System for local error compensation in electromagnetic tracking systems

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED CASES

Applicants claim the benefit of International Application Number PCT/IB2007/051010, filed Mar. 22, 2007, and Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/788,472, filed Mar. 31, 2006.

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present disclosure relates to an electromagnetic tracking system (EMTS) for medical devices and, more particularly, to metal distortion error compensation systems and methods for accurate tracking in a medical environment.

BACKGROUND

The outcomes of minimally invasive medical procedures can be improved by using electromagnetic tracking systems (EMTS) to track the location of medical instruments and display this information on medical images, thereby helping to guide the medical instrument to a target location in the anatomy. EMTS generally uses an electromagnetic field generator to create a local electromagnetic field at the site of the procedure and a medical instrument or device containing a suitable sensor coil. Electrical current is induced in the sensor coil which is a function of the position and orientation of the sensor coil relative to the electromagnetic field generator. The EMTS computes the position of the sensor coil, and therefore the position of the medical instrument, based on the induced electrical current. A particular advantage of EMTS is that line of sight is not required to determine/monitor instrument location or movement, thereby making it particularly suitable for tracking needles or catheters inside anatomy.

One of the main problems with using EMTS in a medical environment is the presence of metallic conductive or ferromagnetic objects in proximity to the electromagnetic field. These objects create distortions, or metal artifacts, which create errors in the position and orientation tracking of medical instrument(s). The table or platform capable of sustaining a medical procedure is usually a main source of metal distortions. However, other objects, such as CT gantry, X-ray or C-arm, can also cause and/or contribute to distortions. Such distortions and associated errors in a clinician's assessment/understanding of instrument positioning may directly and negatively affect the outcome of a medical procedure using EMTS. Currently the clinical utility of EMTS is limited because the positional and orientational accuracy of EMTS cannot be guaranteed in the presence of metal distortions.

U.S. Pat. No. 6,400,139 to Khalfin et al. discloses methods/apparatus for electromagnetic position and orientation tracking with distortion compensation functionality. More particularly, the Khalfin '139 patent discloses methods/apparatus that employ at least one stationary sensor, called a “witness sensor,” having a fixed position and orientation near or within the volume to account for electromagnetic distortion. One or more probe sensors are placed on an object to be tracked within the volume, and the output of each witness sensor is used to compute the parameters of a non-real effective electromagnetic source. The parameters of the effective source are used as inputs to the computation of position and orientation as measured by each probe sensor, as if the object were in the non-distorted electromagnetic field produced by the effective source or sources.

Despite efforts to date, a need remains for systems and methods that effectively compensate for metal distortions, thereby improving the accuracy and/or reliability of EMTS in a medical/clinical environment. In addition, a need remains for systems/methods that improve EMTS performance such that catheter tracking in cardiac and vascular applications, oncology applications such as needle biopsies, radio-frequency ablations, cryoablations, prostate cancer therapies, etc., are effectively and reliably achieved. These and other needs are satisfied by the systems and methods disclosed herein.

SUMMARY

The present disclosure is directed to error compensation systems and apparatus for addressing metal distortions that exist and/or are encountered in using an electromagnetic tracking system (EMTS), e.g., in medical and/or surgical procedures. According to an exemplary embodiment, the disclosed EMTS includes an electromagnetic field generator that is adapted to generate an electromagnetic field. The electromagnetic field generator is generally adapted to be positioned in a medical/surgical/clinical environment, such that the electromagnetic field generated thereby may be used to track sensor data from electromagnetic sensors and suitable electromagnetic sensor coil(s). The disclosed sensor coil(s) are typically embedded in a medical device or other structure/element to be introduced to the clinical environment, thereby allowing positional and orientational data to be tracked while the medical device or other structure is positioned, in whole or in part, within an anatomy. An error compensation function is generated from an error compensation tool associated with the disclosed system/method, and error compensation generated thereby is applied to the positional and orientational data associated with the medical device or other structure for accurate tracking. The error-compensated information may be displayed on an imaging system, stored in computer memory and/or printed.

According to exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure, the disclosed error correction tool includes a plurality of electromagnetic sensors fixed in a known/predetermined geometric configuration. Preferably, the error correction tool is situated or oriented so as to surround the local area of interest, i.e., the clinical/anatomical region where a medical, surgical and/or diagnostic procedure is to take place. In a preferred embodiment, an optical tracking sensor is attached to the error correction tool for higher accuracy. The optical tracking sensor is generally unaffected by metal distortion and its position and orientation is fixed and known with respect to at least one electromagnetic sensor on the error correction tool.

In a further exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure, prior art EMTS-related problems are overcome by generating distortion mapping that allows for free movement of the generator and/or table. This embodiment utilizes an optical tracking system that is adapted to track position data from optical sensors placed on the electromagnetic field generator and table used in the medical/surgical procedure. A positioning system is used to move an EMTS sensor to different locations to facilitate mapping of distortion data. This creates several possible distortion maps for different positions of the table and field generator relative to each other. Thus, a single comprehensive mapping is obtained and, according to the present disclosure, subsequent movements of the table and/or field generator during and/or in between procedures does not negatively effect the reliability and/or accuracy of the disclosed EMTS. Indeed, according to exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure, an imaging system is provided that is adapted to display tracking information for a medical device or other structure that is advantageously compensated by distortion mapping.

Additional features, functions and advantages associated with the disclosed systems and methods will be apparent from the description which follows, particularly when read in conjunction with the figures appended hereto.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

To assist those of ordinary skill in making and using the disclosed systems and methods, reference is made to the appended figures, wherein:

<figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 1</figref> is a schematic illustrating a first exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure;

<figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 2</figref> is a schematic illustrating a second exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure; and

<figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref> is a schematic illustrating a third exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EXEMPLARY EMBODIMENT(S)

The present disclosure provides advantageous electromagnetic tracking systems (EMTS) for medical devices and other structures. The disclosed systems/methods provide metal distortion error compensation, thereby facilitating accurate tracking of such devices/structures in a medical/surgical environment. By effectively compensating for metal distortions, the disclosed systems and methods improve the accuracy and/or reliability of EMTS in a medical/clinical environment. For example, improved EMTS performance is provided such that effective and reliable catheter tracking in cardiac and vascular applications, oncology applications such as needle biopsies, radio-frequency ablations, cryoablations, prostate cancer therapies, and the like.

Referring initially to <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 1</figref>, illustrated is electromagnetic tracking system (EMTS) <b>10</b> having an electromagnetic field generator <b>11</b>. In a first embodiment, generator <b>11</b> creates a local electromagnetic field capable of tracking sensor data from electromagnetic sensors <b>13</b> and medical device <b>14</b>. During a medical/surgical procedure, device <b>14</b> typically penetrates an anatomy <b>15</b> beneath the skin to a target location. An electromagnetic sensor coil is embedded on device <b>14</b>. An electric current is induced in the sensor coil which is a function of position and orientation of the sensor coil relative to electromagnetic field generator <b>11</b>. The sensor coil is detected by the local electromagnetic field generated by generator <b>11</b>. Sensor data from the sensor coil is displayed on imaging system <b>16</b>. Imaging system <b>16</b> can include, but is not limited to, a monitor with computer typical in a medical environment. This data consists of position and orientation of the sensor coil, thus the position and orientation of the medical device <b>14</b> can be determined. The medical device can be a needle, a catheter, or any device moving through an anatomy.

Error correction tool <b>12</b>, having electromagnetic sensors <b>13</b>, is placed surrounding the site of interest, typically over the location of the medical procedure. By monitoring position readings of sensors <b>13</b> on correction tool <b>12</b>, a correction function is derived and applied to the sensor coil position and orientation data. The correction tool thus achieves local error compensation for metal distortions existing in the environment. These distortions are common among CT, X-ray and ultrasound environments.

Error correction tool <b>12</b> typically has a number of electromagnetic sensors arranged in a fixed and known geometric configuration. <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 1</figref>, for example, shows four sensors arranged in a square configuration. In an exemplary embodiment, the electromagnetic sensors could be arranged in a 10 cm by 10 cm square. In an alternative exemplary configuration, only three sensors are arranged in a triangle of known dimensions. In a preferred embodiment, the exact positions of the sensors relative to each other should be known. It is particularly useful to arrange the sensors in a way such that the site of interest for the procedure can be surrounded by the sensors.

According to exemplary embodiments of the disclosed systems and methods, positional readings are taken from sensors <b>13</b> when tool <b>12</b> is placed in the field of view of generator <b>11</b>. If metal distortions are present (and absent correction functionality as disclosed herein), the position of one or more of the sensors will be incorrect and EMTS <b>10</b> will not properly recognize/translate the geometric arrangement. However, since the relative positions of sensors <b>13</b> are fixed and known according to the present disclosure, the disclosed systems and methods facilitate correction of the EMTS reading (i.e., un-distortion), thereby yielding the correct geometric shape. This correction can then be applied to the positional reading of medical device <b>14</b> and, in this way, the field local to the tool is compensated for errors caused by metal distortion.

Although it is possible to perform error correction solely using electromagnetic sensors, error may still exist since the absolute positions of the sensors read by the EMTS are not known in the presence of metal distortions. In a preferred embodiment of the present disclosure, means for identifying the absolute position of at least one of the sensors enables the absolute position of all sensors <b>23</b> to be known/determined. <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 2</figref> illustrates an exemplary embodiment where optical tracking sensor <b>26</b> is attached to error correction tool <b>22</b>. Optical tracking sensor <b>26</b> is generally in a fixed and known position relative to at least one of electromagnetic sensors <b>23</b>. Optical tracking space and electromagnetic tracking space can be registered to imaging system <b>27</b>, thus providing an absolute positional reference for error tool <b>22</b>. Imaging system <b>27</b> can include, but is not limited to, a monitor with computer/central processing unit, as are known for use in a medical/surgical environment. In this preferred embodiment, absolute positions of electromagnetic sensors <b>23</b> generate a more accurate distortion correction function local to the error tool.

According to <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 2</figref>, EMTS <b>20</b> is schematically illustrated and includes an electromagnetic field generator <b>21</b>. In this exemplary embodiment, generator <b>21</b> creates a local electromagnetic field capable of tracking sensor data from electromagnetic sensors <b>23</b> and medical device <b>24</b>. During a medical/surgical procedure, device <b>24</b> typically penetrates an anatomy <b>25</b> beneath the skin to a target location. An electromagnetic sensor coil is embedded on device <b>24</b>. An electric current is induced in the sensor coil which is a function of position and orientation of the sensor coil relative to electromagnetic field generator <b>21</b>. The sensor coil is detected by the local electromagnetic field generated by generator <b>21</b>. Sensor data from the sensor coil is displayed on imaging system <b>27</b>. This data consists of position and orientation of the sensor coil, thus the position and orientation of medical device <b>24</b>. The medical device can be a needle, a catheter, or any device moving through an anatomy.

Error correction tool <b>22</b>, which includes electromagnetic sensors <b>23</b>, is placed surrounding the site of interest, typically over the location of the medical procedure. By monitoring position readings of sensors <b>23</b> on correction tool <b>22</b>, a correction function is derived and applied to the sensor coil position and orientation data, thereby achieving local error compensation for metal distortions existing in the environment. These distortions are common among CT, X-ray and ultrasound environments.

Error correction tool <b>22</b> typically has a number of electromagnetic sensors arranged in a fixed and known geometric configuration. <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 2</figref>, for example, shows four sensors arranged in a square configuration. As noted with reference to the embodiment of <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 1</figref>, the sensors may be arranged in a 10 cm by 10 cm square. In an alternative embodiment, only three sensors are arranged in a triangle of known dimensions. In a preferred embodiment, the exact positions of the sensors relative to each other are known. It is particularly useful to arrange the sensors in a way such that the site of interest for the procedure can be surrounded by the sensors.

Positional readings can be taken from sensors <b>23</b> when tool <b>22</b> is placed in the field of view of generator <b>21</b>. If metal distortions are present, the position of one or more of the sensors will be incorrect and EMTS <b>20</b> will not properly translate the geometric arrangement. Since the relative positions of sensors <b>23</b> are fixed and known, it is possible to un-distort and correct the EMTS reading, thereby yielding the correct geometric shape. This correction can then be applied to the position reading of medical device <b>24</b> and, in this way, the field local to the tool is compensated for errors caused by metal distortion.

<figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref> illustrates a third exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure in which electromagnetic field generator <b>34</b> has at least a first optical tracking sensor <b>35</b><i>a</i>. Generator <b>34</b> creates a local electromagnetic field capable of tracking sensor data from an electromagnetic sensor coil embedded on a medical device or other structure/element. An electric current is induced in the sensor coil. The electric current is a function of position and orientation of the sensor coil relative to electromagnetic field generator <b>34</b>. Sensor data from the sensor coil is displayed on imaging system <b>36</b>. Imaging system <b>36</b> can include, but is not limited to, a monitor with a conventional computer/central processing unit, as are typical in the medical/surgical environment. This data consists of position and orientation of the sensor coil, which translates to the position and orientation of the medical device. The medical device can be a needle, a catheter, or any device moving through an anatomy.

With further reference to <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref>, exemplary table <b>33</b> can take the form of a typical platform used for medical/surgical procedures, including but not limited to a CT table, X-ray table, or ultrasound table. As noted previously, the medical procedure environment, including table <b>33</b>, typically creates metal distortions that alter the accuracy of a conventional EMTS. These distortions are advantageously overcome according to the exemplary embodiment of <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref>.

As schematically depicted in <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref>, at least a second optical tracking sensor is advantageously attached to table <b>33</b>. Electromagnetic mapping is achieved through the use of positioning system <b>30</b> having an EMTS sensor <b>31</b>. In the exemplary embodiment of <figref idref="DRAWINGS">FIG. 3</figref>, positioning system <b>30</b> is moved to different locations within a desired spatial volume, wherein electromagnetic sensor <b>31</b>, first optical sensor <b>35</b><i>a </i>and second optical sensor <b>35</b><i>b </i>are in communication. Positioning data is gathered for all three sensors relative to each other, thereby permitting and/or facilitating mapping any local distortions caused by the local environment relative to different known positions of the positioning system, the electromagnetic field generator and the table.

Useful and practical distortion compensation is derived according to exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure by moving at least one sensor <b>31</b> to known location(s) with high accuracy within a desired spatial volume. Multiple mappings may be performed for many different locations and orientations of electromagnetic field generator <b>34</b> and/or table <b>33</b>. Optical tracking sensors <b>35</b><i>a </i>and <b>35</b><i>b </i>can be a typical six degree of freedom optical sensor immune to metal distortions. Thus, comprehensive mapping and compensation are derived for different generator and table positions. This procedure need only be undertaken once, thereby enhancing the ease of use of the disclosed EMTS systems, e.g., in a medical/surgical environment. Once completed, both the generator and the table can be moved around during an actual medical/surgical procedure and the compensation mapping will still be valid.

According to an exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure, an optical tracking system <b>35</b> monitors location of optical tracking sensors <b>35</b><i>a </i>and <b>35</b><i>b </i>so that their positions are known at all times during the mapping procedure. Positioning system <b>30</b> positions EMTS sensor <b>31</b> very accurately at known locations in space. The corresponding position and orientation data is recorded on the EMTS. The field generator is then moved to a different location relative to the table and the procedure is repeated. The field generator and table need not be moved to many different locations; a few locations may be sufficient to derive a mapping that can compensate for a range of positions of the generator and table. The table is the main source of metal distortions in the use of EMTS in medical applications, however other objects in a typical medical environment, such as CT gantry, X-ray or C-arm, can also cause distortions. This method can be applied to other anticipated sources of disruption.

By providing error compensation, the use of EMTS is more realistic and practical, in turn allowing many opportunities for integrating medical imaging with medical device tracking. The technology is generically applicable to most any situation where a physician needs to guide a medical device to a location within an anatomy.

Although the present disclosure is provided with reference to exemplary embodiments of the present systems and methods, the present disclosure is not limited to such exemplary embodiments. Rather, the systems and methods of the present disclosure may be modified, altered and/or enhanced without departing from the spirit or scope hereof, as will be readily apparent to persons of ordinary skill in the art based on the description herein. The present disclosure expressly encompasses such modifications, alterations and enhancements within the scope hereof.