Composition useful for providing nox removing coating on material surface
Abstract
This record has no abstract on file.
Term
Term ended
Projected expiry passed 14 September 2024, 2 years ago.
- Priority and filed
- Published
- Projected expiry
- Today
17 claims: 12 independent, 5 dependent
- 1Claims of equivalent WO 2006030250 A2 CLAIMS 1. A NO x removing composition for use as a coating on material surface, comprising at least:a) photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles having at least a de-NO x activity, b) particles having a de-HNU 3 activity, c) an opacifying agent, and d) a silicon based-material in which said particles are dispersed, wherein said photocatalytic particles have a crystalline size ranging from 1 to 50 nm.
- 17A method for imparting self-cleaning properties towards atmospheric contaminants to a surface of a material, said method comprising at least the steps of:- applying a composition according to anyone of claims 1 to 16 onto the surface of a material, and - drying or curing the composition to obtain an opaque coating thereon.
Independent claims12
110 paragraphs in 1 section, as filed
Description of equivalent WO 2006030250 A2
0001Composition useful for providing NCy removing coating on material surface
0002The present invention relates to compositions having photocatalytic self- cleaning properties for use as NO<sub>x</sub> removing coating on material surfaces.
0003In the field of buildings and coatings, the pollution of the environment raises a serious problem of contamination of exterior materials for buildings and outdoor buildings. Dust and particles floating in the air deposit on the roof and the outer wall of buildings in fine weather. Upon exposure to rainfall, the deposits flow together with rainwater and flow down along the outer wall of the building. As a result, the contaminant adheres along the course of the rainwater. As the surface dries, soil appears in a stripe pattern. To solve at least in part this problem, it has already been proposed to deposit a coating on construction material surfaces. Alternatively, said coating furthermore exhibits photocatalytic self-cleaning properties towards atmospheric contaminants. Thus, titanium oxide photocatalytic coatings are disclosed in EP 0 901 991, WO 97/07069, WO 97/10186 and WO 98/41480. More specifically, titanium dioxide (TiO<sub>2</sub>) which is a semiconductor, converts
0004UV radiation (for example from UV light) into electrons and holes which can ultimately initiate the degradation of harmful organic compounds into harmless substances. Typical atmospheric contaminants are for example, nitrogen oxides, ozone and organic pollutants adsorbed on the coated surface of the materials. This is particularly advantageous in built- up areas, for example, in city streets, where the concentration of organic contaminants may be relatively high, especially in intense sunlight, but where the available surface area of materials is also relatively high.
0005However, one problem associated with so-formed oxidized species, like HNO<sub>3</sub> formed from the reaction OfNO<sub>2</sub> and NO with TiO<sub>2</sub>AJV light in the presence of water and oxygen, is their absorption on the coated surface of the material where they may cause problems of stains and/or corrosion.
0006Accordingly, there is still a need for a coating having a significant improvement in decontamination properties, non staining ability and outstanding durability over prior coatings. Surprisingly, the inventors have discovered that such a purpose could be efficiently achieved by a specific composition for use as a coating. Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a composition which, when applied as a coating on a surface of a material, exhibits improved NO<sub>x</sub> and optionally VOC<sub>x</sub> (i.e. Volatile Organic Content like xylene and benzene) removing properties. Another object of the present invention is to provide a composition which, when applied as a coating on a surface of a material, can easily release the contaminant therefrom in particular by rainfall or by washing with water. Specifically, the composition, when applied to a surface of a substrate to form a film, enables a contaminant or derivative thereof adhered onto the surface to be easily washed away by water. According to one aspect, the instant invention is directed to a NO<sub>x</sub> removing composition for use as a opaque coating on construction material surfaces, comprising at least: a) photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles having at least a de-NO<sub>x</sub> activity, b) particles having a de-HNO<sub>3</sub> activity, c) an opacifying agent, and d) a silicon based-material, in which are dispersed said particles, wherein said photocatalytic particles have a crystalline size ranging from 1 to 50 nm.
0007According to another aspect, the instant invention relates to a method for imparting self-cleaning properties towards atmospheric contaminants at the surface of a material, said method comprising at least the steps of: applying a composition according to the invention onto the surface of a material, drying or curing the said composition to provide an opaque coating system. The coating obtained according to the present invention, in particular after having been exposed to water and UV light, exhibits high durability and de-NO<sub>3</sub> efficiency as shown here-after in the examples.
0008Photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles:
0009The composition according to the present invention comprises at least dispersed photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles having at least a de-NO<sub>x</sub> activity with NO<sub>x</sub> meaning NO and/or NO<sub>2</sub>. According to a specific embodiment, said photocatalytic particles also exhibit a de-VOC activity. The term "de-NO<sub>x</sub> and/or de-VOC" activity as used herein refers to an ability to transform NO<sub>x</sub> and/or VOC species to their respective oxidized species like HNO<sub>3</sub> for NO<sub>x</sub>.
0010Specifically, in the present invention, the term "photocatalytic particles" used herein refers to particles based on a material which, when exposed to light (excitation light) having higher energy (i.e., shorter wavelength) than the energy gap between the conduction band and the valence band of the crystal, can cause excitation (photoexcitation) of electrons in the valence band to produce a conduction electron and a valence hole.
0011. The photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles contained in the composition according to the present invention basically include anatase or rutile forms of titanium oxide and mixtures thereof.
0012For example, the titanium dioxide particles of the coating, the nature of the particle may be predominantly the anatase crystalline form. "Predominantly" means that the level of anatase in the titanium dioxide particles of the coating composition is greater than 50% by mass. The particles of the coating composition may exhibit a level of anatase of greater than 80%.
0013The degree of crystallization and the nature of the crystalline phase are measured by X-ray diffraction.
0014The crystalline titanium dioxide particles incorporated in the coating exhibit a mean size ranging from 1 to 300 nm, preferably ranging from 2 to 100 nm, more preferably still from 5 to 50 nm. The diameters are measured by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and also XRD.
0015The preferred photocatalyst particles have a high surface area per gram, e.g., higher than 50 m /g and preferably above 100 m /g as measured by the BET method. In contrast, the surface area per gram of conventional TiO<sub>2</sub> pigments i.e. having photocatalytic properties is about 1-3O m /g. The difference in the much smaller particles and crystallites of the photocatalyst particles, gives rise to a much higher surface area.
0016Particularly convenient for the invention, are the photocatalytic TiO<sub>2</sub> sold, e.g. S5-300 A and B sold by Millennium Inorganic Chemicals Ltd or a proprietary neutral sol. The particles having a photocatalytic activity are added in an amount of 0.1 to 25%, preferably 0.5 to 20%, and most preferably 1 to 15%, by weight (expressed in dry matter) of the total weight of said composition.
0017In particular, the composition according to the invention includes at least 1% by weight of photocatalytic particles.
0018According to a specific embodiment, photocatalytic particles may also exhibit a de-VOC removing property.
0019The photocatalytic titanium dioxide particles may be used as a sol prepared by dispersion in water, as a water- or solvent-containing paste, or as a powder. Preferred examples of the dispersant used to prepare a sol include water, alcohols such as methanol, ethanol, isopropanol, n-butanol and isobutanol, and ketones such as methyl ethyl ketone and methyl isobutyl ketone.
0020De-HNCh particles: The composition according to the present invention comprises dispersed particles for removing the oxidized species HNO<sub>3</sub>, formed photocatalytically from NOx particles. These second type of particles are called "HNO<sub>3</sub> removing particles" or de-HNO<sub>3</sub> particles.
0021Illustrative examples of de-HNO<sub>3</sub> particles include basic compounds, in particular any insoluble carbonates and for example calcium carbonate, zinc carbonate, magnesium carbonate and mixtures thereof. Especially, preferred examples of such compounds include calcium carbonate. No particular limitation is imposed on its amount which should be sufficient to achieve the transformation of HNO<sub>3</sub> to its alkaline salt and, secondary, compatible with the coating including it. An amount of 0.05 to 50%, in particular of 0.1 to 30%, by weight (expressed in dry matter) of the total weight of said composition may be particularly convenient.
0022The ratio de-HNO<sub>3</sub> particles/photocatalytic particles may vary from 0.05 to 5, in particular from 0.1 to 3 and more particularly from 0.2 to 2.0.
0023Said particles i.e. de-HNO<sub>3</sub> particles and photocatalytic particles are included in the composition according to the invention in an amount greater than 1% by weight (expressed in dry matter), in particular lower than 50% and more particularly lower than 35% by weight of the total weight of the composition. Silicon-based component:
0024The composition of the present invention contains a silicon-based component wherein at least previously disclosed particles are entrapped. Specifically, in the present invention, the term "silicon-based material" used herein refers to any material based on silica or mixture thereof, which is able to provide a silicon based-film convenient for coating.
0025The silicon based-material advantageously provides a polysiloxane polymer film. According to one embodiment, the silicon based-material includes at least one polysiloxane derivative and in particular having the formula
0026<sub>1</sub><img file="WO2006030250A2_D0001.tif" /> wherein
0027- n has a value to provide an aqueous dispersion of polysiloxane having weight percentage solid ranging from 40 - 70%, and
0028- R<sub>1</sub> and R<sub>2</sub> are alkyl radicals of 1 to 20 carbon atoms or an aryl group such as phenyl.
0029Typically, the value of n ranges from about 5 to 2000.
0030Illustrative R<sub>1</sub> and R<sub>2</sub> radicals are alkyl groups (e.g., methyl, ethyl, propyl, butyl, 2-ethylbutyl, octyl), cycloaklyl groups (e.g., cyclohexyl, cyclopentyl), alkenyl groups (e.g., vinyl, hexenyl, allyl), aryl groups (e.g., phenyl, tolyl, xylyl, naphthyl, diphenyl) aralkyl groups (e.g., benzyl, phenylethyl), any of the foregoing groups in which some or all of the hydrogens bonded to the carbons have been substituted (such as with halogen atoms or cyano), or groups substituted with or containing, for example, amino groups, ether groups ( — O — ), carbonyl groups ( — CO — ), carboxyl groups ( — COOH) or sulfonyl groups ( — SO<sub>2</sub> — ) (e.g., chloromethyl, trifluoropropyl, 2-cyanoethyl, 3- cyanopropyl). In particular, the molecular weight of the polysiloxane ranges from 500 to
00315000, in particular from 1500 to 5000.
0032Particularly convenient for the instant invention care, polysiloxanes sold under the trademark WACKER BS 45 by the firm WACKER-Chemie GmbH. The content of the polysiloxane in the composition according to the present invention may be suitably determined. According to a specific embodiment, it may ranges from 1 to 60% by weight in particular from 5 to 50% by weight (expressed in dry matter) of the total weight of the composition. According to a specific embodiment, the composition according to the invention may also contain an organic binder.
0033Organic binder:
0034The organic binder may be chosen among copolymers of styrene/butadiene, and polymers and copolymers of esters of acrylic acid and in particular copolymers of polyvinylacrylic and styrene/acrylic esters.
0035In the present invention, styrene acrylic copolymer includes copolymers of styrene/acrylic esters thereof.
0036The inventors have unexpectedly discovered that such a compound was particularly advantageous to obtain a photocatalytically active coating having a high de- NO<sub>x</sub> efficiency.
0037Such effect was in particular noticed where this compound is a styrene/acrylic copolymer and more particularly used in a weight ratio of photocatalytic TiO<sub>2</sub> particles/organic binder and in particular styrene/acrylic copolymer ranging from 0.3 to 4.5, in particular from 0.5 to 3.6, more particularly from 1 to 3.5.
0038In particular, a styrene acrylic emulsion such as ACRONAL 290D from BASF GmbH may be used.
0039When the composition includes an organic binder, it is preferably introduced in place of apart of the silicone based-material. The composition may have a weight ratio of silicone based-material/organic binder ranging from 20 to 1.
0040Opacifying agents
0041According to the invention, the opacifying agent includes any organic or inorganic compound able to provide hiding power to the coating. It includes pigments, colorants and/or fillers as listed hereafter. More preferably, it includes at least one inorganic compound like titanium dioxide, either rutile or anastase. Such titanium dioxide pigments which are not photoactive are disclosed in US 6 342 099 (Millennium Inorganic Chemicals Inc.).
0042In particular, the particles of Tiona 595 and/or the particles of Tiona AT-I sold by Millennium Inorganic Chemicals Ltd may be used. The composition may contain such an opacifying agent in an amount ranging from 0.5 to 20% by weight in particular from 0.5 to 35% by weight.
0043The composition according to the present invention may include at least a solvent.
0044Examples of solvents usable herein include water, an organic solvent, and a mixed solvent composed of water and an organic solvent. Water, and alcohol is particularly preferred.
0045The composition according to the present invention may contain optional components provided that such an addition does not compromise the shelflife, UV durability, opacity or non-staining properties. Examples of such additional compounds include filler(s) like quartz, calcite, clay, talc, barite and/or Na-Al-silicate; pigments like TiO<sub>2</sub>, lithopone, and other inorganic pigments; dispersants like polyphosphates, polyacrylates, phosphonates, naphthene and lignin sulfonates; wetting agents like anionic, cationic, amphoteric and non-ionic surfactants; defoamers like silicon emulsions, hydrocarbons, long-chain alcohols; stabilizers like mostly cationic compounds; coalescents agents like alkali-stable esters, glycols, hydrocarbons; rheological additives like cellulose derivatives (CMC, HEC), xanthane gum, polyurethane, polyacrylate, modified starch, bentone and other lamellar silicates; water repellents like alkyl siliconates, siloxanes, wax emulsion, fatty acid Li salts and conventional fungicides or biocides.
0046The composition of the present invention may be applied onto the surface of the material by any suitable method, and examples of suitable methods include spray coating, dip coating, flow coating, spin coating, roll coating, brush coating, and sponge coating.
0047The composition after the application onto the surface of the substrate is then dried or cured to form a thin film. The term "dried or cured" used herein means that the silicon based-material contained in the composition according to the present invention is converted to a silicon-based film. Therefore, drying may be performed by either air drying or heat drying. Alternatively, ultraviolet irradiation or the like may be conducted to cause polymerization so far as the precursor is converted to a silicon film.
0048The composition according to the present invention may be applied on the surface of a high variety of materials. The material is not particularly limited, and examples thereof include metals, ceramics, glasses, plastics, woods, stones, cements, concretes, fibers, woven fabrics, and combinations of the above materials and laminates of the above materials. Specific examples to which the composition may be applied include housing, building materials; exterior of the buildings; interior of the buildings; sashes; windowpanes; structural materials; exterior of machineries and articles; dustproof covers and coatings; films, sheets, seals; tunnel and parking areas.
0049In preparing the preferred embodiments of the present invention, various alternatives may be used to facilitate the objectives of the invention.
0050The following examples are presented to aid in an understanding of the present invention and are not intended to, and should not be construed to limit the invention in any way. All alternatives, modifications and equivalents which may becomes obvious to those of ordinary skill in the art upon a reading of the present disclosure are included within the spirit and scope of the invention.
0051Examples
0052Compositions were prepared by using the following materials:
0053- photocatalytic titanium dioxide: PC 105 (42% TiO<sub>2</sub> by weight in water containing 1% of sodium hexametaphosphate) from Millennium Inorganic Chemicals,
0054- titanium dioxide pigments: Tiona 595 from Millennium Inorganic Chemicals,
0055- calcium carbonate (filler) Snowcal 60 from Omya Ltd.
0056- Hydroxy ethyl cellulose Natrosol 250 MR from Hercules Incorporated 3% solution in water,
0057- Wacker BS45: Polysiloxane polymer latex from Wacker Chemie GmbH, - Texanol: 2, 2, 4 trimethyl-1,3 pentanediol monoisobutyrate from Eastman
0058Chemical Company,
0059Sodium salt of polyacrylic acid: Dispex N40 from Allied Colloids Ltd. The paints are prepared in three parts termed A, B & C.
0060For part A, the TiO<sub>2</sub> is added to water to which is then added Natrosol 250MR, Dipex N40 and Snowcal-60.
0061The components are mixed under high shear.
0062For part B, the polysiloxane polymer is added to part A and then part C, the Texanol is added to parts A and B.
0063The compositions of so-prepared paints are listed in Table I.
0064<img file="WO2006030250A2_D0002.tif" />
0065The percentages stated in the table are the percentages expressed in commercial product i.e. dry matter + solvent.
0066Table I
0067Method for determination of coating photoactivitv towards methylene blue Irradiating Titanium dioxide with Ultra Violet light results in the production of holes and electrons which are then capable of forming reactive species such peroxide, hydroperoxide and hydroxyl ions. These are then capable of oxidising organic molecules such as methylene blue to water, carbon dioxide and nitrogen containing species with the associated loss of colour. The level of photoactivity is monitored by measuring the L* (brightness) and b* value (blue/yellowness).
0068The method is most suitable for coatings that are wetted with water such as latex or emulsion paints. The porosity of the coatings will affect the amount of stain that the films will pick up but this is minimised by the addition of a thickener to the methylene blue solution. There may also be colour changes of the blue due to pH effects.
0069Preparation of Methylene Blue solution
0070The methylene blue is first dissolved in de-mineralised water to a concentration of 0.05% by weight. Using slow speed stirring the equivalent of 1% Natrasol MR<sup>®</sup>
0071(Hydroxy Ethyl Cellulose) is then added. In order for the Natrosol to hydrate, the pH is raised to approximately 8.0 with dilute ammonia. This requires only a few drops. The solution is stirred for a further hour to completely hydrate the Natrosol.
0072Paint Film Staining
0073The paint film to be tested is over-coated with a film of the methylene blue solution by drawing down a film using a spiral wound rod. The test film has previously been prepared by applying a wet paint film to 30 microns thick Melinex or Mylar sheet. The spiral wound rods are specified to give various film thicknesses but those giving 25 to 50 microns wet film are generally employed. The coatings are left to dry at 23 deg C. 50% RH overnight.
0074Measurement
0075A suitable sized area of the coatings is cut from the film and the L* and b* measurements are made using a Spectrophotometer. The paint films are then exposed to light from an Atlas Suntest machine set to give a light output of 551 W/m<sup>2</sup> from 250 to 765 run. The paint films are re-measured at suitable intervals, typically 18 to 24 hours.
0076The difference in L* and b* between the unexposed and exposed results is a measure of the photoactivity of the coating towards self-cleaning. The data are provided in the following table.
0077<img file="WO2006030250A2_D0003.tif" />
0078Table II
0079Method for Determination of durability
0080The durability of the coatings was assessed by preparing coatings on stainless steel panels and exposing them to simulated weathering conditions in a machine designed for that application. The amount of weight which the coating losses during the exposure was a measure of its durability.
0081The stainless steel panels measure 75 by 150 mm and were 0.75 mm thick. The panels were weighed to 0.0001 g before and after application of the paint film so that the weight of the coating can be calculated.
0082The panels can be coated by any convenient means including brushing, spraying, spinning or by spiral rod applicator. Only the surface to be exposed was coated. The dry film thickness was typically in the range of 20 to 50 microns.
0083The coatings were left to dry for 7 days before exposure in the Weatherometer. The Weatherometer used for the exposures was a Ci65A made by Atlas Electric Devices, Chicago. The light source was a 6.5 kW Xenon source emitting 0.5 W/m<sup>2</sup> UV at 340 nm. The black panel temperature was 63 degrees Celsius. Water spray was applied for 18 minutes out of every 120 minutes and there was no dark cycle.
0084The so-obtained values are submitted in the Figure 1. They show that only about 15 or 38% by weight of the initial total weight of the coating obtained from Fl and F2 according to the invention have been lost after 1500 hours exposure.
0085Determining of NO/NO? removal by coatings
0086The paint films were irradiated with 0.5 W/m<sup>2</sup> UV at 340 nm for 168 hours using a filtered Xenon light source (Atlas Weatherometer Ci65A) before carrying out the test. This either activates or increases the activity of the coatings over and above the un- exposed coatings. For the NO<sub>x</sub> measurements, the samples were irradiated with a UV fluorescent tube which emits 10 W/m<sup>2</sup> UV in the range of 300 to 400 run. The NO<sub>x</sub> that is used is NO at 225 ppb in nitrogen.
00871. Equipment
0088Nitrogen Oxides Analyser Model ML9841B
0089- ex Monitor Europe
0090UV Lamp Model VL-6LM 365 & 312 nanometer wavelength - ex BDH
0091Air-tight sample chamber 3 channel gas mixer
0092- ex Brooks Instruments, Holland
00932. Gases
0094NO Nitric Oxide
0095Compressed air containing water vapour to give 50% Relative Humidity in mixed gas stream.
00963. Method
00971. Switch on Analyser and exhaust pump. Ensure exhaust pipe goes to atmosphere.
00982. Allow to warm-up. Several internal components need to reach operating temperature before the analyser will begin operation. The process will, typically, take 60 mins from cold start and the message START-UP SEQUENCE ACTIVE will be displayed until operating conditions are met.
00993. After warm-up turn on air and test gas supply to the gas mixer.
01004. Calibrate the Analyser on the Test gas supply only, (turn the air channel to zero on the gas mixer), according to the manufacturer's instructions.
01015. After calibration turn OFF the test gas supply at the gas mixer. 6. Place test sample in the test chamber and seal chamber. 7. Turn on both air and test gas and adjust each until required level of test gas is reached, shown by the Analyser output. RECORD level. Check that the Relative Humidity is 50% within plus or minus 5%.
01028. Switch on the UV lamp when test gas levels are at desired point.
01039. Allow the irradiated sample value to reach equilibrium, typically up to 3 mins.
010410. RECORD the value shown on the analyser.
010511. Report "Initial Value" i.e. no UV, "Final Value" after UV exposure for set period.
0106INITIAL VALUE - FINAL VALUE * 100
010712. % NOx Removed =
INITIAL VALUE
0109The data are provided in the following table.
0110<img file="WO2006030250A2_D0004.tif" />
11 members in 8 offices
Members11
| Document | Office | Kind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| AU2004323298A1 | Australia | A1 | |
| WO2006030250A2 | World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) | A2 | |
| MX2007003021A | Mexico | A | |
| MX2007003021A | Mexico | A | |
| EP1805268A2This record | European Patent Office (EPO) | A2 | |
| WO2006030250A3 | World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) | A3 | |
| BRPI0419048A | Brazil | A | |
| BRPI0419048A | Brazil | A | |
| US2008003367A1 | United States of America | A1 | |
| CN101103078A | China | A | |
| JP2008513188A | Japan | A |
10 legal events, as the office reported them to INPADOC
Over the term
Point at a mark for the eventEvents
| Event | Code | |
|---|---|---|
| Application deemed to be withdrawnWithdrawn18D | 18D | |
| Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patentGrantedSTATUS: THE APPLICATION IS DEEMED TO BE WITHDRAWNSTAA | STAA | |
| First examination report despatched17Q | 17Q | |
| Request for extension of the european patent (deleted)DAX | DAX | |
| Deferred search report published (corrected)R17D | R17D | |
| Party data changed (applicant data changed or rights of an application transferred)RAP1 | RAP1 | |
| Request for examination filed17P | 17P | |
| Designated contracting statesAK | AK | |
| Request for extension of the european patentAX | AX | |
| Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phaseORIGINAL CODE: 0009012PUAI | PUAI |
Numbers
- Publication
- 1805268
- Application
- 47693643
Titles3
- German
- GEEIGNETE ZUSAMMENSETZUNG ZUR BEREITSTELLUNG EINES ENTSTICKENDEN ÜBERZUGS AUF EINER WERKSTOFFOBERFLÄCHE
- English
- COMPOSITION USEFUL FOR PROVIDING NOX REMOVING COATING ON MATERIAL SURFACE
- French
- COMPOSITION UTILE POUR APPLIQUER UN REVETEMENT DE SUPPRESSION DE NOX SUR UNE SURFACE DE MATERIAU
Classification
- CPC, 16
- B01J37/0219
- B01J21/063
- B01J37/0009
- C03C17/007
- C03C2217/445
- C03C2217/477
- C03C2217/71
- C04B41/4961
- C04B2111/2061
- C08K3/22
- C09D5/1618
- C09D7/61
- C09D7/67
- B01J35/40
- B01J35/39
- B01J35/45
- IPC, 12
- C09D5 00
- C03C17 00
- C03C17 25
- C03C17 34
- C03C17 245
- C03C23 00
- C04B41 00
- C04B41 45
- C04B41 52
- B01J35 40
- B01J35 45
- C09D7 61
Designated states33
- Contracting states, 28
- Austria
- Belgium
- Bulgaria
- Switzerland
- Cyprus
- Czechia
- Germany
- Denmark
- Estonia
- Spain
- Finland
- France
- United Kingdom
- Greece
- Hungary
- Ireland
- Italy
- Liechtenstein
- Luxembourg
- Monaco
- Netherlands (Kingdom of the)
- Poland
- Portugal
- Romania
and 4 moreShow fewer
- Sweden
- Slovenia
- Slovakia
- Türkiye
- Extension states, 5
- Albania
- Croatia
- Lithuania
- Latvia
- North Macedonia