Wind turbine blade with anti-noise devices
Abstract
A wind turbine comprising at least a blade (11) having an aerodynamic profile with a leading edge (13), a trailing edge (15) and suction and pressure sides between the leading edge (13) and the trailing edge (15) that includes an anti-noise device (31) placed on the suction side formed by elements (33) that modify the frequency spectra of the boundary layer noise. Preferably the anti-noise device (31) is placed on the suction side between two sections corresponding to chord positions in the range of 40%-95% of the chord length, measured from the leading edge (13).

Term
1.6 yearsto projected expiry
Projected expiry 23 April 2028, counted from filing; an application has no term until it is granted.
- Priority
- Filed
- Published
- Today
- Projected expiry
15 claims: 9 independent, 6 dependent
- 1A wind turbine comprising at least a blade (11) having an aerodynamic profile with a leading edge (13), a trailing edge (15) and suction and pressure sides between the leading edge (13) and the trailing edge (15), characterized in that the blade (11) includes an anti-noise device (31) placed on the suction side formed by elements (33) that modify the frequency spectra of the boundary layer noise.
- 8A wind turbine blade according to any of claims 1-7, characterized in that said elements (33) are bodies of an arrow shape, said bodies being defined by left and right upper and lower trapezoidal faces (51, 53, 55, 57) with common central sides from the arrow tip (41) to the arrow center (43) and lateral faces (61, 63, 65, 67, 69, 71) extending between said upper and lower faces (51, 53, 55, 57),
- 13A wind turbine blade according to any of claims 8-12, characterized in that the angle θ 1 between the outer side (75) of the left upper face (51) and the arrow axis (77) is comprised between 5-60 deg and in that the angle θ 2 between the outer side (79) of the right upper face (53) and the arrow axis (77) is comprised between 5-60 deg.
- 14A wind turbine blade according to any of claims 8-13, characterized in that the angle θ 3 between the inner side (81) of the left upper face (51) and the arrow axis (77) is comprised between 30-90 deg and in that the angle θ 4 between the inner side (83) of the right upper face (53) and the arrow axis (77) is comprised between 30-90 deg.
- 15A wind turbine blade according to any of claims 8-14, characterized in that the length λ 1 of the side (85) connecting the inner and outer sides (81, 75) of the left upper face (51) is comprised between 0-20 cm, the length λ 2 of the side (87) connecting the inner and outer sides (83, 79) of the right upper face (53) is comprised between 0-20 cm and the length λ 3 of a side projection of said elements (33) is comprised between 0-20 cm and the length λ 4 of a frontal projection of said elements (33) is comprised between 0-20 cm.
Independent claims9
35 paragraphs in 5 sections, as filed
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
0001The invention relates to wind turbine blades with anti-noise devices and in particular with devices intended for reducing the aerodynamic audible noise produced in dB(A).
BACKGROUND
0002An important constrain in the power production in wind turbines is that imposed by the noise generated during operation. In particular, wind turbine blades produce aerodynamic audible noise due to the interaction between the boundary layer and the trailing edge.
0003Turbulent boundary layers on wind turbine blades produce noise after the onset of the transition and when interacting with the trailing edge. The anisotropy, history and length scale of the turbulence within the boundary layer affect the noise generated by an airfoil.
0004There are known several proposals for reducing the aerodynamic noise produced by wind turbine blades.
0005One of them is the use of serrated trailing edges. In this respect, <patcit id="pcit0001" dnum="EP0652367A"><text>EP0652367</text></patcit> discloses rotor blades having its rear edge irregularly formed, in particular in a saw-tooth form. <patcit id="pcit0002" dnum="EP1314885A"><text>EP1314885</text></patcit> discloses rotor blades with serrated trailing edges each having a plurality of span-wise, periodic indentations, in the form a saw teeth having approximately 60 degrees included angles between adjacent vertices. <patcit id="pcit0003" dnum="EP1338793A"><text>EP1338793</text></patcit> discloses rotor blades in which a dentation is formed in the trailing edge part of the blade which is shaped in a serration of triangular tooth, of trapezoid tooth, or of sawtooth.
0006Another proposal, disclosed in <patcit id="pcit0004" dnum="WO2006122547A"><text>W02006/122547</text></patcit>, is the use of turbulence generating means as noise reduction means. Said means are placed on the leeward surface side of the wind turbine blade and at the outer section of the wind turbine blade in direction of the blade tip.
0007The prior art also teaches the use of wind turbine operational control methods for reducing the aerodynamic noise and, in particular, controlling the rotor speed. In this respect, the publication "<nplcit id="ncit0001" npl-type="b"><text>Wind Turbine Noise", Wagner et al., Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1996</text></nplcit> summarizes the problems raised by the noise produced by wind turbines and some proposals for its reduction.
0008The present invention provides a different solution for reducing the aerodynamic noise produced by the wind turbine blades.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
0009An object of the present invention is to provide a wind turbine blade with means that allow altering the characteristics of the boundary layer and therefore modify the emitted noise.
0010Another object of the present invention is to provide a wind turbine blade with audible noise reduction means. Although the acoustic energy in the noise emission may remain unaltered, the audible noise production will be reduced.
0011These and other objects of the present invention are met by providing a wind turbine comprising at least a blade having an aerodynamic profile with a leading edge, a trailing edge and suction and pressure sides between the leading edge and the trailing edge and including an anti-noise device placed on the suction side formed by elements that modify the frequency spectra of the boundary layer noise.
0012As it will be explained in detail below, said elements are not intended to produce turbulence as a mechanism for noise reduction like in <patcit id="pcit0005" dnum="WO2006122547A"><text>WO 2006/122547</text></patcit> but coherent fluidic structures. The introduction of turbulence implies the introduction of random motion in the boundary layer, while the introduction of coherent structures is associated to the introduction of ordered motion in the boundary layer.
0013Other features and advantages of the present invention will be understood from the following detailed description in relation with the enclosed drawings.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
0014<ul id="ul0001" list-style="none" compact="compact"><li><figref idref="f0001">Figure 1</figref> is a schematic side view of a wind turbine blade with an anti-noise device according to the present invention.</li><li><figref idref="f0001">Figure 2</figref> is a perspective view of a single element of an anti-noise device according to the present invention.</li><li><figref idref="f0002">Figure 3</figref> is a plan view of the single element shown in <figref idref="f0001">Figure 2</figref>.</li><li><figref idref="f0002">Figures 4, 5 and 6</figref> are perspective views of three different embodiments of an anti-noise device according to the present invention.</li><li><figref idref="f0003">Figure 7</figref> shows schematically the coherent vortical structures generated by a single element of an anti-noise device according to the present invention.</li><li><figref idref="f0003">Figure 8</figref> shows a surface oil visualization of the effect of the coherent structures on the surface of a blade.</li></ul>
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
0015When the flow goes over a blade, a boundary layer is formed. This boundary layer is the region in the flow field where the velocity adapts from the velocity in the flow away from the blade and the non-slip condition that is naturally imposed on the surface of it. The nature of the boundary layer can be laminar or turbulent. A laminar boundary layer could be seen as a boundary layer where the flow moves smoothly, like in layers parallel to the surface. Laminar boundary layers naturally develop into turbulent boundary layers, where there is a high component of random motion. The change from laminar to turbulent occurs in a region called "transition region", where different fluidic structures develop changing the nature of the boundary layer. The first turbulent structure to appear is the "turbulent spot". Turbulent spots travel downstream, merge and develop into A structures (also called hairpin structures). The latter structures promote mixing in the boundary layer, and due to the motion patterns introduced in the flow, they are self-maintained. Short after the appearance of the A structures the flow becomes completely turbulent, and no instantaneous order can be found. In turbulent boundary layers "real" viscous effects (those due to the viscosity) are only present in the viscous sub-layer, which is a very small region close to the wall. In the rest of the turbulent boundary layer the viscous effects are only apparent, as they are due to the random motion and not to the viscosity and shear stress energy dissipation.
0016The power levels of noise emitted and its distribution in frequencies highly depends on the length scale of the turbulence and the power spectra of the pressure fluctuations introduced on the surface of the blade by the turbulent motion. The scale of the turbulent structures within the boundary layer is of the same order of the boundary layer thickness, and its characteristic length scales and power spectra distribution are highly dependent on the history of the boundary layer upstream of the location considered, which, for aeroacoustic purposes, is usually the trailing edge.
0017It is the idea of this invention to alter both, the scale of the turbulence and its power distribution in the frequency domain by the use of elements introducing coherent fluidic structures, placed behind the location of the transition line, where the change from laminar to turbulent boundary layer occurs.
0018<figref idref="f0001">Figure 1</figref> shows a wind turbine blade 11 having a leading edge 13 and a trailing edge 15 that includes an anti-noise device 31 according to this invention placed on the right side -from the point of view of the wind direction 17- of the transition line 21 where the change from a laminar boundary layer to a turbulent laminar layer occurs.
0019When the flow near the blade goes over the anti-noise device, coherent vortical structures 35 (see <figref idref="f0003">Fig. 7</figref>), aligned with the free-stream are produced, dramatically altering the boundary layer and changing its fluidic characteristics. Streamwise aligned coherent vortices have shown to have a great impact on the velocity distribution on the boundary layer and on its turbulent characteristics, i.e. turbulence levels, turbulent kinetic energy production, etc. (see <figref idref="f0003">Fig. 8</figref>).
0020It modern wind turbine blades it can be considered that the transition line 21 is located, for moderate angles of attack, between two sections corresponding to chord positions in the range of 40%-95% of the chord length, measured from the leading edge 13.
0021<figref idref="f0001">Figure 1</figref> shows the anti-noise device 31 extending from the root 19 to the tip 21. It is thought that the anti-noise device 31 shall be placed along a section of the blade 11 extending between 5% to the 100% of its length measured from its root 19.
0022In another embodiment the anti-noise device 31 is placed along a section of the blade 11 extending between 66% to the 100% of its length measured from its root 19.
0023<figref idref="f0001">Figure 2</figref> shows an embodiment of a single element 33 that can be used in the anti-noise device 31 in its position with respect to the flow direction indicated by the x-axis and the blade span indicated by the z-axis.
0024Following <figref idref="f0001">Figures 2</figref> and <figref idref="f0002">3</figref> it can be seen that the single element 33 is a body of an arrow shape which is positioned on the suction side of the blade 11 with the arrow tip 41 oriented towards the leading edge 13.
0025In another embodiment the single element 33 is positioned on the suction side of the blade 11 with the arrow tip 41 oriented towards the trailing edge 15.
0026The element 33 is defined by left and right upper and lower trapezoidal faces 51, 53, 55, 57 with common central sides from the arrow tip 41 to the arrow center 43 and lateral faces 61, 63, 65, 67, 69, 71 extending between said upper and lower faces 51, 53, 55, 57.
0027In a preferred embodiment the heights t1, t2, t3 and t4 of, respectively, the arrow tip 41, the arrow center 43 and the arrow left and right ends 45, 47 are comprised between 0-10 mm.
0028In another preferred embodiment the height t1 of the arrow tip 41 is lesser than the height t2 of the arrow center 43 and the heights t3, t4 of the arrow left and right ends 45, 47 are lesser than the height t2 of the arrow center 43 and greater than the height t1 of the arrow tip 41.
0029In a preferred embodiment the angle θ<sub>1</sub> between the outer side 75 of the left upper face 51 and the arrow axis 77 is comprised between 5-60 deg, the angle θ<sub>2</sub> between the outer side 79 of the right upper face 53 and the arrow axis 77 is comprised between 5-60 deg, the angle θ<sub>3</sub> between the inner side 81 of the left upper face 51 and the arrow axis 77 is comprised between 30-90 deg and the angle θ<sub>4</sub> between the inner side 83 of the right upper face 53 and the arrow axis 77 is comprised between 30-90 deg.
0030In a preferred embodiment the length λ<sub>1</sub> of the side 85 connecting the inner and outer sides 81, 75 of the left upper face 51 is comprised between 0-20 cm, the length λ<sub>2</sub> of the side 87 connecting the inner and outer sides 83, 79 of the right upper face 53 is comprised between 0-20 cm, the length λ<sub>3</sub> of a side projection of element 33 is comprised between 0-20 cm and the length λ<sub>4</sub> of a frontal projection of element 33 is comprised between 0-20 cm.
0031<figref idref="f0002">Figure 4</figref> shows an anti-noise device 31 formed by a plurality of elements 33 placed on the blade individually, leaving spaces between them.
0032<figref idref="f0002">Figure 5</figref> shows an anti-noise device 31 formed by a plurality of elements 33 placed on the blade in groups, leaving spaces between the groups.
0033<figref idref="f0002">Figure 6</figref> shows an anti-noise device 31 formed by a plurality of elements 33 placed on the blade side by side without leaving spaces between them.
0034Varying the geometrical dimensions already defined and the spacing between elements 33, different vortical strengths and core sizes can be obtained for the coherent vortical structures. Geometrical dimensions of the elements 33 have an impact on the fluidic characteristics of the generated filaments, and therefore can be tuned to be used over a wide range of wind turbine operating characteristics for noise reduction purposes. In all the cases the change in the velocity and vorticity distributions within the boundary layer is expected to shift the noise power spectra distribution (in dB(A)).
0035Although the present invention has been fully described in connection with preferred embodiments, it is evident that modifications may be introduced within the scope thereof, not considering this as limited by these embodiments, but by the contents of the following claims.
Contents5
4 sheets
Sheet 1 Sheet 2 Sheet 3 Sheet 4
Every citation, both ways
| Document | Relation | Office | Cited during |
|---|---|---|---|
| US8267657B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US9297357B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US11300097B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US7976276B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US7976283B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US8414261B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US8834127B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US10767623B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| DE102009035689A1 | Cited by | Germany | Search report |
| US9506452B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US10180125B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US8834117B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| EP3421783A1 | Cited by | European Patent Office (EPO) | Search report |
| DE102011056491B4 | Cited by | Germany | Applicant |
| US8430638B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| EP3786444A1 | Cited by | European Patent Office (EPO) | Search report |
| US8083488B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US10746157B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US10465652B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| US8523515B2 | Cited by | United States of America | Applicant |
| EP0652367A1 | Cites | European Patent Office (EPO) | Applicant |
| EP1314885A1 | Cites | European Patent Office (EPO) | Applicant |
| EP1338793A2 | Cites | European Patent Office (EPO) | Applicant |
| WO2006122547A1 | Cites | World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) | Applicant |
| WAGNER ET AL.: "Wind Turbine Noise", 1996, SPRINGER-VERLAG | Non-patent | – | Applicant |
11 members in 5 offices
Priority claims2
| Document | Office | Kind | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| 200701494 | Spain | – | |
| 200701494 | Spain | A |
Members11
| Document | Office | Kind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| US2008298967A1 | United States of America | A1 | |
| CN101324218A | China | A | |
| EP2028366A2This record | European Patent Office (EPO) | A2 | |
| ES2345583A1 | Spain | A1 | |
| ES2345583B1 | Spain | B1 | |
| US8157532B2 | United States of America | B2 | |
| CN101324218B | China | B | |
| EP2028366A3 | European Patent Office (EPO) | A3 | |
| EP2028366B1 | European Patent Office (EPO) | B1 | |
| DK2028366T3 | Denmark | T3 | |
| ES2925301T3 | Spain | T3 |
82 legal events, as 11 offices reported them to INPADOC
Over the term
Point at a mark for the eventEvents
| Event | Code | Office | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gb: european patent ceased through non-payment of renewal feeCeasedGBPC | GBPC | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Ep patent lapsedLapsedEBP | EBP | DK | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Application deemed withdrawn, or ip right lapsed, due to non-payment of renewal feeWithdrawnR119 | R119 | DE | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Patent lapsedLapsedMM4A | MM4A | IE | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed because of non-payment of the annual feeLapsedMM | MM | BE | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Patent ceasedCeasedPL | PL | CH | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]GrantedPGFP | PGFP | EP | |
| No opposition filedOpposition26N | 26N | EP | |
| No opposition filed within time limitOppositionORIGINAL CODE: 0009261PLBE | PLBE | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: NO OPPOSITION FILED WITHIN TIME LIMITSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| No opposition filed against granted patent, or epo opposition proceedings concluded without decisionGrantedR097 | R097 | DE | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Deletion acc. to par. 5 (withdrawal of the translation of the ep patent)MK05 | MK05 | AT | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo]LapsedPG25 | PG25 | EP | |
| Patent invalid in the netherlands as no translation has been filedMP | MP | NL | |
| Definitive protectionFG2A | FG2A | ES | |
| Invalidation of extension of european patentsMG9D | MG9D | LT | |
| Ep patent with danish claimsT3 | T3 | DK | |
| European patents granted designating irelandGrantedFG4D | FG4D | IE | |
| Reference to at number (ep patent validated in austria)REF | REF | AT | |
| Dpma publication of mentioned ep patent grantGrantedR096 | R096 | DE | |
| European patent takes effect as a national patent in ch/liEP | EP | CH | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | EP | |
| European patent grantedGrantedFG4D | FG4D | GB | |
| (expected) grantORIGINAL CODE: 0009210GRAA | GRAA | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: THE PATENT HAS BEEN GRANTEDSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| Grant fee paidORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR3GRAS | GRAS | EP | |
| Intention to grant announcedINTG | INTG | EP | |
| Despatch of communication of intention to grant a patentORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR1GRAP | GRAP | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: GRANT OF PATENT IS INTENDEDSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: EXAMINATION IS IN PROGRESSSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| Party data changed (applicant data changed or rights of an application transferred)RAP1 | RAP1 | EP | |
| Designation fees paidAKX | AKX | EP | |
| Extension fees paidAXX | AXX | EP | |
| Extension fees paidAXX | AXX | EP | |
| Extension fees paidAXX | AXX | EP | |
| Extension fees paidAXX | AXX | EP | |
| First examination report despatched17Q | 17Q | EP | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: EXAMINATION IS IN PROGRESSSTAA | STAA | EP | |
| Request for examination filed17P | 17P | EP | |
| Designated contracting states (corrected)RBV | RBV | EP | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | EP | |
| Request for extension of the european patentAX | AX | EP | |
| Information provided on ipc code assigned before grantRIC1 | RIC1 | EP | |
| Information provided on ipc code assigned before grantRIC1 | RIC1 | EP | |
| Information provided on ipc code assigned before grantRIC1 | RIC1 | EP | |
| Search report despatchedORIGINAL CODE: 0009013PUAL | PUAL | EP | |
| Party data changed (applicant data changed or rights of an application transferred)RAP1 | RAP1 | EP | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | EP | |
| Request for extension of the european patentAX | AX | EP | |
| Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phaseORIGINAL CODE: 0009012PUAI | PUAI | EP |
Numbers
- Publication
- 2028366
- Application
- 80077613
Titles3
- German
- Windturbinenschaufel mit Geräuschdämpfungselementen
- English
- Wind turbine blade with anti-noise devices
- French
- Pale d'éolienne avec dispositifs d'insonorisation
Classification
- CPC, 13
- F03D1/0608
- F05B2240/30
- F05B2250/183
- F05B2260/962
- F05D2270/17
- F05D2250/183
- F05D2260/962
- F05D2240/127
- F05D2240/30
- F05B2240/3062
- Y02E10/72
- F05B2240/122
- Y10S415/914
- IPC, 3
- F03D1 06
- F03D3 06
- F01D5 14
Designated states38
- Contracting states, 34
- Austria
- Belgium
- Bulgaria
- Switzerland
- Cyprus
- Czechia
- Germany
- Denmark
- Estonia
- Spain
- Finland
- France
- United Kingdom
- Greece
- Croatia
- Hungary
- Ireland
- Iceland
- Italy
- Liechtenstein
- Lithuania
- Luxembourg
- Latvia
- Monaco
and 10 moreShow fewer
- Malta
- Netherlands (Kingdom of the)
- Norway
- Poland
- Portugal
- Romania
- Sweden
- Slovenia
- Slovakia
- Türkiye
- Extension states, 4
- Albania
- Bosnia and Herzegovina
- North Macedonia
- Serbia