Enhanced energy absorbing materials

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Field of the Invention

0001The invention relates to enhanced energy absorbing materials . The materials have utility in the manufacture of ballistic vests, hard and soft armor, life protective systems, and anti-ballistic systems.

Description of the Prior Art

0002Materials made from ballistic grade fibers are known in the art, such as the well known aramid fiber-based material sold under the tradename Kevlar®. Methods of processing these materials into finished articles are also known. Ballistic fiber materials, ballistic vest constructions and other materials and methods are described, for example, in <patcit id="pcit0001" dnum="US6276255B"><text>U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,276,255</text></patcit>; <patcit id="pcit0002" dnum="US6268301B"><text>6,268,301</text></patcit>; <patcit id="pcit0003" dnum="US6266819B"><text>6,266,819</text></patcit>; <patcit id="pcit0004" dnum="US6248676B"><text>6,248,676</text></patcit>; and <patcit id="pcit0005" dnum="US6026509B"><text>6,026,509</text></patcit>. The materials and methods described in these United States Patents may be used, without limitation, in combination with the novel aspects of the invention described herein.

0003Needle felting, sometimes referred to herein as needle punching or simply needling, is a process used in the textile industry in which an element such as a barbed needle is passed into and out of a fabric to entangle the fibers. Needle felting itself is not new, and is described for example in <patcit id="pcit0006" dnum="US5989375A"><text>U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,989,375</text></patcit>; <patcit id="pcit0007" dnum="US5388320A"><text>5,388,320</text></patcit>; <patcit id="pcit0008" dnum="US5323523A"><text>5,323,523</text></patcit>;<patcit id="pcit0009" dnum="US3829939A"><text> 3,829,939</text></patcit>; and<patcit id="pcit0010" dnum="US6405417B"><text> 6,405,417</text></patcit>.

0004The use of quasi-unidirectional fabric layers in ballistic materials is known. For example, a quasi-unidirectional fabric is commercially available from Barrday Inc. of Cambridge Ontario, Canada under the trade name Sentinel^®. This fabric comprises at least two unidirectional fabric layers cross-laid in a 0/90 configuration relative to each other. These ballistic resistant yarns are woven into a second fabric composed of yarns having substantially lower tenacity and tensile modulus than the ballistic cross-laid yarns to hold the ballistic yarns in place. This method of construction, in theory, forms a fabric substantially stronger than conventional woven materials due to the lack of bending in the ballistic resistant yarns that results from a traditional weaving operation. However, there is a limitation in the performance of such materials due to the inherent lack of stability in the structure. Because the ballistic yarns are not secured in position during a ballistic event, they will spread and allow passage through the interstices by a projectile.

0005<patcit id="pcit0011" dnum="WO9320271A"><text>WO 93/20271</text></patcit> is directed to a non-woven layer that consists of short polydefin fibres. <patcit id="pcit0012" dnum="WO9320271A"><text>WO 93/20271</text></patcit> directly addresses the need of improving the specific energy absorption (SEA) and ballistic impact divided by the areal density (weight per m²).

0006The material provided in Example VI of <patcit id="pcit0013" dnum="WO9320271A"><text>WO 93/20271</text></patcit> utilizes the calendered felt F₀, prepared in Example I, and needles it together with the Dyneema 504^R fabric. The ballistic structure of Example VI provides a highly rigidised material with an areal density of 2.6 kg/m² and a layer thickness of 8mm, i.e. an extremely densified material.

0007<patcit id="pcit0014" dnum="WO0150898A"><text>WO 01/50898</text></patcit> relates to a knife-stab resistant composite, wherein the layers of fabric in the composite are woven para-aramids with low fabric tightness and are arranged in the composite free to move relative to one another.

0008Thus, there continues to be a need for fabrics with high ballistic resistant performance in a dense, compact format which can be conveniently manufactured.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

0009The invention is directed to a ballistic material according to the attached claims, comprising at least one woven layer of ballistic grade fiber and at least one nonwoven layer of fabric, said nonwoven layer entangled with the woven layer in a direction substantially perpendicular to an x-y plane of the ballistic material, preferably by a needle felting process. As used herein, "woven" includes unidirectional and quasi-unidirectional fabrics.

0010The invention may be embodied as a stack of woven layers (such as the quasi-unidirectional Sentinel® fabric mentioned above) and a nonwoven layer which is attached to and entangled with the stack of woven layers on one or both faces to form an integral structure having an areal density of about 0.07 pounds per square foot (342 g/m²) to about 0.32 pounds per square foot (1,562g/m²). The resulting integral structure offers advantages in handling and subsequent manufacturing because the material is ready-to-use and does not require assembly of individual ballistic fabric layers.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

0011<figref idref="f0001">Fig. 1</figref> is an exploded view of a ballistic material showing nonwoven layers, layers of ballistic grade material, and a graphical representation of the needle felting elements.

0012<figref idref="f0002">Fig. 2</figref> is a graph showing the performance of ballistic materials according to the invention compared to prior art ballistic materials.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

0013Referring to <figref idref="f0001">Figure 1</figref>, ballistic material (4) according to the invention extends generally in the x-y plane. At least one and preferably a stack of layers (1) comprises ballistic grade woven fabrics, such as layers of unidirectional fiber tows or yarns. If unidirectional tows or yarns are used, these are preferably cross-laid at 90 degree angles with respect to one another and held in place by lightly stitching, sewing or interweaving lightweight yarns such that the material remains manageable during the manufacturing processes without separating and without bending the individual tows or yarns.

0014In a unidirectional fabric the tows all run in the same direction. In a quasi-unidirectional fabric the tows may be laid in more than one direction. As used herein, "unidirectional" encompasses both unidirectional and quasi-unidirectional fabric, unless the context requires otherwise.

0015Fabrics woven from ballistic fibers in a variety of weave styles including plain, basket, twill, satin and other complex weaves including, but not limited to, unidirectional, quasi unidirectional, and three dimensional materials, alone or in combination, can be used as the woven layers. As used herein "woven" fabrics includes stitched tows and knits. A plurality of knitted layers or stitched tows may be used with the invention.

0016In preferred embodiments, stack of layers (1) comprises multiple layers of quasi-unidirectional fabric such as that commercially available from Barrday Inc. of Cambridge Ontario, Canada, under the trade name Sentinel®. This material is a fabric having unidirectional ballistic resistant yarns in at least two layers cross-laid at ninety degree angles relative to each other. The ballistic resistant yarns are then held in place by being woven in a second fabric composed of yarns having substantially lower tenacity and tensile modulus than the ballistic cross-laid yarns. Alternatively, the layer(s) (1) may simply be woven ballistic grade fibers such as Kevlar® (para-aramid fibers), poly (p-phenylene-2, 6-benzobisoxazole) (PBO), Spectra® (high molecular weight polyethylene fibers) or ballistic nylons.

0017The ballistic grade layer(s) (1) is combined with nonwoven batting layers (2) or sandwiched between layers of nonwoven batting material. After aligning the material, the stack is subj ected to a needle felting process to attach the layers to each other, increase the density and stabilize the finished fabric.

0018In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the nonwoven layer is composed of a high performance ballistic resistant fiber, especially a ballistic resistant fiber having a tenacity of at least 15 grams per denier (13.5 g/decitex) and a tensile modulus of at least 400 grams per denier (360 g/decitex) (hereinafter "ballistic grade nonwoven fibers"). The at least one layer (2) comprises staple para-aramid fibers. In a non-inventive embodiment, the nonwoven layer may be selected from natural fibers and synthetic fibers. Natural fiber includes cotton, wool, sisal, linen, jute and silk. Synthetic fiber includes aramid fibers, extended chain polyethylene fibers, PBO fibers, regenerated cellulose, rayon, polynosic rayon, cellulose esters, acrylics, modacrylic, polyamides, polyolefins, polyester, rubber, synthetic rubber, saran, glass, polyacrylonitrile, acrylonitrile-vinyl chloride copolymers, polyhexamethylene adipamide, polycaproamide, polyundecanoamide, polyethylene, polypropylene and polyethylene terephthalate. It is generally possible to use non-ballistic grade nonwoven fibers for the nonwoven layer and still produce a material having satisfactory ballistic performance for some applications.

0019The needle felting step stabilizes the fabric layers and prevents the individual tows from separating. In a preferred embodiment, the nonwoven layer(s) (2) comprises ballistic grade staple fibers, and the needle felting step entangles these fibers in the interstices of the woven fabric or cross-laid tows or yarns so that some are in a direction substantially perpendicular to the x-y plane of the fabric and mechanically connects the fabric plies. This mechanical bond prevents a high-energy projectile from spreading the individual tows of the unidirectional fabric layers, as the projectile acts to penetrate the material. While entanglement of nonwoven fibers prevents tows from separating, the process also prevents delamination of the individual layers. In addition, this stabilization process increases the density of the material, thereby engaging more fibers per unit volume. In preferred embodiments, a nonwoven layer is attached on one side of a stack of fabric layers by needlefelting; however a ready-to-use ballistic material according to the invention may have nonwoven layers attached on both sides thereof.

0020The thickness of the finished material is not particularly limited and may range from about .025 in. (0.0635 cm) to about 4.0 in. (10.06 cm), preferably from about 0.10 in. (0.254 cm) to about 2.0 in. (5.03 cm), depending on the end use and the desired number of woven fabric layers. The number of woven fabric layers (including unidirectional or quasi-unidirectional layers) in a stack is likewise determined by the type of woven layers used and the end use. More than two, for example four to five hundred, and preferably four to twenty layers of woven fabric attached to a nonwoven layer is appropriate to form a core material for many life protection systems applications. In embodiments, a first stack having a plurality of woven layers and a nonwoven layer on a face thereof is prepared by needle punching, and a second stack having similar construction is prepared. The first stack and the second stack may be then needlepunched together so that the nonwoven layers face opposite sides of the material.

0021The needle felting of the nonwoven layer or layers and the stack of woven layers must be varied according to the woven fabric type. The variation of the needling process may include the amount of needle punches per unit area and/or the depth of those punches. The optimal amount and type of needling, and the amount of nonwoven fiber can be determined by ballistic testing, preferably performed using standard ballistic testing procedures, such as Military Standard (Mil Std) 662 F or National Institute of Justice (NIJ) Standard 0104.04 .

0022For example only and not by way of limitation, materials according to the Examples herein were prepared by placing nonwoven material (which may be manufactured, for example, by dry laid carding and mechanical needling) having an areal weight of about 2.5 oz/sq.yd. (84.78 g/m²) and a thickness of about 0.060 in. (0.152 cm) at the inlet side of a needlepunch loom on an automatic roll feed system timed to feed the material at the same rate as the machine speed. Layers of quasi-unidirectional woven materials were arranged in a stack configuration on the inlet side of the needlepunch loom. The leading edge of the woven layers were then tacked together to a leader fabric (a fabric used solely to bring another material through the needlepunch loom) for stability. The nonwoven fabric was fed to the needlepunch loom edge and the entire system of nonwoven and woven materials was fed into the needlepunch loom for consolidation. The step of superposing a nonwoven layer on a stack of woven layers includes placing a nonwoven layer above the stack of woven layers on the loom. Layers of nonwoven fabric may be interleaved between layers of woven fabric.

0023The first pass through the needlepunch loom used 400 penetration/sq.in. (62 penetrations/cm²) with an 8 mm penetration of needle into the materials. The type of needle used is a finishing needle. The machine ran at 1.6 yards/minute (1.46 m/min.). The consolidated material is then run through the loom a second time with the nonwoven component remaining face-up. The second pass is to ensure that all of the woven layers are mechanically entangled in the z-direction with the nonwoven layer. The second pass through the loom was at 600 penetrations/sq. inch (93 penetrations/cm²) with an 8 mn penetration of needle into the materials. For this pass, the machine ran at 2.0 yards/minute (1.83 m/min.).

0024As a result, the nonwoven layer was firmly attached to the woven layers and the finished material was ready for use in the manufacture of ballistic articles without requiring assembly of individual layers.

0025After needle felting, the material may be further consolidated by calendering the needle felted stack through nip rolls. Calendering in a nip roll further densifies the system and reduces the overall thickness profile of the material. Calendering is the process of applying pressure, and sometimes heat, to a material for further densification. The density of a consolidated material is generally increased between 40 to 55 percent and the thickness decreased by between 30 to 35 percent. The combined result of these steps is expected to increase the performance of the system in terms of ballistic testing performed in accordance with NIJ standards for projectile penetration, back face signature, and against fragment simulating projectiles (FSP's). The finished material may further be enhanced by the application of a water repellant treatment, or other coating or treatment.

0026Methods of mechanical entanglement, other than needlepunching, can be used, such as hydroentanglement, the use of the water or airjets, and the like.

0027Due to increased ballistic performance of fabrics according to the invention, less material can be used to achieve equivalent ballistic performance making the end products lighter weight, more flexible and thus more comfortable as a ballistic garment. The process adheres individual layers together through the entanglement process, which increases the interlaminar shear strength and communication between adjacent layers during a ballistic event. This effect allows energy from an impacting projectile to be more readily absorbed and evenly distributed throughout the fabric layers.

0028The thickness and weight of the finished ballistic material vary depending on the amount of fibers used in the nonwoven layer, the degree of needle felting, and the type and number of woven layers in the stack. The format of the product also depends on the intended end use. In conventional ballistic vest apparel, the vest typically consists of multiple layers of woven ballistic grade materials that are then stitched, and in some cases laminated to hold the layers in place. The layers, commonly known as a pack, are then covered with a more wearable dress cover material. In the present invention, the introduction of the insertion of a preassembled core for the ballistic protective component is new. The core is considered the base ballistic protection from which the remaining level of ballistic protection is built. Several cores may be added, as well as other ballistic grade materials known in the art, to obtain the desired ballistic performance of the pack. For a ballistic vest, a core material may be made with a single layer of nonwoven material attached by needlepunching to a stack of woven layers (which is defined to include unidirectional and quasi-unidirectional layers) to form a material having a thickness in a range of about 0.1 in. (0.254 cm) to about 0.3 in. (0.76 cm), typically about 0.25 in. (0.63 cm), which may be cut as a single layer to form a vest.

0029Generally, an important goal for ballistic materials (particularly wearable materials) is to increase ballistic performance at lighter material weight. A suitable material weight for a core ballistic material is in a range of about 0.07 Ibs/ft² (342 g/m²) to about 0,32 lbs/ft² (1,562 g/m²), and preferably about 0.18 lbs/ft² (878 g/m²) to about 0.32 lbs/ft² (1,562 g/m²).

0030In addition to the performance benefit, the needling process forms a ballistic core material that does not require further assembly of the layers. For example, if the fabric were used by a ballistic vest manufacturer to create a ballistic vest, the manufacturer may cut a unit of material from a single roll of fabric that has been tested to meet specific ballistic requirements. This method avoids the additional labor of cutting many layers of ballistic fabric, stacking, counting and quilting or stitching layers together. The core material is thus "ready-made" ballistic material, offering economic as well as performance advantages in a single monolithic core material that can then be used as a building block to create various constructions in numerous potential products for both hard and soft armor materials.

0031The core material made according to the invention has other uses apart from the manufacture of ballistic vests and other ballistic garments. For example, the material may be resinated and used as hard armor or hard composite armor, and in both hard and soft containment structures, bomb containment structures and mitigating panels. The core materials comprising several prefabricated layers provides for ease-of-use in many of these applications.

0032Conventionally, processing by secondary steps enhances the use of fabric in vests, blankets, and composites, particularly for bullet resistant applications. During a ballistic event, energy is transferred in several directions: orthogonally to the flight of the projectile along the yarns of the fabric layer and simultaneously longitudinally to the path of the projectile into the pack. This longitudinal energy transfer occurs before the projectile penetrates the fabric layer. This transfer of energy into the pack plays a significant role in stopping the projectile The layers of fabric must be in intimate contact for efficient longitudinal energy transfer. Therefore, the fabric layers are conventionally processed to maintain this contact. The secondary step(s) are also used to stiffen the ballistic pack and/or to reduce or spread the energy (blunt trauma) that is transferred to the body during the stop of a ballistic threat. Fabric subjected to a ballistic event is pushed back into a cone shape by the projectile during impact. The cone has a larger surface area than the initial flat surface, and the secondary processing permits the fabric to spread open in order to cover the increased area. Such conventional secondary processing steps also help to prevent the fabric layers from opening up during the ballistic event. Conventional secondary steps that may be used include sewing and/or lamination of the fabric layers. The use of core technology according to the invention replaces these conventional secondary steps by increasing the intimate contact between the layers. In addition, the core technology provides this contact in a more efficient manner. The mechanical entanglement of the core technology not only provides contact between fabric layers, but also increases contact between the tows within each fabric layer. However, in some applications conventional secondary processes, including sewing and/or lamination, may be used in combination with mechanical entanglement.

0033Coatings known in the art, such as a water repellant polytetrafluoroethylene coating, may advantageously be applied to the finished fabric to improve the performance.

0034The following fabrics were prepared :

EXAMPLE 1

0035A nonwoven fabric consisting ofpara-aramid fibers was superposed on eight cross-laid layers of a para-aramid quasi-unidirectional fabric to form a stack. The stack was subjected to needle felting consolidation to obtain a thickness of about 0.11 inches (0.28 cm) and a weight of about 0.24 lbs/sq. ft. (1.171 kg/m²). The resulting material exhibited enhanced ballistic performance when compared to a stack of cross laid layers of quasi-unidirectional fabric of comparable thickness, as demonstrated in the Comparative Examples below.

EXAMPLE 2 (Comparative)

0036A nonwoven fabric consisting of para-aramid fibers was superposed on eight layers of a para-aramid quasi-unidirectional fabric to form a stack. The stack (prior to subsequent steps) had a cumulative thickness of about 0.25 inches. The stack was subjected to needle felting consolidation. Subsequently seven additional woven layers (quasi-unidirectional) and a second nonwoven layer were simultaneously attached to the original stack via needling. The second nonwoven layer was attached to the exposed woven side. Thus, the manufacture is similar to that of Example 1, except that a plurality of stacks of woven fabric and a plurality of nonwoven layers were used. The finished fabric had an areal density of about 0.48 lbs/sq. ft. (2.342 kg/m²), a thickness of about 0.2 in. (0.51 cm).

EXAMPLE 3 (Comparative)

0037A nonwoven fabric consisting of para-aramid fibers was superposed on ten cross-laid layers of a para-aramid plain woven fabric to form a stack The stack was subjected to needle felting consolidation. The finished material had a cumulative thickness of about 0.13 in. (0.33 cm) and a weight of about 0.38 lbs/sq. ft. (1.854 kg/m²). The core material design of this Example is similar to that of Example 1 except that a plain weave woven layer was used.

EXAMPLE 4 (Comparative)

0038A nonwoven fabric consisting of para-aramid fibers was superposed on ten cross-laid layers of a para-aramid plain woven fabric and consolidated by needlepunching to form a first stack similar to the stack of Example 3. A second stack, substantially identical to the first stack, was attached back-to-back with the first stack so that the woven layers were sandwiched between the nonwoven layers. The finished fabric had an areal density of about 0.76 lbs/sq. ft. (3.709 kg/m²) and a thickness of about 0.24 in. (0.61 cm).

EXAMPLE 5

0039The fabric of Example 1 was further subjected to a calendering step between nip rolls, which carry the material between and through the rolls and out the other side via the force of the rolls. The material density was increased to 43 lb/ft³ (0.69 g/cm³) with a thickness of 0.135 inches (0.34 cm), an increase in density of 50 percent, and a decrease in thickness of 33 percent.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLES:

0040A woven/nonwoven material configuration combined via mechanical needling according to the invention was compared to three standard ballistic materials which were prepared using the same woven material and different consolidation methods, for ballistic performance. Ballistic performance was measured using Mil Std 662. V-50, V-0 and corresponding backface signature results were compared. V-50 is commonly known as the measurement of the velocity at which fifty-percent of the projectiles fired penetrate the ballistic material under evaluation. V-0 is commonly known as the measurement of the velocity at which zero percent of the projectiles fired penetrate the ballistic material under evaluation. Backface signature measurements are determined by recording the depth at which the material penetrates into a clay backstop. NIJ has determined that a backface signature of 44 mm or less is considered survivable.

0041Comparative Example 1: An "x-stitch" was used to combine individual layers of Sentinel® quasi-unidirectional woven fabric. The total weight of the material was about 0.5 lbs/sq. ft. (2.44 kg/m²).

0042Comparative Example 2: A 1-inch quilt stitching was used to combine individual layers of Sentinel® quasi-unidirectional woven fabric. The total weight of the material was about 0.5lbs/sq. ft. (2.44 kg/m²). This quilted format is the typical design of conventional ballistic fabrics.

0043Comparative Example 3: Layers of Sentinel® quasi-unidirectional woven fabric were adhered to one another using a polymeric laminate. Heat was then applied to the total laminate structure to create the final consolidated material. This material is rigid and weighs 0.5lbs/sq. ft. (2.44 kg/m²).

0044Inventive Example: A needle punched nonwoven layer was used to combine a stack of Sentinel® quasi-unidirectional woven fabric to obtain a total weight of about 0.5 lbs/sq. ft. (2.44 kg/m²). The core compounds were formed using the method described in Example 1.

0045Table 1 lists the performance of Comparative Examples 1 through 3 compared to the Inventive Example for both the V-50 value, in feet per second, and the backface signature, in millimeters. The fabric according to the invention performs better than the Comparative Examples 1 through 3 for both V-50 and backface signature. Although Comparative Example 2 performs nearly the same for V-50, the quilt stitched material is more cumbersome to manufacture and has an unsatisfactory backface signature. Comparative Example 3 exhibited fair performance but Comparative Example 3 is a rigid material that does not conform to the body.

0046<tables id="tabl0001" num="0001"><table frame="none"><title>Table 1</title><tgroup cols="6" colsep="0" rowsep="0"><colspec colnum="1" colname="col1" colwidth="23mm" /><colspec colnum="2" colname="col2" colwidth="19mm" /><colspec colnum="3" colname="col3" colwidth="40mm" /><colspec colnum="4" colname="col4" colwidth="20mm" /><colspec colnum="5" colname="col5" colwidth="26mm" /><colspec colnum="6" colname="col6" colwidth="28mm" /><thead><row><entry valign="top" /><entry valign="top" /><entry valign="top" /><entry valign="top" /><entry namest="col5" nameend="col6" rowsep="1" align="center" valign="top"><b>Results</b></entry></row><row><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>Sample</b></entry><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>Stitching</b></entry><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>Areal Density lbs/sq. ft.</b></entry><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>Projectile</b></entry><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>V-50 (fps|m/s)</b></entry><entry rowsep="1" align="center"><b>Backface (mm)</b></entry></row></thead><tbody><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 1</entry><entry>x-stitch</entry><entry align="char" char="." charoff="5">0.5</entry><entry align="center">9 mm</entry><entry align="right">990|302</entry><entry align="center">70</entry></row><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 2</entry><entry>1 inch quilt</entry><entry align="char" char="." charoff="5">0.5</entry><entry align="center">9 mm</entry><entry align="right">1241|378</entry><entry align="center">52</entry></row><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 3</entry><entry>None</entry><entry align="char" char="." charoff="5">0.5</entry><entry align="center">9 mm</entry><entry align="right">1115|340</entry><entry align="center">40</entry></row><row><entry>Inventive Ex.</entry><entry>None</entry><entry align="char" char="." charoff="5">0.5</entry><entry align="center">9 mm</entry><entry align="right">1264|385</entry><entry align="center">34</entry></row></tbody></tgroup></table></tables>

0047Table 2 shows the percentage improvement for the Inventive Example versus each of the Comparative Examples.

0048<tables id="tabl0002" num="0002"><table frame="none"><title>Table 2</title><tgroup cols="3" colsep="0" rowsep="0"><colspec colnum="1" colname="col1" colwidth="22mm" /><colspec colnum="2" colname="col2" colwidth="15mm" /><colspec colnum="3" colname="col3" colwidth="19mm" /><thead><row><entry valign="top" /><entry namest="col2" nameend="col3" align="center" valign="top"><b>% Improvement</b></entry></row><row><entry valign="top" /><entry align="center" valign="top"><b>V50</b></entry><entry align="center" valign="top"><b>Backface</b></entry></row></thead><tbody><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 1</entry><entry align="center">28%</entry><entry align="center">62%</entry></row><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 2</entry><entry align="center">27%</entry><entry align="center">35%</entry></row><row><entry>Comp. Ex. 3</entry><entry align="center">12%</entry><entry align="center">15%</entry></row></tbody></tgroup></table></tables>

0049<figref idref="f0002">Figure 2</figref> displays a graphical interpretation of the V-0 to V-50 results for Comparative Examples 2 and 3 and the Inventive Example, showing the advantage of the needle punch consolidation versus conventional consolidation methods. The material incorporating needling technology enhances and improves the ballistic performance as shown from the V-0 to V-50 data.

0050Generally the slope of the performance curve for traditional woven ballistic materials is shaped like an "S". This is seen for Comparative Example 2, which is a conventional ballistic material design. Comparative Example 3, which is a rigid material, would not be expected to have the S shaped profile. Depending on the type of material, the slope of the V-0 to V-50 curve can be gradual or steep. A gradual "S" shape makes the true and consistent V-0 value of a given design difficult to state accurately and is therefore less preferable. As shown in <figref idref="f0002">Figure 2</figref>, the use of needling technology according to the invention increases the slope of the curve, which allows a more accurate and reliable statement of V-0. This change in the slope also is an indication of the change in consistency of the materials used to build the technology. The slope of the curve for the needled materials shows an increased consistency in the overall material construction for the Inventive Example.