5,464,985 by T.J. Kornish et al.</text></patcit>, <patcit id="pcit0008" dnum="US5854485A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 5,854,485 by T. Bergmann</text></patcit>, in <patcit id="pcit0009" dnum="WO9940610A"><text>WO 99/40610 by M.L. Vestal</text></patcit>, in <patcit id="pcit0010" dnum="US6300627B"><text>U.S. Patent No. 6,300,627 by C. Koster et al.</text></patcit> and in <patcit id="pcit0011" dnum="WO9901889A"><text>WO 99/01889 by C. Hop</text></patcit>. In all TOF-TOF tandems, a pulsed ion beam is time separated in a first, high-energy TOF and filtered by timed ion selector, so that only ions-of-interest pass into the CID cell. The CID cell is filled with gas at a low gas pressure (usually below 1 mtorr) to induce single high-energy collisions with the buffer gas sufficient for ion fragmentation, but still retaining short duration to maintain an ion packet. A pulsed beam of fragment ions is analyzed in a second, high energy TOF. To handle the large energy spread of the fragment ions, the second TOF employs either quadratic field potential or an additional pulsed acceleration.
0008In <patcit id="pcit0012" dnum="WO0077823A"><text>WO 00/77823 by A.Verentchikov</text></patcit>, a variation of TOF-TOF tandem employs slow injection of parent ions into a CID cell with collisional dampening of fragments and subsequent injection into an orthogonal TOF. The instrument is the closest prototype of the invention, considering employed components. Collisional dampening in the fragmentation cell improves ion beam characteristics upstream of the second TOF and allows high resolution and accurate measurements of fragment ion masses. The first TOF operates at 1kV energy and a short time scale. A time gate in front of a CID cell admits only one parent ion-mass at a time.
0009In all described tandems the first mass analyzer (either quadrupole, ion trap or TOF) selects one parent ion mass at a time and rejects all other components. In some applications, like drug metabolism studies, it is acceptable to follow a single compound of interest. In the case of complex mixtures (like protein characterization out of gels), however, it is necessary to analyze multiple parent ions. Using existing techniques, sequential MS-MS analysis of multiple precursors is tedious and insensitive.
0010Recently introduced tandem IMS-CID-TOF mass spectrometers employ a principle of time-nested acquisition, potentially to be implemented without ion losses. See <patcit id="pcit0013" dnum="WO0070335A"><text>WO 00/70335 by D. Clemmer</text></patcit> (also published as <patcit id="pcit0014" dnum="US6323482B"><text>U.S. Patent No. 6,323,482</text></patcit>). Since separation in the ion mobility spectrometer (IMS) occurs in milliseconds and TOF mass spectrometry in microseconds, it is possible to acquire fragment spectra for each ion mobility fraction. The disadvantage of the technique is a poor IMS separation with mobility resolution below R=50, which corresponds to low mass resolution. Since IMS-TOF tandem employs a principle of comprehensive tandem mass spectrometry with time-nested acquisition, it is selected as a "prototype" of the invention.
0011The idea of MS-MS analysis without parent ion losses is also disclosed in <patcit id="pcit0015" dnum="WO0115201A"><text>WO 01/15201 by B. Reinhold and A. Verentchikov</text></patcit>. Ions are selected by resonant excitation and moved between ion traps without rejecting other ionic components. The procedure is tedious and long, while ions from the ion source are lost. So-called parallel ion processing is employed in multiple ion traps in <patcit id="pcit0016" dnum="WO9214259A"><text>WO 92/14259 by Kirchner</text></patcit>, where the beam is split between multiple traps. Time is saved by sacrificing sensitivity.
0012There is still a need for an instrument providing rapid and sensitive MS-MS analysis for multiple parent ions in parallel without rejecting ions coming from an ion source. Such an instrument would further improve a throughput of MS-MS analysis, desirable in analysis of complex mixtures.
<u>SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION</u>
0013The present invention appreciates that one can implement the principle of nested time separation using two time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometers; a slow TOF1 for parent ion separation, and a fast TOF2 for fragment mass analysis. Thus, the tandem mass spectrometry of the invention employs two time-of-flight separations, wherein, for the same mass-to-charge ratio, flight time in the first separation step is much longer than flight time in the second separation step and multiplicity of parent ions are separated, fragmented and mass analyzed per single ion injection from the ion source.
0014The mass spectrometer of the invention comprises a pulsed ion source, a time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF1) for time separation of the parent ions, a fragmentation cell, a second time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF2) for mass analysis of the fragment ions and a data acquisition system. Contrary to prior TOF-TOF systems, flight time in the TOF1 is substantially greater than the combined passage time through the fragmentation cell and the flight time in the TOF2. It could be noted that such principle is sometimes employed in time-of-flight systems but it is used solely for ion detection as described, for example, in <patcit id="pcit0017" dnum="US5202561A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 5,202,561 by U. Giessmann et al.</text></patcit> or by <nplcit id="ncit0003" npl-type="s"><text>J. Martens et al., Rap. Comm. Mass Spectrom., 6(2), 1992, 147-157</text></nplcit>. Ions impinge on a solid surface and resulting secondary ions are deflected onto a TOF detector nearby, preferably using a magnetic field. Due to short flight times (typically on the order of less than 1 microsecond), the detected peaks are resolved so poorly and also contain so many contaminants from the surface that no useful structural information could be extracted about the primary ions and hence they cannot possibly be regarded as fragment mass spectra. This drawback is alleviated in the current invention by employing prolonged separation in TOF1, typically in millisecond range, while separation in TOF2 occurs on a more traditional timescale of several tens of microseconds. Prolonged separation in TOF1 could be achieved by operating longer TOF1 at much lower kinetic energy, typically around 1 to 100 eV, while using shorter TOF2 at 3 to 10 keV energy. Time between arrivals of adjacent parent ion species becomes sufficient to fragment and mass analyze fragments without severely compromising quality of fragment spectra. Thus, the invention allows rapid MS-MS analysis of multiple parent ions in real time without rejecting parent ions. The MS-MS acquisition cycle lasts a few milliseconds and can be repeated multiple times to improve sensitivity and signal quality.
0015To avoid ion losses the ion source is operated in a pulsed mode at about 100 Hz repetition rate, compatible with millisecond time of MS-MS cycle. A Matrix Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization (MALDI) ion source is one example of a usable pulsed ion source. The invention is also compatible with a wide variety of continuous ion sources, like ESI, MALDI with gas cooling, Chemical Ionization and gas filled Photoionization ion sources. Ion flow is continuously accumulated within storage radio frequency (RF) device and is periodically pulse ejected into the TOF1. The said storage device can be either Paul trap or storage multipole, preferably quadrupole.
0016It is believed that the novel time-nested TOF-TOF method cannot be implemented on existing TOF-TOF instruments without severe sacrifice of performance. The invention discloses several novel TOF1 separators, operating at lower ion energies (1 to 100eV) to expand separation time.
0017Two of those novel TOF1 analyzers employ a combination of a confining radio frequency (RF) field with a DC quadratic field, providing temporal focusing of the ion beam with a relative large energy spread. Those analyzers are capable of operating at a particularly low ion energy ranging from 1 to 10 eV. In one preferred embodiment, the novel TOF1 analyzer comprises a linear multipole ion guide, preferably quadrupole, surrounded by DC mirrors. DC mirrors on both ends are turned on and off to provide ion injection from one TOF1 end, multiple ion reflections and subsequent ion release from another end. In another preferred embodiment, the novel TOF1 analyzer comprises two external rows of DC electrodes and two internal rows of RF-only rods, oriented across TOF1 axis. The structure forms a two-dimensional RF-tunnel combined with quadratic potential distribution along the TOF axis. Ions are injected into the TOF1 at a small angle to the axis, experience multiple reflections along the axis, slowly shift across the axis and leave TOF1 after several reflections.
0018Another three novel analyzers are electrostatic devices, operating at medium energy around 100eV. One of them, a `spiratron' comprises a pair of coaxial cylindrical electrodes with DC voltage applied between them. Ions are injected between the electrodes at small angle to their axis. Medium energy (100 eV) ions turn around central electrode while drifting slowly along the axis. After a number of turns ions leave TOF1 through a cut-off boundary, which is formed by double sided printed circuit board to avoid DC field disturbance. Other two electrostatic separators are planar and cylindrical multi-pass analyzers, employing gridless mirrors, simultaneously acting like a lens. The effective flight path is extended by use of a multi-pass mode, so that a 10ms time scale is achieved despite a higher energy (compared to RF assisted TOF1).
0019The invention is compatible with a variety of fragmentation methods including gas collisions and collisions with surface and by light. The design of fragmentation cells is trimmed to reduce transmission time and time spread. The CID cell is short (around 1 cm), filled with gas at a relatively high pressure (above 0.1 mBar) and supplemented by an axial DC field to accelerate transmission and to modulate the ion beam synchronous with TOF2. The surface induced dissociation (SID) cell uses a pulsed lens to provide spatial focusing together with temporal focusing (bunching). Ions are ejected out of the SID cell by pulsing the probe potential, synchronized (though with time shift) with the bunching lens and TOF2 pulses.
0020Although the choice of the second time-of-flight analyzer is not critical, the TOF with orthogonal ion injection (o-TOF) is more suitable in a majority of tandem examples. In order to improve the efficiency of orthogonal injection (so-called duty cycle), it is preferred to eject ions out of the fragmentation cell synchronous and slightly prior to the orthogonal injection pulses.
0021The TOF-TOF tandem of the invention is expected to separate parent ions at a moderate resolution, mostly limited by speed of the second TOF MS, e.g. 10µs. The estimated resolution of TOF1 on the order of 300 (see detailed description) is still sufficient to isolate a group of isotopes of parent ions and is much higher than the resolution of parent separation in the prior art ion mobility spectrometer. Higher resolution of separation could be achieved in longer TOF1 or by periodic selection of ions by a time gate in front of CID cell.
0022The invention permits multiple strategies for data acquisition. In a simplest and robust approach, MS-MS data are acquired continuously and MS-MS spectra of multiple parent ions are reconstructed afterwards. It is wiser, though, to perform MS-MS analysis in two stages. At first, MS-only stage, parent ions are continuously admitted into the TOF2 for mass analysis of parent ions. Information on masses of parent ions is used for a second MS-MS stage. The time gate opens only at a time of arrival of multiple parents of interest to improve the resolution of parent ion separation and to avoid signals from chemical background. TOF2 signal is also acquired for selected time windows only to reject meaningless data flow. Similar information on parent ions may be obtained using an optional on-line detector located anywhere after TOF1.
0023In addition to highly sensitive and rapid MS-MS analysis, the invention provides multiple types of MS-only analysis. TOF1 alone can be used for MS only analysis for the sake of spreading peaks in time, avoiding detector saturation and using an inexpensive and slow transient recorder. A better quality spectrum of parent ions could be acquired in TOF2 while using TOF1 in a pass mode. So-called "Parent scan", i.e. spectrum of parent ions having a set of specific fragments, can be reconstructed from MS-MS data, averaged in multiple source injections. The data could be finally stored for parents masses only.
0024Since MS/MS spectra are acquired for all precursor ions of interest in a single ion injection, the invention provides an exceptional speed of MS/MS analysis, estimated as 10 to 30 full cycles a second. The speed of MS-MS analysis is compatible with the time scale of chromatographic separation, thus, a real time LC-MS-MS analysis is possible without any prior limitations, such as "data dependent acquisition," currently employed in ion traps and Q-TOFs. High acquisition speed and sensitivity of the invented MS-MS tandem also opens an opportunity for using nested LC-LC analysis up-front.
<u>BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS</u>
0025This invention is pointed out with particularity in the appended claims. The above and further advantages of this invention may be better understood by referring to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which: <ul id="ul0001" list-style="none" compact="compact"><li><figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref> is a block diagram, illustrating the method of the invention.</li><li><figref idref="f0001">Fig. 2</figref> is a timing diagram of operation of tandem TOF-TOF mass spectrometer.</li><li><figref idref="f0002">Fig. 3</figref> is a schematic of novel in-line TOF1.</li><li><figref idref="f0002">Fig. 4</figref> is a schematic of novel W-shape TOF1.</li><li><figref idref="f0003">Fig. 5</figref> is a schematic of vacuum pulsed MALDI ion source.</li><li><figref idref="f0003">Fig. 6</figref> is a schematic of pulsed MALDI ion source with collisional dampening.</li><li><figref idref="f0003">Fig. 7</figref> is a schematic of continuous ion source with pulsing storage quadrupole.</li><li><figref idref="f0004">Fig. 8</figref> is a schematic of CID cell.</li><li><figref idref="f0004">Fig. 9</figref> is a schematic of SID cell.</li><li><figref idref="f0004">Fig. 10</figref> is a schematic of orthogonal TOF2.</li><li><figref idref="f0004">Fig. 11</figref> is a schematic of coaxial TOF2</li><li><figref idref="f0005">Fig. 12</figref> is a schematic of TOF-TOF with in-line TOF1 and CID cell.</li><li><figref idref="f0006">Fig. 13</figref> is a schematic of TOF-TOF with W-shape TOF1 and SID cell.</li><li><figref idref="f0007">Fig. 14</figref> is a schematic of TOF-TOF with static coaxial TOF1.</li><li><figref idref="f0008">Fig. 15</figref> is a schematic of planar electrostatic multi-pass TOF1.</li><li><figref idref="f0009">Fig. 16</figref> is a schematic of cylindrical electrostatic multi-pass TOF1.</li></ul>
<u>DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION</u>
0026A method of tandem mass spectrometry analysis of the invention comprises the steps of: generating an ion pulse in an ion source, containing a mixture of different analyte ions; separating the analyte ions according to time-of-flight within a first time-of-flight mass spectrometer, operating at low energy, and, thus, generating a train of ion packets in a sequence of their masses; sequentially fragmenting the analyte ions without mixing the separated ion packets; mass analyzing the fragmented ions within a second time-of-flight mass spectrometer at a time scale much shorter than a time scale of the first separation step; acquiring fragment mass spectra for multiple analyte ion mass-to-charge ratios at a single ion pulse out of the ion source, and, optionally, summing the fragment spectra for each of the analyte ions over multiple source pulses.
0027Fundamental to the method is arranging the separation time in the first TOF much longer than fragmentation time and time of fragment mass analysis for the same mass-to-charge ratio. Substantial difference in time scales is utilized to separate, fragment and mass-analyze fragments for multiplicity of parent ions per single ion injection out of the ion source. The substantial difference in time scale is achieved by a longer flight path and/or lower ion energy in the first TOF.
0028Referring to <figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref>, the method is illustrated by a block diagram of the major tandem MS-MS components. The generic TOF-TOF instrument with time-nested acquisition 11 comprise a sequentially communicating pulsed ion source 12, a first time-of-flight mass spectrometer -TOF1 13, a fragmentation cell CID/SID 14, a second time-of-flight mass spectrometer TOF2 15 and a data system 16 for time-nested acquisition. The pulsed ion source is biased compared to the TOF1 spectrometer at a small potential difference by voltage supply 17, and the TOF1 is biased compared to the CID cell at a potential difference by voltage supply 18. An optional timed gate 19 may be inserted between the TOF1 13 and the CID cell 14 to enhance TOF1 separation.
0029Briefly, in operation, the pulsed ion source generates an ion pulse of analyte (parent) ions and injects ions into the TOF1 at a reduced energy, typically between 1 to 10eV, controlled by a voltage supply 17. This is an important difference between the current invention and the prior art, since TOF spectrometers are usually operated at energies between 3 and 30keV. Separation in TOF1 occurs typically in several milliseconds. As a guiding example consider an effective length of TOF1 L1=8m, mean ion energy E=3 eV and ion mass m=1000 a.m.u. In this example, ion velocity is V=800 m/s and the flight time is 10ms. Time-separated parent ions are sequentially ejected out of TOF1 into the CID cell at an increased energy level controlled by a DC bias between TOF1 and the cell. Energetic collisions with the carrier gas molecules convert the parent ions into fragments. Subsequent gas collisions cause collisional dampening of fragment ions. Fragments rapidly travel through the cell and are injected into the TOF2 spectrometer. TOF2 separates fragment ions at a much shorter time scale, between 10 and 100µs. Drastic difference in time scales of TOF1 and TOF2 allows data acquisition of multiple fragment spectra, corresponding to different parent ions between source pulses. The specialized data acquisition system 16 acquires multiple fragment spectra in a time-nested fashion, where individual spectra are not mixed together. Fragment spectra for each parent ion are integrated over a number of ion source pulses. Thus, ion pulse, generated in the ion source, is used for acquiring a full set of MS-MS data for multiple parents without rejecting ions at all stages.
0030Referring to <figref idref="f0001">Fig. 2</figref>, a typical time diagram illustrates the method of the invention, synchronization of individual devices and a principle of time-nested data acquisition. The top graph 21 presents an acquisition cycle, where ion injections occur every 10ms, i.e. 100 times a second. Parent ions are separated in the TOF1 within 10ms time, and the CID cell receives a train of ion packets, aligned in accordance with parent ion mass, graph 22. Parent ions are partially fragmented in the cell, and because of a short transmission time in the cell, fragments arrive at TOF2 almost simultaneously with their parents, graph 23. Each new family of ions (i.e. parents and daughters) is orthogonally pulsed into the high energy TOF2 every 10µs, producing TOF2 spectra for each parent mass - graph 24. Each TOF2 spectrum obtains a time tag of TOF2 pulse relative to source pulse, i.e. TOF1 time tag. The spectra with the same TOF1 time tag are summed over multiple ion source pulses, as shown by dashed lines, connecting two TOF2 spectra with the same TOF1 time tag.
0031In the above described operation mode, the time-nested acquisition is done in a straightforward way. Instrument operation parameters remain the same, regardless of the ion beam composition from the ion source, and data are acquired all the time. All the information, like parent ion spectra and fragment spectra for various parents, is extracted in a subsequent data analysis.
0032In another operation mode, which should be called 'data dependent acquisition', MS-MS analysis occurs in two steps. On the first step, mass spectrum of parents is acquired in a TOF2, while TOF1 and CID cell pass ions continuously without.On the second step, the instrument is operated as MS-MS, i.e., the TOF1 separates parent ions, the fragmentation cell forms fragments, the TOF2 acquires fragment mass spectra in the time-nested data fashion. The time-nested acquisition is enhanced by utilizing the information on the parent ion masses and avoiding data acquisition at blank times, when no parents are coming. An optional timed gate 19 may be used to enhance TOF1 separation as well as suppression of chemical noise. It is naturally expected, that ion packets coming out of TOF1 are shorter, than the same ion packet at the exit of the CID cell. The timed gate admits ions only at multiple narrow time windows, corresponding to arrival of parent ions. Such gating suppresses ion signal coming from chemical background and improves detection limit. Gate operation may also be used to enhance separation of pair of parent ions of close mass by sacrificing sensitivity. Several sets of MS-Ms data are acquired, while timed gate admits only one parent mass of a pair at a time.
0033Having described a general method for the purpose of clarity, the detailed embodiments will be first discussed on the level of individual components and only then presented as examples of integrated TOF-TOF apparatus. Though some employed components are well known in the art, their configuration and parameters are altered to suit purposes of the invention. To understand selected compromises, let us first look at major challenges in TOF-TOF method and apparatus.
0034The method of the invention is highly counterintuitive, since it would be referred as undoable for multiple reasons. One of ordinary skill in the art would contend that: TOF1 resolution would be extremely low, since ion energy spread in the source is comparable to ion energy in the TOF1; TOF1 resolution would also suffer because of a large turn around time (time spread, caused by initial velocity spread) in a weak accelerating field; ion losses through the TOF1 are expected to be devastating, because of expected large length of TOF1, and because of high divergence of slow ion beam in the TOF1; ion losses are expected to be even higher, since vacuum stage of TOF1 and gas the filled CID cell should be separated by a small aperture; and it also looks unlikely to have quick transmission through the CID cell in the time scale of 10 to 100µs. Most existing CID cells have time spreads on the order of 200 to 10,000µs. None of the available commercial data acquisition systems currently employed in TOF technology is capable of handling expected data flow rate.
0035These are mostly concentrated around TOF1 and arise from knowledge on existing TOF mass spectrometers, operating at high energy. The inventor has realized that multiple schemes of TOF1 are capable of slow separation with moderate resolution. In some of the embodiments, improvement of TOF1 resolution is made by employing an ion mirror with quadratic potential distribution, known to compensate for energy spread. The phenomenon is similar to elastic oscillations, where period does not depend on oscillation amplitude. Quadratic fields are well explored in TOF art-for example, see <nplcit id="ncit0004" npl-type="s"><text>Makarov et. al. in Int. J. of Mass Spectrom. and Ion Processes, v.146/147, 1995, pp. 165-182</text></nplcit>. Unfortunately, such analyzers also introduce a large beam-divergence. The inventor also realized that low energy TOF could be improved by introducing a radio frequency confinement of the ion beam in at least one direction. RF confinement reduces ion beam divergence and also reduces surface charging, crucial for low energy apparatuses. A novel type of TOF has been found, combining RF confinement with axial DC quadratic potential.
0036Referring to <figref idref="f0002">Fig. 3</figref>, the preferred embodiment of novel low energy time-of-flight separator 31 comprises an RF-only multipole 32, two electrostatic mirrors 33 and pulse generators 34. Mirrors are constructed of multiple electrodes, interconnected with a chain of dividing resistors 35. External electrodes of mirrors 33 are connected to pulse generators 34 with the middle electrode of mirrors 33 being ground. The end field is terminated by apertures 36, with the potential adjusted as a portion of full potential on pulse generators 34.
0037In operation, the RF field provides a radial confinement, shown by arrows 37 on <figref idref="f0002">Fig. 3</figref>. Radial RF confinement does not affect ion motion along the axis. Axial parabolic electric field is formed by field penetration between multipole rods. The parabolic field provides ion axial reflections with a period, grossly independent on ion energy and proportional to square root of ion m/z. Pulsing potentials on the mirror ends allows switching between ion injection into TOF1, ion reflections 39 within TOF1 and subsequent ion release on the other end of TOF1. The effective flight path L1<sub>EFF</sub> is approximately Nπ+1 times higher than TOF1 length L, where N is a number of full turns. Overall, RF confinement and multiple reflections allow prolonged time separation without ion losses, while quadratic potential enhances TOF1 resolution and allows separation of a slow ion beam with a high relative energy spread.
0038The ideal quadratic scheme is altered by presence of free flight segment on the way in and the way out of TOF1. According to above cited publication by Makarov et. al., even in the case of substantial field free flight, here c.a. 30% of LI<sub>EFF</sub>, a mass resolution of 2000 is achievable for ion pulses with relative energy spread up to 50%. To keep free flight path below 0.3L1<sub>EFF</sub>, the scheme requires at least 5 reflections, corresponding to 2 full turns. It helps to increase L1<sub>EFF</sub> to 7.3L but reduces mass range of parent ions to a factor of two, i.e. M<sub>MAx</sub>/M<sub>MIN</sub>≤2.
0039Referring to <figref idref="f0002">Fig. 4</figref>, another viable embodiment of a novel, low energy, time-of-flight separator 41 comprises an RF channel 42, surrounded by a set of electrostatic electrodes 43, terminating electrodes 44, and a deflector 45. The RF channel is formed by multiple rods 46 with alternating RF phase and aligned along the Y -axis. Electrodes of electrostatic mirrors 43, are also aligned along the Y-axis, and are connected via a chain of dividing resistors 47.
0040In operation, rods 46 with alternating RF potential form an RF tunnel, confining ions in the Z direction. The potential on electrodes 43, 44 is distributed by a resistor chain to form quadratic potential along the X-axis with minimum at the center plane of TOF. Field of external DC electrodes penetrates into the RF channel, providing a weaker but still quadratic potential distribution. Not accounting for fringing fields there is no field in the Y direction. Ions are injected at a small angle to the X-axis and are deflected by deflection plates 45 to double deflection angle for ions with mean energy. The deflection reduces Y-spatial spread, caused by X-energy spread. Ion motion is a combined slow drift along the Y direction and of multiple reflections along the X direction. Overall, ion trajectories have a wave shape, ending at the boundary of the RF tunnel. Ions gain some spatial spread at the exit of TOF, which is partially compensated by ion post-acceleration and focusing by a lens.
0041According to SIMION simulations by the inventor, even at a 50% energy spread the 50x30cm device allows N= 4 to 5 pairs of reflections without mixing ions with adjacent turns. The effective flight path of the device approximately equals L*π*N, and reaches L1<sub>EFF</sub>=7.5m. The RF field does not limit TOF1 resolution up to R=1000. Obviously a second type of TOF1, which may be called RF confined W-shape TOF, provides a simpler operation and longer flight path in TOF1, thus improving separation in TOF1, mostly limited by ratio of flight time between two TOF analyzers. The complexity of TOF1 could be reduced by using printed circuit board (PCB) assembly.
0042In both of the described TOF mass separators, the period of each reflection is grossly independent of ion energy and is proportional to the square root of the ion m/z. Ions are confined by the RF field and ion losses are practically eliminated. Introduction of the novel low-energy TOF analyzers makes the present invention practical, resolving the above-mentioned objections: a) The high relative energy spread is compensated by quadratic distribution of potential in the ion mirror, created by a DC electric field penetration into multipole guide or tunnel; b) Because of the TOF1 ability to operate at high relative energy spread, it can operate at much lower ion energy and at a much longer time scale, compared to conventional TOF. As a result, the apparatus tolerates a much longer ion pulse out of the ion source, and turn around time is no longer an obstacle; c) Drastic difference in time scales of TOF1 and TOF2 allows time-nested data acquisition; d) Ion losses are practically avoided by guiding ions within the radio-frequency guide or tunnel; e) Ion confinement by the RF field and ion post-acceleration in-front of the CID cell allow full transmission of the ion beam into the CID cell; f) Time spread in the CID cell is reduced by using a short, high pressure cell with an additional axial DC field, and g) Transient recorder with a large and fast averaging memory has been recently introduced by Swiss company Acquiris (www.acquiris.com).
0043The detailed description continues on the level of individual components: pulsed ion sources, fragmentation cell and TOF2, specifically tailored for purposes of the method and apparatus of the invention. Particular attention will be paid to the issue of time spread.
0044Referring to <figref idref="f0003">Fig. 5</figref>, the TOF-TOF method and apparatus of this invention employs a pulsed MALDI ion source 51, comprising a source housing 52, a sample plate 53 with analyzed sample 54, a pulsed laser 55, a low voltage power supply 54, and an exit aperture 56.
0045In operation, samples for analysis are prepared within matrices known in the art, and deposited on the sample plate 53. The pulsed laser 55 illuminates the sample and generates a short pulse of analyte ions. Ions are known to be ejected with a 300 to 600m/s velocity, which corresponds to initial ion energy between .5 and 1.5 eV for 1kD ion. The ions are accelerated by a few Volts potential bias. One can estimate, that 1kD of ions leave the ion source with few microseconds time spread and less than 1 eV energy spread. The major drawback of a vacuum MALDI ion source is ion temporal instability, well described in conventional, high energy MALDI. The invention is likely to be applicable to softer MALDI ion sources, employing soft matrices or an infra-red laser. Temporal stability of ions is improved by the collisional cooling, described below.
0046Referring to <figref idref="f0003">Fig. 6</figref>, the TOF-TOF method and apparatus of the invention employs a gas-filled pulsed MALDI ion source 61. The source 61 comprises features of the vacuum MALDI source, such as a source housing 62, a sample plate 63 with analyzed sample 64, a pulsed laser 65, a low voltage power supply 66, and an aperture 67A. The source 61 also comprises a gas inlet 68, feeding gas into the housing 62, and an additional pumping stage 69, terminated by exit aperture 67B to reduce a gas load on TOF1 pump.
0047In operation, the source housing 62 is filled with a buffer gas via the gas inlet 67. Gas pressure in the source housing is sustained between .01 to 1torr to provide ion collisional cooling (see Verentchikov et al., ASMS Conference 1999 in www.asms.org). A differential pumping system with two 1mm apertures 67A, B and two conventional 2501/s turbo pumps (one pumping TOF1), sustains vacuum in TOF1 better than 1E-6torr. The laser pulse generates a rapid (1 to 3ns) ion ejection from the sample. The laser 65 is a high-energy laser to enhance ion production. Collisions with the buffer gas relax ion internal energy. Collisions with the gas also dampen ion kinetic energy to nearly thermal energy -0.01 to 0.1 eV, still retaining pulse property of ion beam. Ions are sampled by gas flow through the aperture, assisted by c.a. 1V DC bias on the sample plate. Ions are then accelerated to the required kinetic energy, controlled by DC bias between apertures 67A, B, and leave the ion source. Internally cold ions are stable and survive long separation in TOF1 without ion decomposition. Overall, gas dampening in the MALDI source benefits TOF-TOF method of present invention, while leaving time and energy spread within boundaries 10µs and 1 eV, feasible for slow TOF1 separation.
0048Referring to <figref idref="f0003">Fig. 7</figref>, the TOF-TOF method and apparatus of the invention uses a pulsed ion source 71, comprising a continuous ion source with soft ionization 72 with an exit aperture 73, and a gas filled RF trapping device 74, enclosed in an additional pumping stage 75. The continuous ion source may be one of the following: electrospray (ESI), APCI, gas filled MALDI, PI or CI. The trapping device may be one of the following: 3-D Paul trap, linear RF -only multipole with axial ejection, curved RF multipole with radial ejection. The preference is given to linear quadrupole ion trap with axial ejection. When used, the quadrupole 74 is surrounded by DC electrodes 76 and apertures 73, 77.
0049In operation, the quadrupole is filled with buffer gas at 1 to 100mtorr pressure. Differential pumping system 75 reduces gas load on TOF1 pumping. Ions are generated in the ion source 72 and continuously fill the RF-only quadrupole ion guide 74. Gas collisions dampen ion kinetic energy and confine ions along the quadrupole axis and at the bottom of a DC well created by electrodes 76 and aperture 77. Periodically, a potential on electrodes 76 and exit aperture 77 are adjusted to eject the stored ions in the axial direction into TOF1. This construction produces an ion pulse having less than 1eV energy spread and less than 10µs time spread.
0050A desired TOF1 mass resolving power of 300 to 500, sufficient to separate a group of isotopes, requires a 600 to 1000 time-of-flight resolving power. For 10µs initial time spread and time-of-flight resolving power of 1000, the flight time for 1kD of ions has to be at least 10ms, achievable at few electron-Volts of ion energy and an effective flight path from 5 to 10m. The above described multi-tum TOF1 analyzers provide a 10m effective path within a .5 to 1m device. The next logical question is whether ions could be fragmented within a few tenths of microseconds, so that primary separation would not be ruined.
0051Referring to <figref idref="f0004">Fig. 8</figref>, the TOF-TOF method employs a short, high gas pressure CID cell 81 for ion fragmentation. The CID cell 81 comprises a vacuum housing 82, an entrance lens 83, a CID chamber 84 connected to a gas inlet 85, an RF focusing device 86 with optional DC electrodes 87, enclosed in the CID chamber, and exit ion lens 88. The CID cell also comprises an optional timed ion selection gate 89. The gas inlet feeds buffer gas into CID chamber. The CID chamber 83 comprises apertures 83A, B. The vacuum housing 82 comprises apertures 82A, B, and vacuum pump 82C. The RF focusing device is preferably a RF-only quadrupole.
0052Conventional CID cells, typically 10 to 20cm long, operate at c.a. 10mtorr gas pressure. In order to provide rapid ion transfer, the CID cell, employed in the present invention, is much shorter, typically 5 to 10mm, and operates at a much higher gas pressure, above 300mtorr. A high-pressure region is concentrated in the chamber 84 and is surrounded by an additional layer of differential pumping. Apertures 84A, B, typically 1.5mm diameter, limit total gas flow into the vacuum housing to c.a. 0.1torr*L/s. Pump 82C with pumping speed of 300L/s evacuates vacuum housing to c.a. 3E-4torr. Apertures 82A, B, typically 1.5mm diameter, further reduce gas flow into TOF1 and TOF2, operating at a gas pressure below 3E-7torr. To avoid gas discharge, the RF amplitude is preferably reduced below 300V peak to peak, preferably accompanied by a frequency drop below 1MHz.
0053In operation, ions are accelerated in- front of the cell to an energy sufficient for ion fragmentation, typically 50 eV/kDa. Ion packets enter the cell via apertures 82A and 84A and are focused by lens 83. At 300mtorr gas pressure, gas density equals n=1E+22m<sup>-3</sup>, and an ion of 1kDa mass with a cross section of σ=100 Å<sup>2</sup> has a mean free path λ=1/nσ=0.1mm. For a typical quadrupole length of L=1cm, ions experience c.a. 100 collisions. Number of collisions, 3 times higher than ion/gas mass ratio, is sufficient to ensure fragmentation with subsequent dampening. First energetic collisions convert ion kinetic energy into ion heating, causing ion fragmentation. Once ions lose kinetic energy, subsequent gas collisions stabilize the fragment ions, further dampen their kinetic energy and confine ions to the axis due to the RF field focusing. The phenomenon of collision dampening is well described in <patcit id="pcit0018" dnum="US4963736A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 4,963,736 by D. Douglas and J. French</text></patcit>.
0054Time spread of the ion beam in the CID cell is of significant concern in the present invention. Travel time before the high pressure region is assumed while tuning TOF1, and it creates a time delay only, not a time spread. Gas collisions can cause a significant time spread even in a short CID cell. To reduce the spread, ion passage through the cell is assisted by an electrostatic axial field, created by DC potentials at apertures 84A, B. At a typical quadrupole inscribed diameter D=1cm and length L=1cm, fringing fields penetrate into the RF quadrupole, being suppressed by a factor less than 2. Accelerating potential of 20V can provide ion drag through gas at velocity c.a. 500m/s, limiting full passage time below 20µs and time spread below 10µs. Controlling the passage time helps to bunch the ions (i.e. compress duration of ion pulse) prior to injection into TOF2. The accelerating field in CID cell is modulated, being synchronized (with time shift) to TOF2 injection pulses.
0055Referring to <figref idref="f0004">Fig. 9</figref>, the TOF-TOF method and apparatus of the invention employ a fragmentation cell 91 with surface induced dissociation (SID) for ion fragmentation. The SID cell 91 comprises a bunching (temporal focusing), spatial focusing and steering lens 92, a probe 93, preferably coated with fluorocarbon mono- layer, a pulse generator 94, attached to the probe, and a DC accelerating column 95, surrounded by ground shield 96. The DC accelerating column comprises a mesh 97, connected to a pulse generator 98.
0056In operation, ion packets of time -separated parent ions are pulse accelerated to c.a. 50 eV/kDa specific energy, being bunched by a lens 92. Bunching, previously employed in magnet sector-TOF tandems, is known to compress ion packet duration below dT<1µs. The lens 92 focuses and steers parent ion packet 99 onto the center of the probe 93. Ion beam impinges the surface at some angle, say 45 degree. Medium energy collisions with fluorocarbon mono-layer surface are known to induce fragmentation of peptides and small molecular ions. Fragment ions bounce off the surface with c.a. 500 to 2000 m/s velocity, traveling less than 2mm within dT<1µs of primary ion packet duration. During impinging a small retarding potential is applied to the mesh 97, preventing leakage of fragment ions into the TOF2 analyzer. After an appropriate delay, corresponding to impinging of the entire primary ion packet, pulse generators 94 and 98 are triggered, and electric pulses are applied to the probe 93 and the mesh 97. Fragment ions are pulse accelerated into the TOF2 analyzer.
0057Compared to the CID cell, the SID cell has the advantages of: operating at low pressure and thus reducing requirements on pumping system; removing time spread in fragmentation step; and accepting wider beam of primary ions.
0058Disadvantages of SID are: poorly characterized fragmentation pattern of medium mass ions; higher energy spread of fragment ions reducing TOF2 resolution; and metastable decay of fragment ions in TOF2 analyzer. The CID cell is better suited for in-line TOF1, while SID cell is better suited for W-TOF1.
0059Referring to <figref idref="f0004">Fig. 10</figref>, the TOF-TOF method and apparatus of the invention employ a conventional orthogonal TOF 101 for mass analysis of fragment ions, preferably in conjunction with the CID cell. The o-TOF 101 comprises an orthogonal pulse accelerator 102, an ion mirror 103, a floating free-flight region 104, a TOF detector 105 and an in-line detector 106. Both detectors are connected to a data acquisition system, comprising a fast averaging transient recorder 107. TOF analyzer 101 is enclosed within a vacuum chamber 108 and is evacuated by a pump 109.
0060Operation of o-TOF is well described in the art. A continuous or pulsed ion beam, accelerated to c.a. 10 eV, enters the acceleration region. Periodic pulses accelerate the ions orthogonal to c.a. 3keV and inject them into the TOF analyzer. Ions get reflected in the ion mirror and hit the TOF detector 105. A portion of initial ion beam is acquired on the in-line detector 106. To accommodate rapid analysis of fragment ions, parameters of the o-TOF are slightly altered. The analyzer is small - L=10 to 20cm, operates at high TOF energy (5 to 15kV) to accommodate high repetition rate, c.a. 100KHz. A small size analyzer allows operation at gas pressure slightly below 1E-5torr. The conventional TOF analyzer is also modified by using high current secondary electron multiplier (SEM) or hybrid MCP/PEM for detector and by using a fast averaging transient recorder for data acquisition system. Small length and short flight time pose a limit on TOF2 resolution. To improve resolution of TOF2, one can increase the flight time in TOF2, while limiting the time windows of admitted ions by one of: 10µs time gate interleaved between IMS scans and use slower pulse rate of TOF2; pulse TOF2 at 100KHz rate and divert ions within TOF2 onto several detectors; pulse TOF2 at 100KHz rate and use position sensitive detector in TOF2. TOF2 is optionally equipped with in-line detector in order to avoid acquiring signal in blank time, when no ions are coming from TOF1.
0061Referring to <figref idref="f0004">Fig. 11</figref>, the TOF-TOF method also employs a conventional reflecting TOF 111 for mass analysis of fragment ions, preferably in conjunction with the SID cell. The TOF 111 comprises a built-in SID cell 91, an electrically floated free flight region 112, a detector 114 with a detector shield 113, an ion mirror 115, a vacuum housing 116, a pump 117 and a transient recorder 118 for data acquisition..
0062In operation, a pulse of fragment ions is accelerated within the SID cell 91, fly through the field free region 112, are reflected in the ion mirror 115 and hit the detector 114. Ion trajectories are shown by lines 119. The signal from the detector is acquired on the transient recorder 118. Again, for the purposes of rapid data acquisition the analyzer is relatively short, L=10 to 20cm, and operates at high acceleration potential to accommodate a high repetition rate of 100KHz.
0063Having described individual components, it becomes easier to grasp the concept and peculiarities of the integrated TOF-TOF method and apparatus. Below find specific examples of TOF-TOF tandems of the invention, though, not limiting a multiplicity of viable combinations.
0064Referring to <figref idref="f0005">Fig. 12</figref>, one preferred embodiment of TOF-TOF instrument 121 comprises a sequentially connected pulsed source 71 with a continuous ion source 72, a storage quadrupole 74 and electrodes 76, 77, an in-line time-of-flight mass spectrometer TOF1 31 with an RF-only quadrupole guide 32, surrounded by two pulsed ion mirrors 33A, B, a short gas-filled collision CID cell 81 with an RF quadrupole 86, surrounded by apertures 84A, B and the second, orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometer o-TOF2 101 with a pulse accelerator 102, equipped with an analog data acquiring system 107. Individual components have been described above and are shown on <figref idref="f0002">Figs. 3</figref>, <figref idref="f0003">7</figref>, <figref idref="f0004">8 and 10</figref>, and their previous numbers are retained in further discussion.
0065In operation, continuous ion source 71 feeds parent ions into the storage quadrupole 74. Once every 10 to 20ms ions are ejected from the storage quadrupole by pulsing potentials on DC electrodes 76 and exit aperture 77. An ejected ion packet containing a multiplicity of different parent ions is less than 10µs long and has less than 1 eV energy spread. Mean energy of the ejected ion pulse is adjusted to c.a. 2 eV by selecting pulse potentials on electrodes 76 and 77. Ions are admitted into the TOF1 separator by dropping the potential of the first mirror 33A. Ions are radially trapped by the quadrupole RF field but are free to travel along the quadrupole axis. Once parent ions of all masses (limited to the ratio Mmax/Mmin=2) pass the first mirror, the first mirror 33A is turned on. The second mirror 33B has been turned on within the previous cycle. The ions experience multiple reflections, preferably 5 reflections, between the two mirrors with quadratic potential distribution along the TOF1 axis. The period of oscillation is grossly independent on ion energy and is proportional to the square root of parent ion mass. The effective flight path of the analyzer is up to 2π+1α = 7.3 times longer than the physical length of TOF1. After the preferred numbers of reflections (preferably 5) ions are released out of TOF1 by lowering the potential of the second mirror 33B. The train of time -separated ion -packets enters the CID cell. A typical time scale of time separation is on the order of 10ms, measured as a flight time of 1kDa ions, and the duration of each packet, corresponding to parent ion mass, is approximately 10µs. Parent ions are separated with c.a. 1000 time resolution, corresponding to 500 mass resolution.
0066After leaving TOF1, each ion packet is accelerated to a specific energy of 50 eV/kDa, sufficient to induce fragmentation in gas collisions. Ions are focused by a lens system and injected into high pressure CID cell via aperture 82A and 84A. The ions fragment in the cell, and fragment ions are collision -dampened and confined by an RF field. The cell is actively emptied by pulsed potential of two CID apertures 84A, B, synchronous and time shifted relative to TOF2 pulses. Ions enter orthogonal acceleration region 102, get injected into TOF2 analyzer, being time separated and, thus, mass analyzed in TOF2. Synchronized injection into TOF2 eliminates time gaps, i.e. almost no fragments are lost between TOF2 pulses. Synchronous injection also improves the duty cycle of TOF2. Most of the fragment ions are contained within the acceleration region 102 at the time of TOF2 pulse.
0067TOF2 spectra present fragment spectra for every time -separated parent ion mass. Spectra with the same TOF1 tag (i.e., corresponding to parent ions of the same m/z) are summed over multiple source injections. Within 1 second of acquisition the data will contain 1000 fragment spectra, averaged over 100 source injections.
0068In the above described apparatus there are three almost equal (c.a.10µs) sources of time -spread, deteriorating resolution of TOF1 separation: time -spread gained in the ion source; time -spread in the CID cell and due to TOF2 digitization (i.e. acquiring spectra at discrete time). Assuming no correlation between those three sources, the overall time spread is estimated as 17µs (square root of three higher than each spread). The resulting resolution of TOF1 separation becomes equal to 300, which is still considered to be a fair resolution for parent -ion separation. For comparison, TOF1 resolution in commercial MALDI TOF-TOF is c.a. 100, and quadrupole resolution in Q-TOF in a high sensitive mode is c.a. 300. Resolution of TOF1 of the present invention can be potentially improved by one of the following means: increasing the length of TOF1 above 1m; optimizing ion energy within TOF1; applying a timed gate with multiple narrow mass windows, interleaved between scans; pulsing TOF2 faster and diverting ions onto several detectors; and using a position sensitive detector in TOF2.
0069Referring to <figref idref="f0006">Fig. 13</figref>, another preferred embodiment of a TOF-TOF apparatus of the invention comprises a gas-filled pulsed MALDI ion source 61, a W-shape TOF1 41, a SID cell 91 and a coaxial TOF2 111. The source 61 comprises a gas-filled chamber 62, a sample plate 63, a laser 65 and a low voltage bias supply 66, connected to the sample plate 63. The TOF1 41 comprises deflection plates 45, two static reflectors 43 with terminating plates 44, and a two-dimensional RF tunnel 42. Static reflectors 43 surround the RF channel 42 to form a quadratic potential distribution. The SID cell 91 comprises a bunching and focusing lens 92 and a probe 93, coated with fluorocarbon mono-layer. The TOF1 111 comprises a secondary electron multiplier-SEM 113, connected to a transient recorder 114. The source 61 and the SID cell 91 are located off-line to allow multiple ion reflections within TOF1 41. The above selected combination of elements is chosen mostly to demonstrate interaction between elements, not described in the previous TOF-TOF embodiment.
0070In operation, laser 65 pulses produce a short burst of primary ions off the sample plate 63 at a repetition rate of 50 to 100Hz. The source chamber 62 is filled with gas to relax ion internal energy and prevent ion decomposition. Ions are sampled through a thin gas layer by electric field and gas flow, so that each ion packet remains shorter than 10µs and has energy spread less than 1 eV. The ion packet is accelerated into the multi-reflecting TOF1 41 at a small angle to the Y axis by another few Volts of potential provided by low voltage bias supply 66. The steering plates 45 double the angle to reduce spatial spread in X direction, related to Y axis energy spread. Ion motion within TOF1 has three independent components - oscillation in confining RF field in Z-direction, multiple reflections along Y axis with a period almost independent on ion energy, and a slow drift along the orthogonal - X axis. After several Y bounces the ions leave TOF1 and enter the bunching lens 92 of the SID cell 91, being time separated into a train of ion packets and aligned according to their m/z ratio. Multiple reflections at a small ion -energy allow prolonged time separation in the order of 10ms. Since a quadratic DC field in TOF1 compensates for ion energy spread, separation in TOF1 does not increase the 10µs time spread of ion packets. Thus, after leaving TOF1 the parent ions are separated with a c.a. 300 to 500 mass resolution.
0071Periodically, say once in every 10µs, ions are time bunched into c.a. 1µs packets and spatially focused to c.a. 1mm by a pulsed lens 92. Pulse -focused ion - packets hit the surface of the SID probe 93 coated with a fluorocarbon mono-layer. Collisions with the surface induce ion fragmentation. Fragments, slowly moving from the surface, are spread for c.a. 1mm within 1µs time. A delayed electric pulse applied to the probe 93 accelerates the fragment ions and injects them into the second TOF2 111 analyzer. Initial parameters (i.e. parameters prior to the probe pulse) of fragment ions are good enough to carry mass analysis in TOF2 with resolution of couple thousand. A signal is detected on the SEM 114 with high dynamic range. Signal is passed to the transient recorder 113, and data are acquired in a time-nested fashion. TOF2 transients, representing fragment spectra of various parent ions, are not mixed together. Each fragment mass spectrum obtains a time tag of TOF1 separation, measured as a time between source pulse and bunching lens pulse. TOF1 time tags carry information on parent ion m/z ratio. TOF2 spectra with the same TOF1 time tag are averaged over multiple laser pulses to improve signal to noise ratio.
0072It is recognized that a comprehensive TOF-TOF method of the invention could be realized employing simpler static TOF1. Below find several examples of static separators. Retention of an ion beam in a static field requires operation at a relatively higher energy around 100-200 eV. Millisecond separation time is achieved by extending flight path and using focusing properties of specially designed electrostatic fields.
0073Referring to <figref idref="f0007">Fig. 14</figref>, another embodiment of a low -energy, time-of-flight separator 121 comprises an electrostatic lens 122, a deflector 123 and an analyzer, consisting of an entrance unit 124, two coaxial electrodes 125 and 126 with DC voltage applied between them, and exit unit 127, followed by deflector 128 and lens 129. The described device is known as a "spiratron" and is described in: <nplcit id="ncit0005" npl-type="s"><text>Bakker I.M.B., The Spiratron.-, In: Adv. In Mass Spectrom., London, 1971, v.5, pp. 278-280</text></nplcit>. The novelty is introduced by using the device as a low energy separator in tandem TOF system.
0074In operation, an ion beam from a pulsed ion source 71 is transformed by a lens 122 into a much wider beam with proportionally lower angular spread (a "quasi-parallel beam"). This beam is deflected by the deflector 123 to provide a controlled angle of inclination α relative to the axis of the electrodes 125 and 126. The same effect may be achieved, for example, by positioning electrodes 125 and 126 at a fixed angle. The ion beam would enter the electrostatic radial field between electrodes 125 and 126 via an aperture in the entrance unit 124. One preferred embodiment of the entrance unit 124 includes 3 double-sided printed-circuit boards (PCB). Outside surfaces of these boards would face deflector 123 and have metallization on them to create an equipotential surface. The opposite surfaces of these boards would face the gap between electrodes 125 and 126 and contain a set of metallization strips. These strips are connected to a resistive voltage divider that provides a voltage distribution matching the ideal logarithmic voltage distribution between electrodes 125 and 126 and thus minimizing perturbation of this field along ion trajectories. Exit unit 127 may have similar construction.
0075After the ions pass through entrance unit 124, they start moving along a spiral trajectory, wound around electrode 125, and separated in time-of-flight according to their mass-to-charge ratios. To minimize ion beam size, this spiral needs to be circular. This is achieved when voltage U between electrodes 125 and 126 corresponds to the mean ion energy V1 as defined by the equation <chemistry id="chem0001" num="0001"><img file="EP1522087B1_D0001.tif" /></chemistry> where r<sub>1</sub> and r<sub>2</sub> are the radii of electrodes 125 and 126, respectively. After a number of rotations, the ions exit the field through the exit unit 127, having drifted distance H along the axis. Construction of the exit unit 127 is similar to that of the injection unit 124. The maximum number of rotations is limited mainly by the full angular spread Δα of the ion beam (Δα<<1) that in turn is limited by the effective temperature of the initial ion beam kT: as defined by the equation <chemistry id="chem0002" num="0002"><img file="EP1522087B1_D0002.tif" /></chemistry> where M is magnification of lens 122 and coefficient p depends on the required confidence level (p<sup>~</sup>4 for 95% of ions, p<sup>~</sup>5 for 99% of ions, and p<sup>~</sup>6.6 for 99.9% of ions). The resolving power of the spiratron is limited both by the maximum number of rotations and the energy spread at the levels of 50-70. <chemistry id="chem0003" num="0003"><img file="EP1522087B1_D0003.tif" /></chemistry><chemistry id="chem0004" num="0004"><img file="EP1522087B1_D0004.tif" /></chemistry>
0076Though resolution is inferior, compared to above-described TOF1 spectrometers, the spiratron device has an advantage of simplicity, higher operation energy and it works without stroboscopic techniques prior to TOF2.
0077The novel static TOF1 can be coupled to any of above-described fragmentation systems and TOF2 spectrometers or fragment analysis. Referring to <figref idref="f0007">Fig. 14</figref> TOF1 121 is coupled to the CID cell 81 and the orthogonal TOF 101. The major challenge in this combination is to focus the primary beam onto the entrance of the CID cell. Though the ion beam has a high 100 eV energy and the beam gets wider at the exit, the beam is grossly parallel and can be well focused onto a small aperture by conventional lens.
0078Referring to <figref idref="f0008">Fig. 15</figref>, another embodiment of the first (i.e. TOF1) time-of-flight separator of the invention 151, also known as an 'electrostatic multi-pass separator', comprises a free flight channel 152, liner 153 and two electrostatic mirrors, composed of focusing electrodes 154, and reflector electrodes 155. The free flight channel 152 has entrance and exit windows 156. All electrodes are extended along the Y-axis such that the electrostatic field is two-dimensional in the area of the ion path. A pulsed ion beam is introduced into the multi-turn electrostatic TOF 151 via a spatial focusing lens 157 and a set of steering plates 158A, B. The path of the ions is shown by the line 159. A typical axial potential distribution U(x) is shown by the graph 160.
0079In operation, the ion pulse is focused into a parallel beam by lens 157 and is steered by plates 158A, B. The beam is introduced into the separator 151 via the entrance window 156 at a small angle to X -axis. The ions experience multiple reflections along the X-axis, while slowly drifting along Y -axis. After multiple full turns (each full turn is formed by a pair of reflections) the ions leave separator 151 through the exit window 157, being time separated according to their m/z ratio. The number of full turns, and therefore flight length, depends on the injection angle which is adjustable by potentials on the steering plates.
0080Electrostatic mirrors are designed similar to mirror in gridless TOF devices. Electrostatic potentials, applied to the mirror electrodes are tuned to satisfy conditions of spatial focusing and time-of-flight focusing. Graph 160 shows the type of axial potential distribution U(x), satisfying those requirements. To provide spatial focusing along Z direction, each of the electrostatic mirrors 153 forms a lens with a focal point, located near the center plane of the free flight region (shown by dashed line). The ion beam (line 159), starts as a parallel beam at the entrance window 156. After the first reflection in the right side mirror the beam is focused into a point at the middle plane. Note, that focusing of all ions is presented on the drawing by a single ion trajectory, intersecting the axis. After reflection in the left hand mirror, the beam is again converted into a parallel beam.
0081According to the inventor's ion optics simulation using SIMION program, the spatial focusing in the specific TOF1 151 is compatible with time-of-flight focusing in at least the first order, i.e., the first derivatives of flight time on the initial energy and on the orthogonal displacement are equal to zero. The ion beam remains confined if only initial spatial spread is under 5% of TOF1 width and angular spread is below 2 degrees. For energy spread under 3% the time of flight resolution of TOF1 exceeds 10,000. Such initial conditions are realistic for an ion beam accelerated to approximately ≥30 eV after pulse ejection out of linear storing quadrupole.
0082Operation at a relatively higher energy (30 to 100 eV), compared to other embodiments, requires a longer ion path in TOF1 (30 to 100m) to achieve a millisecond time scale separation in TOF1. The ion path could be easily extended because of the low complexity of TOF1 design and its static operation. An instrument of 1m length with an approximately 20 full ion turns corresponds to at least a 50m effective flight path.
0083Referring to <figref idref="f0009">Fig. 16</figref>, another embodiment of the invention utilizes a modified electrostatic multi-pass separator, formed by folding a two-dimensional field into a cylindrical field. In this embodiment, called a cylindrical multi-pass separator 161, for the purpose of compact design, each elongated electrode is converted into a pair of coaxial cylinders- -internal and external. The separator 161 comprises a free flight channel, formed by cylinders 162, 163, and two electrostatic mirrors, composed of focusing cylinders 164, and reflector cylinders 165. The external cylinder of free flight channel 162 has entrance and exit windows 166, equipped with beam deflector 170. A pulsed ion beam is introduced into separator 161 via a spatial focusing lens 167, a set of steering plates 168, through entrance window 166 and deflector 170. The ion path is shown by the line 169.
0084In operation, the cylindrical separator is very similar to the above-described two-dimensional electrostatic multi-pass separator. Ions are forced to make multiple bounces between mirrors, while being spatially focused by lens electrodes. In order to retain ions near same radius of orbit, an additional potential is applied between the external and internal cylinders 162 and 163. A radial deflecting potential could be also applied between the external and internal cylinders of electrodes 164 and 165.
0085The entrance and exit of ions can be organized in multiple ways. Fig. 16B shows an example of ion introduction through a slit-shaped window 166B with subsequent horizontal deflection, aligning ion beam along X-axis. To reduce fringing fields, the deflector 170B is surrounded by mesh. <figref idref="f0009">Fig. 16</figref> shows an example of ion introduction along X-axis through a segment cut-out in the entire cylindrical analyzer. A beam is injected into the analyzer after horizontal deflection by plates 170C. Field distortion is minimized by using double-sided PCB, equi-potential within cut-out and with distributed potentials on the side oriented towards cylindrical analyzer. The above - described electrostatic multi-pass separators are suggested for use in comprehensive tandem TOF spectrometer of the invention in variety of combinations with earlier described pulsed ion sources, fragmentation cell and fast TOF2.
0086Obviously, presented examples of TOF1 separators, including separators with RF confinement, spiratron and static multi-pass separators, do not exhaust all the possibilities of TOF1, providing prolonged time separation, while retaining ion beam, but rather prove the feasibility of the general method of comprehensive tandem TOF mass spectrometry of the invention.
<u>TOF1 BYPASS</u>
0087The tandem TOF spectrometers of the invention described above provide increased speed and sensitivity of analysis as compared to existing tandem TOF mass spectrometers. This improvement is achieved by employing the principle of time-nested acquisition, applied for the first time to tandem TOF. Ion pulses from the ion source are fully utilized and multiple parent ions are analyzed per single source pulse. The invention also improves the rate of MS-MS information, compared to the closest prototype-IMS-TOF also employing time-nested acquisition. The improvement is made by getting much higher resolution at the step of parent ion separation and thus, providing analysis of more complex mixtures.
0088The greater speed provided by tandem MS-MS analysis opens tremendous opportunities for coupling multi-step liquid-phase separations with tandem MS analysis at a realistic time scale. Such separation techniques may include ion-exchange separation, affinity separation, liquid phase chromatography (LC) and capillary electrophoresis (CE). High speed LC and CE separation in a short time scale became routine in LC-MS analysis. However, LC-MS-MS analysis, usually slowed down by low speed of MS-MS stage, is no longer the case after introducing the comprehensive TOF-TOF method and apparatus of the invention.
0089Having described the different embodiments of the invention along with some examples of combining useful elements, it will now become apparent for one skilled in the art that other embodiments incorporating the concepts may be used. It is felt, therefore, that these embodiments should not be limited to disclosed embodiments, but rather should be limited only by the scope of the following claims.
13 sheets
Sheet 1 Sheet 2 Sheet 3 Sheet 4 Sheet 5 Sheet 6 Sheet 7 Sheet 8 Sheet 9 Sheet 10 Sheet 11 Sheet 12 Sheet 13
Every citation, both ways
| Document | Relation | Office | Cited during |
|---|---|---|---|
| US11881387B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11367608B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11342175B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11081332B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11295944B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11239067B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US12205813B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11587779B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11309175B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11328920B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US10950425B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11049712B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11756782B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11211238B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11205568B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11621156B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11817303B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US6323482B1 | Cites | United States of America | Examiner |
| WO9901889A | Cites | World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) | – |
| US6323482B1 | Cites | United States of America | – |
| HENDERSON S.C. ET AL: 'ESI/ION TRAP/ION MOBILITY/TIME-OF-FLIGHT MASS SPECTROMETRY FOR RAPID AND SENSITIVE ANALYSIS OF BIOMOLECULAR MIXTURES' ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY, US LNKD- DOI:10.1021/AC9809175 vol. 71, no. 2, 15 January 1999, pages 291 - 301, XP000917830 ISSN: 0003-2700 | Non-patent | – | – |
| HENDERSON S.C. ET AL: "ESI/ION TRAP/ION MOBILITY/TIME-OF-FLIGHT MASS SPECTROMETRY FOR RAPID AND SENSITIVE ANALYSIS OF BIOMOLECULAR MIXTURES", ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY, US LNKD- DOI:10.1021/AC9809175, vol. 71, no. 2, 15 January 1999 (1999-01-15), pages 291 - 301, XP000917830, ISSN: 0003-2700 | Non-patent | – | Examiner |
18 members in 11 offices
Priority claims3
| Document | Office | Kind | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0216438 | United Kingdom | – | |
| 0216438 | United Kingdom | A | |
| 0313262 | United States of America | W |
Members18
| Document | Office | Kind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| GB0216438D0 | United Kingdom | D0 | |
| GB2390935A | United Kingdom | A | |
| CA2492808A1 | Canada | A1 | |
| WO2004008481A1 | World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) | A1 | |
| AU2003228749A1 | Australia | A1 | |
| EP1522087A1 | European Patent Office (EPO) | A1 | |
| KR20050056937A | Republic of Korea | A | |
| CN1689134A | China | A | |
| US2005242279A1 | United States of America | A1 | |
| JP2005538346A | Japan | A | |
| US7196324B2 | United States of America | B2 | |
| US2007187585A1 | United States of America | A1 | |
| JP4435682B2 | Japan | B2 | |
| CN1689134B | China | B | |
| EP1522087B1This record | European Patent Office (EPO) | B1 | |
| AT501522T | Austria | T | |
| ATE501522T1 | Austria | T1 | |
| DE60336318D1 | Germany | D1 |
50 legal events, as 7 offices reported them to INPADOC
Over the term
Point at a mark for the eventEvents
| Event | Code | Office | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expiry of rightR071 | R071 | DE | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| No opposition filed against granted patent, or epo opposition proceedings concluded without decisionGrantedR097 | R097 | DE | |
| Gb: european patent ceased through non-payment of renewal feeCeasedGBPC | GBPC | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| No opposition filedOpposition26N | 26N | EP | |
| Patent lapsedLapsedMM4A | MM4A | IE | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Notification of lapseLapsedST | ST | FR | |
| No opposition filed within time limitOppositionORIGINAL CODE: 0009261PLBE | PLBE | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: NO OPPOSITION FILED WITHIN TIME LIMITSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Patent ceasedCeasedPL | PL | CH | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Discontinued in the netherlands as no translation has been filedVDEP | VDEP | NL | |
| Dpma publication of mentioned ep patent grantGrantedR096 | R096 | DE | |
| Corresponds to:REF | REF | EP | |
| European patents granted designating irelandGrantedFG4D | FG4D | IE | |
| European patent takes effect as a national patent in ch/liEP | EP | CH | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | EP | |
| European patent grantedGrantedFG4D | FG4D | GB | |
| (expected) grantORIGINAL CODE: 0009210GRAA | GRAA | EP | |
| Grant fee paidORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR3GRAS | GRAS | EP | |
| Despatch of communication of intention to grant a patentORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR1GRAP | GRAP | EP | |
| First examination report despatched17Q | 17Q | EP | |
| Request for examination filed17P | 17P | EP | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | EP | |
| Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phaseORIGINAL CODE: 0009012PUAI | PUAI | EP |
Numbers
- Publication
- 1522087
- Application
- 37265188
Titles3
- German
- TANDEM FLUZEITMASSENSPEKTROMETER UND VERFAHREN
- English
- TANDEM TIME OF FLIGHT MASS SPECTROMETER AND METHOD OF USE
- French
- SPECTROMETRE DE MASSE A TEMPS DE VOL EN TANDEM ET PROCEDE D'UTILISATION ASSOCIE
Classification
- CPC, 3
- H01J49/406
- H01J49/004
- G01N27/623
- IPC, 4
- H01J49 40
- G01N27 62
- H01J49 06
- H01J49 10
Designated states27
- Contracting states, 27
- Austria
- Belgium
- Bulgaria
- Switzerland
- Cyprus
- Czechia
- Germany
- Denmark
- Estonia
- Spain
- Finland
- France
- United Kingdom
- Greece
- Hungary
- Ireland
- Italy
- Liechtenstein
- Luxembourg
- Monaco
- Netherlands (Kingdom of the)
- Portugal
- Romania
- Sweden
and 3 moreShow fewer
- Slovenia
- Slovakia
- Türkiye