Process for producing single wall nanotubes using unsupported metal catalysts

<u style="single">BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION</u>

<u style="single">Field of the Invention</u>

This invention relates to a method for producing single wall carbon nanotubes, also known as linear fullerenes, employing unsupported metal containing catalysts, for decomposition of a C₁ to C₆ carbon feedstock such as carbon monoxide.

<u style="single">Description of the Related Art</u>

Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes

Multi-walled carbon nanotubes, or fibrils, are well-known. Typically, carbon fibrils have a core region comprising a series of graphitic layers of carbon.

Since the 1970's, carbon nanotubes and fibrils have been identified as materials of interest for a variety of applications. Submicron graphitic fibrils belong to a class of materials sometimes called vapor grown carbon fibers. Carbon fibrils are vermicular carbon deposits having diameters less than approximately 1.0µ. They exist in a variety of forms and have been prepared through the catalytic decomposition of various carbon-containing gases at metal surfaces. Such vermicular carbon deposits have been observed almost since the advent of electron microscopy. A good early survey and reference is found in <nplcit id="ncit0001" npl-type="b"><text>Baker and Harris, Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, Walker and Thrower ed., Vol. 14, 1978, p. 83</text></nplcit>, and in <nplcit id="ncit0002" npl-type="s"><text>Rodriguez, N., J. Mater. Research, Vol. 8, p. 3233 (1993</text></nplcit>).

Carbon fibrils were seen to originate from a metal catalyst particle which, in the presence of a hydrocarbon containing gas, became supersaturated in carbon. A cylindrical ordered graphitic core is extruded which immediately became coated with an outer layer of pyrolytically deposited graphite. These fibrils with a pyrolytic overcoat typically have diameters in excess of 0.1µ. (<nplcit id="ncit0003" npl-type="s"><text>Obelm, A. and Endo, M., J. Crystal Growth, 32:335-349(1976)</text></nplcit>.)

Tibbetts has described the formation of straight carbon fibers through pyrolysis of natural gas at temperatures of 950°-1075° C., <nplcit id="ncit0004" npl-type="s"><text>Appl. Phys. Lett. 42(8):666(18\983</text></nplcit>). The fibers are reported to grow in two stages where the fibers first lengthen catalytically and then thicken by pyrolytic deposition of carbon. Tibbetts reports that these stages are "overlapping", and is unable to grow filaments free of pyrolytically deposited carbon. In addition, Tibbett's approach is commercially impracticable for at least two reasons. First, initiation of fiber growth occurs only after slow carbonization of the steel tube (typically about ten hours), leading to a low overall-rate of fiber production. Second, the reaction tube is consumed in the fiber forming process, making commercial scale-up difficult and expensive.

In 1983, Tennent, <patcit id="pcit0001" dnum="US4663230A"><text>U.S. Patent No. 4,663,230</text></patcit> succeeded in growing cylindrical ordered graphite cores, uncontaminated with pyrolytic carbon, resulting in smaller diameter fibrils, typically 35 to 700 Å (0.0035 to 0.070µ), and an ordered "as grown" graphitic surface. Tennent '230 describes carbon fibrils free of a continuous thermal carbon overcoat and having multiple graphitic outer layers that are substantially parallel to the fibril axis. They may be characterized as having their c-axes, (the axes which are perpendicular to the tangents of the curved layers of graphite) substantially perpendicular to their cylindrical axes, and having diameters no greater than 0.1µ and length to diameter ratios of at least 5.

Tennent, et al., <patcit id="pcit0002" dnum="US5171560A"><text>US Patent No. 5,171,560</text></patcit> describes carbon fibrils free of thermal overcoat and having graphitic layers substantially parallel to the fibril axes such that the projection of said layers on said fibril axes extends for a distance of at least two fibril diameters. Typically, such fibrils are substantially cylindrical, graphitic nanotubes of substantially constant diameter and comprise cylindrical graphitic sheets whose c-axes are substantially perpendicular to their cylindrical axis. They are substantially free of pyrolytically deposited carbon, have a diameter less than 0.1µ, and a length to diameter ratio of greater than 5.

Moy et al., <patcit id="pcit0003" dnum="US88730792A" dnum-type="L"><text>USSN 07/887,307 filed May 22, 1992</text></patcit>, describes fibrils prepared as aggregates having various macroscopic morphologies (as determined by scanning electron microscopy) including morphologies resembling bird nests ("BN"), combed yarn ("CY") or "open net" ("ON") structures.

Multi-walled carbon nanotubes of a morphology similar to the catalytically grown fibrils described above have been grown in a high temperature carbon arc (<nplcit id="ncit0005" npl-type="s"><text>Iijima, Nature 354 56 1991</text></nplcit>). (Iijima also describes arc-grown single-walled nanotubes having only a single layer of carbon arranged in the form of a linear Fullerene.) It is now generally accepted (<nplcit id="ncit0006" npl-type="s"><text>Weaver, Science 265 1994</text></nplcit>) that these arc-grown nanofibers have the same morphology as the earlier catalytically grown fibrils of Tennent.

Single-walled carbon Nanotubes

As mentioned above, the Iijima method partially results in single-walled nanotubes, i.e., nanotubes having only a single layer of carbon arranged in the form of a linear Fullerene.

<patcit id="pcit0004" dnum="US5424054A"><text>United States Patent No. 5,424,054</text></patcit> to Bethune et al. describes a process for producing single-walled carbon nanotubes by contacting carbon vapor with cobalt catalyst. The carbon vapor is produced by electric arc heating of solid carbon, which can be amorphous carbon, graphite, activated or decolorizing carbon or mixtures thereof. Other techniques of carbon heating are discussed, for instance laser heating, electron beam heating and RF induction heating.

Smalley (<nplcit id="ncit0007" npl-type="s"><text>Guo, T., Nikoleev, P., Thess, A., Colbert, D.T., and Smally, R.E., Chem. Phys. Lett. 243: 1-12 (1995)</text></nplcit>) describes a method of producing single-walled carbon nanotubes wherein graphite rods and a transition metal are simultaneously vaporized by a high-temperature laser.

Smalley (<nplcit id="ncit0008" npl-type="s"><text>Thess, A., Lee, R., Nikolaev, P., Dai, H., Petit, P., Robert, J., Xu, C., Lee, Y.H., Kim, S.G., Rinzler, A.G., Colbert, D.T., Scuseria, G.E., Tonárek, D., Fischer, J.E., and Smalley, R.E., Science, 273: 483-487 (1996)</text></nplcit>) also describes a process for production of single-walled carbon nanotubes in which a graphite rod containing a small amount of transition metal is laser vaporized in an oven at about -1200°C. Single-wall nanotubes were reported to be produced in yields of more than 70%.

Each of the techniques described above employs (1) solid carbon as the carbon feedstock. These techniques are inherently disadvantageous. Specifically, solid carbon vaporization via electric arc or laser apparatus is costly and difficult to operate on the commercial or industrial scale.

Supported metal catalysts for formation of SWNT are also known. Smalley (<nplcit id="ncit0009" npl-type="s"><text>Dai., H., Rinzler, A.G., Nikolaev, P., Thess, A., Colbert, D.T., and Smalley, R.E., Chem. Phys. Lett. 260: 471-475 (1996</text></nplcit>)) describes supported Co, Ni and Mo catalysts for growth of both multi-walled nanotubes and single-walled nanotubes from CO, and a proposed mechanism for their formation.

However, supported metal catalysts are inherently disadvantageous, as the support is necessarily incorporated into the single-walled carbon nanotube formed therefrom. Single-walled nanotubes contaminated with the support material are obviously less desirable compared to single-walled nanotubes not having such contamination.

OBJECTS OF THE INVENTION

It is thus an object of the present invention to provide a method of producing single-walled carbon nanotubes which employs a gaseous carbon feedstock.

It is an object of this invention to provide a method of producing single-walled carbon nanotubes which employs a gas phase, metal containing compound which forms a metal containing catalyst.

It is also an object of the invention to provide a method of producing single-walled carbon nanotubes which employs an unsupported catalyst.

It is a further object of this invention to provide a method of producing single-walled carbon nanotubes which employs a gaseous carbon feedstock and an unsupported gas phase metal containing compound which forms a metal containing catalyst.

SUMMARY OF INVENTION

The invention relates to a gas phase reaction in which a gas phase metal containing compound is introduced into a reaction mixture also containing a gaseous carbon source. The carbon source is typically a C₁ through C₆ compound having as hetero atoms H, O<b>,</b> N, S or Cl, optionally mixed with hydrogen. Carbon monoxide or carbon monoxide and hydrogen is a preferred carbon feedstock; preferably, the carbon feedstock gas consists essentially of carbon monoxide.

Increased reaction zone temperatures of approximately 400°C to 1300°C, preferably 700°C to 1100°C, and pressures of between ~0 and ~100 p.s.i.g., are believed to cause decomposition of the gas phase metal containing compound to a metal containing catalyst. Decomposition may be to the atomic metal or to a partially decomposed intermediate species. The metal containing catalysts (1) catalyze CO decomposition and (2) catalyze SWNT formation. Thus, the invention also relates to forming SWNT via catalytic decomposition of a carbon compound.

The invention may in some embodiments employ an aerosol technique in which aerosols of metal containing catalysts are introduced into the reaction mixture. An advantage of an aerosol method for producing SWNT is that it will be possible to produce catalyst particles of uniform size and scale such a method for efficient and continuous commercial or industrial production. The previously discussed electric arc discharge and laser deposition methods cannot economically be scaled up for such commercial or industrial production.

Examples of metal containing compounds useful in the invention include metal carbonyls, metal acetyl acetonates, and other materials which under decomposition conditions can be introduced as a vapor which decomposes to form an unsupported metal catalyst.

Catalytically active metals include Fe, Co, Mn, Ni and Mo. Molybdenum carbonyls and Iron carbonyls are the preferred metal containing compounds which can be decomposed under reaction conditions to form vapor phase catalyst. Solid forms of these metal carbonyls may be delivered to a pretreatment zone where they are vaporized, thereby becoming the vapor phase precursor of the catalyst.

<u style="single">BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS</u>

<ul id="ul0001" list-style="none" compact="compact"><li><figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref> illustrates a reactor capable of producing SWNT.</li><li><figref idref="f0002">Fig. 2</figref> illustrates the vaporizer component of the reactor described in <figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref>.</li></ul>

<u style="single">DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS</u>

It has been found that two methods may be employed to form SWNT on unsupported catalysts. The first method is the direct injection of volatile catalyst. The direct injection method is described is copending application Serial No. <patcit id="pcit0005" dnum="US08459534B"><text>08/459, 534</text></patcit>

Direct injection of volatile catalyst precursors has been found to result in the formation of SWNT using molybdenum hexacarbonyl [Mo(CO)₆] and dicobalt octacarbonyl [Co₂(CO)₈] catalysts. Both materials are solids at room temperature, but sublime at ambient or near-ambient temperatures -- the molybdenum compound is thermally stable to at least 150°, the cobalt compound sublimes with decomposition "<nplcit id="ncit0010" npl-type="b"><text>Organic Syntheses via Metal Carbonyls," Vol. 1, I. Wender and P. Pino, eds., Interscience Publishers, New York, 1968, p. 40</text></nplcit>).

The second method uses a vaporizer to introduce the metal containing compound (<figref idref="f0002">Fig. 2</figref>).

In one preferred embodiment of the invention, the vaporizer <b>10</b>, shown at <figref idref="f0002">Fig. 2</figref>, comprises a quartz thermowell <b>20</b> having a seal <b>24</b> about 1" from its bottom to form a second compartment. This compartment has two 1/4" holes <b>26</b> which are open and exposed to the reactant gases. The catalyst is placed into this compartment, and then vaporized at any desired temperature using a vaporizer furnace <b>32</b>. This furnace is controlled using a first thermocouple <b>22</b>.

A metal containing compound, preferably a metal carbonyl, is vaporized at a temperature below its decomposition point, reactant gases CO or CO/H₂ sweep the precursor into the reaction zone <b>34</b>, which is controlled separately by a reaction zone furnace <b>38</b> and second thermocouple <b>42</b>.

Although applicants do not wish to be limited to a particular theory of operability, it is believed that at the reactor temperature, the metal containing compound is decomposed either partially to an intermediate species or completely to metal atoms. These intermediate species and/or metal atoms coalesce to larger aggregate particles which are the actual catalyst. The particle then grows to the correct size to both catalyze the decomposition of CO and promote SWNT growth. In the apparatus of <figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref>, the catalyst particles and the resultant carbon forms are collected on the quartz wool plug <b>36</b>.

Rate of growth of the particles depends on the concentration of the gas phase metal containing intermediate species. This concentration is determined by the vapor pressure (and therefore the temperature) in the vaporizer. If the concentration is too high, particle growth is too rapid, and structures other than SWNT are grown (e.g., MWNT, amorphous carbon, onions, etc.).

Examples 5 and 6 show many areas of SWNT along with MWNT and other carbon structures. Mo particles ranged from &lt;1-10 nm. In Example 4, mainly MWNT were formed along with other structures of carbon. Mo particles ranged from ∼1-50 nm. Presumably, the particles generated in Examples 5 and 6 were the right size to promote SWNT growth over the other forms possible. In Example 4, particle sizes favored growth of MWNT and other forms.

<u style="single">EXAMPLES</u>

<u style="single">Example 1</u>

In a direct injection process, the catalyst compartment was loaded with -40 mg Molybdenum hexacarbonyl (Mo(CO)₆] which has been ground to ∼-100 mesh. The reactor was heated to 900°C under an argon flow. Argon was then replaced with CO at atmospheric pressure at a flow of ∼0.8 SLM and the catalyst was injected.

The flow of CO was continued for 30 min. at 900°C, after which it was replaced by argon, and the reactor furnace turned off. After cooling to ambient temperature, the entire contents of the reactor including the quartz wool plug which had been tared prior to the run, was emptied into a tared plastic bag. The quartz wool plug was blackened, but the yield of carbon growth (wgt C/wgt catalyst) was &lt;1.

A specimen for Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) was prepared by shaking the quartz wool plug in ethanol in a glass vial and ultrasounding the ethanol for ∼2 min. This procedure dispersed the black particles from the quartz wool. A TEM grid was prepared by evaporating several drops of this dispersion onto a carbon-coated copper grid.

Examination of the grid in the TEM showed a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles varied from ~1- several hundred nm and were shown to be Mo by dispersive X-ray analysis. The MWNT, ranged from ~4-10 nm diameter. Fishbone fibrils (10-50 nm diameter) were also formed.

Examination of the grid also showed several areas containing SWNT. Diameters ranged between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 2</u>

The procedure of Ex. 1 was used to produce a mixture of Mo particles and carbon structures including both MWNT and SWNT. Catalyst charge (Mo(CO)₆] was -8 mg. SWNT yield was &lt;50% of all nanotubes produced.

<u style="single">Example 3</u>

The procedure of Example 1 was used to grow SWNT using ~22 mg Co₂(CO)₈ as catalyst. TEM analysis revealed Co particles to be the major component. MWNT and SWNT ranging in diameter from 1-2 nm were also formed. Estimated yield of SWNT was &lt;25% of the nanotubes formed.

<u style="single">Example 4</u>

A simulated aerosol reactor (<figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref>) was used to produce SWNT. As the catalyst sublimed in the vaporizer, the vapors were swept by the reactant gases into the reaction section where they underwent immediate thermal decomposition to Mo atoms and CO. It is theorized that the Mo atoms aggregated and promoted growth of carbon structures, including SWNT. These were caught on the quartz wool plug.

Approximately 20 mg of Mo(C)₆ was loaded into the vaporizer. Under argon at atmospheric pressure, the reactor section was heated to 900°C while keeping the vaporizer at ambient temperature. The argon stream was then changed to CO @∼0.8 SLM and H₂ @∼0.08 SLM, and while maintaining 900° in the reactor, the vaporizer temperature was raised to 70°C. Over the course of the run (1.5 hrs) the vaporizer temperature rose to 80°C due to heat from the reactor furnace. The vapor pressure of Mo(CO)₆ varied from 0.6-10 torr.

TEM specimens were made by the same procedure as Ex. 1. TEM examination showed mainly very small particles of Mo ranging from ~1-10 nm. Also produced were amorphous carbon structures and MWNT with diameters ~4 nm. SWNT with diameters ~1.5 nm were also produced, but in low yield.

<u style="single">Example 5</u>

A procedure similar to Ex. 4 where ∼20 mg Mo(CO)₆ was loaded in the vaporizer. With the reactor at atmospheric pressure at 900°C, the vaporizer temperature was set at 40°C and CO was fed to the system @∼0.8 SLM. Over the course of the run (1.5 hrs) the vaporizer temperature rose to 57°C. For this temperature span, the vapor pressure of Mo(CO)₆ ranged from 0.6-2 torr.

TEM examination showed mainly Mo nanoparticles 1-10 nm in diameter along with various carbon structures. These included amorphous carbon and MWNT with diameters of 4-10 nm. However, also produced were SWNT with diameters varying from ~1-3 nm. Estimated yield of SWNT was &lt;20% of the nanotubes produced.

<u style="single">Example 6</u>

Using the procedure of Exs. 4-5, ~20 mg Mo(CO)₆ was vaporized at 38-41°C into the reactor zone which was set at 900°C. The feed gas comprised CO @0.8 SLM and H₂ @0.08 SLM and was fed at atmospheric pressure for 2.0 hrs. Vapor pressure of catalyst was nearly constant at ∼0.6 torr.

TEM examination showed the presence of Mo nanoparticles, many ~ 1 nm diameter. The usual amorphous carbon and MWNT with diameters ranging from 4-10 nm were seen. However, SWNT, 1-3 nm in diameter were also produced at a yield of ~50% of the nanotubes produced.

<u style="single">Example 7</u>

Examples 1-6 are summarized in Table I. Precursor was obtained as a powder from ALFA/AESAR, Research Chemicals and Materials. They were ground under an argon blanket to ~-100 mesh. <tables id="tabl0001" num="0001"><table frame="all"><tgroup cols="7"><colspec colnum="1" colname="col1" colwidth="14mm" /><colspec colnum="2" colname="col2" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="3" colname="col3" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="4" colname="col4" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="5" colname="col5" colwidth="27mm" /><colspec colnum="6" colname="col6" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="7" colname="col7" colwidth="15mm" /><thead><row><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">RUN</u> #</entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">CATALYST</u><u style="single">PRECURSOR</u></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">FEEDSTOCK</u><u style="single">COMPOSITION</u></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">REACTOR</u><u style="single">TEMP</u></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">VAPORIZER</u><u style="single">TEMP</u></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">STEM</u></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><u style="single">SWNT</u></entry></row></thead><tbody><row><entry>1*</entry><entry align="center">Mo(CO)₆</entry><entry align="center">CO-100%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">NA</entry><entry align="center">Mix of particles and MWNT/SWNT</entry><entry align="center">&lt;50%</entry></row><row><entry>2*</entry><entry align="center">Mo(CO)₆</entry><entry align="center">CO-100%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">NA</entry><entry align="center">Same as above; X-ray showed no Fe</entry><entry align="center">&lt;50%</entry></row><row><entry>3*</entry><entry align="center">Co₂(CO)₈</entry><entry align="center">CO-100%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">NA</entry><entry align="center">Mostly particles, some SWNT strings</entry><entry align="center">&lt;25%</entry></row><row><entry>4**</entry><entry align="center">Mo(CO)₆</entry><entry align="center">CO-90% H₂-10%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">70-80°C</entry><entry align="center">Mostly particles, MWNT</entry><entry align="center">trace</entry></row><row><entry>5**</entry><entry align="center">Mo(CO)₆</entry><entry align="center">CO-100%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">40-57°C</entry><entry align="center">Mostly particles and MWNT, some SWNT</entry><entry align="center">&lt;20%</entry></row><row><entry>6**</entry><entry align="center">Mo(CO)₆</entry><entry align="center">CO-90% H₂-10%</entry><entry align="center">900°C</entry><entry align="center">38-41°C</entry><entry align="center">Particles, few MWNT, more SWNT</entry><entry align="center">-50%</entry></row></tbody></tgroup><tgroup cols="7" rowsep="0"><colspec colnum="1" colname="col1" colwidth="14mm" /><colspec colnum="2" colname="col2" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="3" colname="col3" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="4" colname="col4" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="5" colname="col5" colwidth="27mm" /><colspec colnum="6" colname="col6" colwidth="28mm" /><colspec colnum="7" colname="col7" colwidth="15mm" /><tbody><row><entry namest="col1" nameend="col7" align="justify">* Direct Injection Method **Simulated Aerosol Method</entry></row></tbody></tgroup></table></tables>

<u style="single">Example 8</u>

Ferrocene (C₅H₅)₂Fe is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 2 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ~4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 9</u>

Ferrocene (C₅H₅)₂Fe is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 6 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 10</u>

Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (CH₃C₅H₄)Mn(CO)₃ is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 2 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 11</u>

Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (CH₃C₅H₄)Mn(CO)₃ is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 6 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ~4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 12</u>

Cyclopentadienyl cobalt dicarbonyl (C₅H₅)CO(CO)₂ is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 2 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ∼1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 13</u>

Cyclopentadienyl cobalt dicarbonyl (C₅H₅)Co(CO)₂ is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 6 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 14</u>

Nickel dimethylglyoxime (HC₄H₆N₂O₂)Ni is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 2 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.

<u style="single">Example 15</u>

Nickel dimethylglyoxime (HC₄H₆N₂O₂)Ni is substituted for the molybdenum hexacarbonyl in the procedure of Example 6 at an appropriate vapor pressure and temperature.

Examination of the grid in the TEM shows a mixture of particles and carbon nanotubes, both MW and SW. Particles vary from ~1- several hundred nm. The MWNT ranges from ∼4-10 nm diameter.

Examination of the grid also shows several areas containing SWNT. Diameters range between 1-2 nm. TEM estimate of the yield of SWNT was &lt;50% of the carbon formed.