Apparatus for detecting cell reversal in rechargeable batteries

Description of equivalent WO 9829910 A2

APPARATUS FOR DETECTING CELL REVERSAL IN RECHARGEABLE

BATTERIES

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

0004In general the present invention relates to rechargeable batteries More specifically, the present invention relates to an apparatus for detecting cell reversal in rechargeable batteries

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

0006Rechargeable batteries are used in a variety of industrial and commercial applications such as fork lifts, golf carts, uninterruptable power supplies, and electric vehicles

0007Rechargeable lead-acid batteries are a useful power source for starter motors for internal combustion engines Rechargeable alkaline batteries are used in numerous consumer devices such as calculators, portable radios, and cellular phones They are often configured into a sealed battery pack that is designed as an integral part of a specific device Rechargeable alkaline batteries can also be configured as larger batteries that can be used, for example, in industrial, aerospace, and electric vehicle applications In rechargeable alkaline batteries, weight and portability are important considerations It is also advantageous for rechargeable alkaline batteries to have long operating lives without the necessity of periodic maintenance

0008There are many known types of nickel-based alkaline cells such as nickel cadmium ("Ni-Cd"), nickel metal hydride ("Ni-MH"), nickel hydrogen, nickel zinc, and nickel iron cells In a Ni-Cd battery, cadmium metal is the active material in the negative electrode Ni-Cd batteries have a positive electrode comprised of nickel hydroxide material The negative and positive electrodes are spaced apart in the alkaline electrolyte Upon application of an electrical potential across the materials of a Ni-Cd battery, the negative electrode undergoes the reaction shown in equation (1 ) charge

0009Cd(OH)₂ + 2e- < - > Cd + 2OH^" (1) discharge

0010During discharge, this reaction is reversed, Cd is oxidized to Cd(OH)₂ and electrons are released.

0011The reactions that take place at the positive electrode of a Ni-Cd battery are also reversible. The reactions at a nickel hydroxide positive electrode in a Ni-Cd battery are shown in equation (2):

0012charge 2Ni(OH)₂ + 2OH- < ^~- - - -> 2NiOOH + 2H₂O + 2e^" (2) discharge

0013Another type of nickel-based rechargeable battery is a Ni-MH battery.

0014Ni-MH batteries also employ a positive electrode comprised of nickel hydroxide material and use an alkaline electrolyte. Upon application of an electrical potential across a Ni-MH battery, the negative electrode material is charged by the absorption of hydrogen and the discharge of a hydroxyl ion, as shown in equation (3): charge M + H₂O + e^" < > M-H + OH^" (3) discharge

0015Upon discharge, the stored hydrogen is released to form a water molecule and release an electron.

0016The reactions that take place at the nickel hydroxide positive electrode of a Ni-MH battery are shown in equation (4):

0017charge Ni(OH)₂ + OH^" < - - > NiOOH + H₂O + e^" (4) discharge This reaction is identical to that occurring at the positive electrode of a Ni-Cd battery Similar equations can be written for the other known types of nickel-based rechargeable batteries

0018As shown by equation (4), during discharge of a nickel-based rechargeable battery, the nickel of the positive electrode is reduced As the nickel is reduced, the potential at the positive electrode (as well as the potential between the positive and negative electrodes) diminishes

0019In a battery pack comprising a plurality of nickel-based, serially connected rechargeable batteries, the amount of nickel hydroxide positive electrode material (and hence the electrical storage capacity) varies among the individual batteries

0020During discharge of the battery pack, the battery first depleted of positive electrode material will be driven into "cell reversal" by the higher capacity batteries in the battery pack

0021During cell reversal, the "cell-reversed" battery's positive electrode "over- discharges" whereby the electrolysis of water into hydroxide ions and hydrogen gas replaces the reduction of nickel as the dominate reaction, thereby causing a significant drop is the voltage across the battery Furthermore, the production of hydrogen gas increases the pressure within the battery, forcing open the battery vent and permitting the battery electrolyte to escape Cell reversal can occur in battery systems comprising all types of serially connected rechargeable batteries Hence, proper discharge management is essential to protect rechargeable batteries from excessive discharge which can lead to battery dehydration There is thus a need for a battery back monitoring system which is capable of detecting cell reversal, and based upon such detection, act to protect the batteries within the battery pack

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

0023It is an objective of the present invention to provide an apparatus and method for detecting cell reversal in a battery pack It is another objective of the present invention to protect the batteries in the battery pack from damage upon detection of cell reversal

0024These and other objectives are satisfied by an apparatus for monitoring a battery pack having two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries the battery pack divided into N serially connected battery segments (S₁ S_N) where N is an integer greater than or equal to one, each of the battery segments (S, S_N) having two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries, the apparatus comprising a detection means for detecting cell reversal in the battery pack, the detection means comprising N divider networks (D₁ D_N), each including a first divider resistor serially connected to a second divider resistor at a resistor junction, each of the divider networks (D₁ D_N) connected across the respective of the battery segments (S., S , N test points (P., P , each located at a junction between two of the rechargeable batteries within the respective of the battery segments (S S_N), and a voltage comparison means for comparing voltage at each of the test points (P₁ P_N) to voltage at the resistor junction of the respective of the divider networks (D₁ D_N)

0025These and other objectives are also satisfied by an apparatus for monitoring a battery pack having a plurality of serially connected rechargeable batteries, a positive battery pack terminal, and a negative battery pack terminal, said apparatus comprising a detection means for detecting cell reversal in said battery pack, said detection means comprising N test points (P., P_N) each located at a unique junction between two of said batteries of said battery pack, N being an integer greater than or equal to one, and said test points (P, P_N) sequentially ordered from high to low voltage, a divider network including N+1 serially connected divider resistors (DR,, DR_N+1), said divider resistors (DR, DR_N+1) forming N resistor junctions (J., J_N) where each of said resistor junctions (J₁ J_N) is between the respective of said divider resistors (DR₁ DR_N+1) and the next of said divider resistors (DR_! DR_N+1), said divider network connected across said battery pack wherein first of said divider resistors (DR_! DR_N+1) is connected to said positive battery pack terminal, and last of said divider resistors (DR_! DR_N+1) is connected to said negative battery pack terminal, and a voltage comparison means for comparing voltage at each of said test points (P₁ P_N) to voltage at the respective of said resistor junctions (J_T J_N)

0026These and other objectives are also satisfied by an apparatus for monitoring a battery pack having two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries, the apparatus comprising a detection means for detecting cell reversal in the battery pack, and a protection means, responsive to the detection means, for limiting current drawn from the battery pack upon detection of cell reversal

0027These and other objectives are also satisfied by a method of detecting cell reversal in a battery pack having two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries, the method comprising the steps of dividing the battery pack into N serially connected battery segments (S, S_N) wherein N is an integer greater than or equal to one, each of the battery segments including two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries, connecting each of N divider networks (D₁ D_N) across the respective of the battery segments (S₁ S_N), each of the divider networks (S, S including a first divider resistor serially connected to a second divider resistor at a resistor junction, locating each of N test points (P₁ P_N) at a junction between two of the rechargeable batteries within the respective of the battery segments (S S_N), comparing voltage at each of the test points (P₁ P_N) to voltage at the resistorjunction of the respective of the divider networks (D₁ D_N), and providing a detection signal when the absolute value of the difference between voltage at any one of the test points (P., P_N) and voltage at the resistor junction of the respective of the divider networks (D, D_N) is greater than a predetermined value, wherein the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half nominal battery voltage

0028These and other objectives are also satisfied by a method of detecting cell reversal in a battery pack having two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries, the method comprising the steps of dividing the battery pack into N serially connected battery segments (S, S_N) wherein N is an integer greater than or equal to one, each of the battery segments including two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries, connecting each of N divider networks (D₁ D_N) across the respective of the battery segments (S₁ S_N), each of the divider networks (S S_N) including a first divider resistor serially connected to a second divider resistor through a voltage drop device, locating each of N test points (PH, P_N) at a junction between two of the rechargeable batteries within the respective of the battery segments (S₁ S_N), comparing voltage at each of the test points (P₁ P_N) to a voltage window defined by voltage at opposite terminals of the voltage drop device of the respective of the divider networks (D, D_N), and providing a detection signal when voltage at any one of the test points (P., P_N) is outside the voltage window across the voltage drop device of the respective of the divider networks (D., D_N)

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

0030Figure 1 depicts a system block diagram showing the relationship between the load, battery pack and detection means,

0031Figure 2 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including a single test point,

0032Figure 3 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including one or more test points,

0033Figure 4 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including a single test point and a divider network having a voltage drop device, Figure 5 depicts a schematic diagram showing how the window comparator may be implemented using operational amplifiers,

0034Figure 6 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including one or more test points and one or more divider networks each having a voltage drop device, Figure 7 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including one divider network connected across an entire battery pack,

0035Figure 8 depicts a schematic diagram of a detection means including a single divider network connected across an entire battery pack where the divider network includes one or more voltage drop devices, Figure 9a depicts a system block diagram showing the relationship of the load, battery pack, detection means, and protection means,

0036Figure 9b depicts a system block diagram showing how the present invention may be used when the battery pack is driving an electric motor,

0037Figure 10a depicts a simplified schematic diagram of a motor throttle, Figure 10b depicts a simplified schematic diagram showing how the voltage control signal from a motor throttle can be regulated, Figure 11 depicts a schematic diagram of an embodiment of the motor regulating means for protecting a battery pack that is being used to drive an electric motor, and

0038Figure 12 depicts a generalized battery pack comprised of two generalized battery segments

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

0040Figure 1 shows a block diagram of a system incorporating the present invention Figure 1 shows a battery pack 103 electrically connected to and supplying power to a load 101 The battery pack 103 includes two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries The battery pack 103 is monitored by the apparatus of the present invention which comprises a detection means 105 for detecting cell reversal in the battery pack 103

0041As used herein, the term "battery" is a single electrochemical cell Also, as used herein, the "nominal voltage" of a rechargeable battery is defined as the voltage at which the battery is rated It is assumed that all of the batteries included in the battery pack are rated at the same voltage Hence, the nominal voltage of each of the rechargeable batteries in the battery pack is the same and this voltage is defined herein as the "nominal battery voltage"

0042As well, the nominal voltage of a battery segment (defined below) is the nominal voltage of an individual battery (i e the nominal battery voltage) multiplied by the number of batteries in that battery segment, the nominal voltage of a battery subsegment (defined below) is the nominal voltage of an individual battery multiplied by the number of batteries within that subsegment, the nominal voltage of a battery pack is the nominal voltage of an individual battery multiplied by the total number of batteries within the battery pack, and the nominal voltage at any node, junction or terminal is the voltage calculated at that node, junction or terminal assuming that each battery in the battery pack is at the nominal battery voltage

0043Also, as used herein, the notation (X_! X_N) denotes a set of N consecutive elements The "first" element of (X_! X_N) is X_! and the "last" element of (X₁ X_N) is X_N Given two sets of consecutive elements (X_! X_N) and (Y₁ Y_M) with M>N, for each element X, of (X₁ X_N), the "respective" element of (Y, Y_N) is Y„ and the

0044"next" element of (Y, Y_N) is Y_l+1 For example, for element X₂ of (X, X_N), the "respective" element of {Y Y_M) is Y₂, and the "next" element of (Y, Y_M) is Y₃ Also, as used herein, a statement or expression using the generic subscript T is true for all elements (X., X_N) For example, the statement that "resistor X, is connected to the respective diode Y" means that resistor X., is connected to diode Y.,, resistor X₂ is connected to diode Y₂, resistor X₃ is connected to diode Y₃, etc Figure 2 shows a schematic diagram of an embodiment of the detection means 105 for detecting cell reversal in a battery pack 103 Shown are the positive battery pack terminal POS and the negative battery pack terminal NEG of the battery pack 103

0045In general, the battery pack is divided into N serially connected battery segments where N is any integer which is greater than or equal to one Each of the battery segments includes two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries of the battery pack The number of batteries in each of the segments may be different

0046In the embodiment shown in Figure 2, the battery pack 103 includes a single battery segment S having two or more batteries The detection means 105 is comprised of a divider network D connected across the single battery segment S

0047The divider network D includes a first divider resistor DR1 serially connected to a second divider resistor DR2 at a resistor junction J The detection means further includes a test point P located at a junction between two batteries of the battery segment S Test point P divides the battery segment S into a first battery subsegment SS1 and a second battery subsegment SS2 where each battery subsegment includes one or more rechargeable batteries

0048In the embodiment shown in Figure 2, the divider resistors DR1 , DR2 are sized so that the nominal voltage at test point P is substantially equal to the nominal voltage at resistor junction J Sizing the divider resistors DR1 , DR2 as described "balances" the circuit shown in Figure 2 so that the resistance of divider resistor DR1 divided by the resistance of divider resistor DR2 is substantially equal to the voltage across subsegment 1 divided by the voltage across subsegment 2, or expressed algebraically

0049resιstance_DR1/resιstance_DR2 = voltage_ss1/voltage_SS2 (5) When one of the batteries goes into cell reversal, that "cell-reversed" battery as well as the battery subsegment including the cell-reversed battery rapidly drops in voltage. This voltage drop "unbalances" the circuit whereby expression (5) above is no longer true, and the voltage at test point P is no longer substantially equal to the voltage at resistor junction J.

0050The detection means 105 further comprises a voltage comparison means VC for comparing the voltage at the test point P to the voltage at resistor junction J. The voltage comparison means is configured to provide a detection signal when the absolute value of the difference between the voltage at test point P and the voltage at resistor junction J is greater than a predetermined value (i.e.,

0051I voltage_p - voltagβ_j I >- predetermined value). Preferably, the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal (.i.e., .5 x [battery voltage_NOMINAL - battery voltage_REVERSA ). More preferably, the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half the nominal battery voltage.

0052The voltage comparison means may be implemented using a voltage comparator VC which compares the voltage at test point P to the voltage at resistor junction J.

0053Figure 3 shows a generalization of the embodiment of the detection means shown in Figure 2. In Figure 3, the battery pack 103 is divided into N serially connected battery segments (S_V..S_N) where each battery segment includes two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries of the battery pack. The detection means 105 comprises N divider networks (D ..D_N). Each divider network D, is connected across the respective battery segment S_j. (Hence, divider network D₁ is connected across battery segment S.,, divider network D₂ is connected across battery segment S₂, etc., for 1 &lt;i&lt;N.) Also, each divider network D. includes a first divider resistor DR1 and a second divider resistor DR2 serially connected at a resistor junction J,.

0054The detection means 105 further comprises N test points (P_r..P_N) where each test point P_; is located at a junction between two of the rechargeable batteries that are located within the respective battery segment S_f. Each test point P, divides the respective battery segment S_; into a first battery subsegment SS1 and a second battery subsegment SS2, each including one or more rechargeable batteries

0055The first and second divider resistors DR1 , DR2 of each divider network D, are sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the nominal voltage at the respective resistor junction J, Sizing the divider resistors this way "balances" the circuit shown in Figure 3 so that expression (5)

0056(resιstance_DR1/resιstance_DR2 = voltage_ss1/voltage_ΞS2) holds for each divider network

D,

0058Hence, with divider resistors DR1 , DR2 sized as described and with batteries at or near the nominal battery voltage, the voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the voltage at the respective junction J„ and expression (5) above is true for each divider network D, However, when a battery undergoes cell reversal, the voltage across the "cell-reversed" battery rapidly drops, and the voltage across the battery segment and battery subsegment including the cell- reversed battery drop accordingly Expression (5) is no longer true for this battery segment Moreover, the voltage at the test point located within this battery segment and the voltage at the resistor junction within the divider network connected across this battery segment will be significantly different (Hence, if the cell-reversed battery is within battery segment S₃, then the voltage at test point P₃ and the voltage at resistor junction J₃ will be significantly different )

0059The detection means shown in Figure 3 further comprises a voltage comparison means for comparing the voltage at each test point P, to the voltage at the respective resistor junction J, The voltage comparison means is configured to provide a detection signal when the absolute value of the voltage difference between any test point P, and the respective resistor junction J, is greater than a predetermined value (i e , | voltage_Pl - voltage_J( | > predetermined value, for 1 ≤\≤N) Preferably, the predetermined value is chosen to be less than or equal to one-half the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal (i e , 5 x [battery voltage_NOMINAL - battery voltage_REVERSA ) More preferably, the predetermined value is chosen to be less than or equal to one-half the nominal battery voltage

0060Generally, the voltage comparison means may be embodied by one or more voltage comparators Preferably, as shown in Figure 3, the voltage comparison means may be embodied by N voltage comparators (VC, VC_N) Each of the voltage comparator (VC., VC_N) may be implemented using one or more operational amplifiers Alternately, the voltage comparison means may be implemented using a processor means which periodically makes the aforementioned voltage comparisons and provides the detection signal upon detection of cell reversal

0061Figure 4 shows another embodiment of the detection means 105 In Figure 4 the battery pack is a single battery segment including a plurality of rechargeable batteries In this embodiment, the detection means 105 comprises a divider network D connected across the single battery segment S The divider network D includes a first divider resistor DR1 serially coupled to a second divider resistor DR2 The divider network D further includes a voltage drop device VD serially coupled between the first and second divider resistors DR1 , DR2 The voltage drop device VD may be a voltage regulator diode such as one from the Motorola

0062LM285/LM385 series Generally, the voltage drop device VD is chosen so that the voltage drop across the voltage drop device VD forms the appropriate voltage window Preferably, the voltage drop device VD is chosen so that the voltage drop across the device is less than or equal to the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal (battery voltage_NOMINAL - battery voltage_REVERSAL) More preferably, the voltage drop device VD is chosen so that the voltage drop of the device is less than the nominal battery voltage Alternatively, the voltage drop device may be a resistive element

0063The embodiment of the detection means 105 shown in Figure 4 further comprises a test point P located at a junction between two batteries of the battery pack Test point P divides the battery segment into two battery subsegment SS1 and SS2 The first and second divider resistors DR1 , DR2 are sized so that the nominal voltage at test point P is the average of the nominal voltages at the opposite terminals of the voltage drop device VD (i e as shown in Figure 4, terminals 415, 417 are the opposite terminals of voltage drop device VD) As defined above, the nominal voltage at a node, terminal or junction is the calculated voltage at that node, terminal or junction assuming that each battery is at the nominal battery voltage (i e the rated voltage)

0064Sizing the divider resistors DR1 , DR2 as described "balances" the circuit shown in Figure 4 so that, with batteries at or near the nominal battery voltage, the voltage at test point P is substantially equal to the average of the voltages on opposite terminals of the voltage drop device VD (i e the voltage at test point P is at or near the center of the voltage window defined by the voltage drop device VD)

0065However, when one of the batteries in the battery pack undergoes cell reversal, the voltage across the cell-reversed battery as well as the subsegment (i e either SS1 or SS2) including the cell-reversed battery rapidly drop This

0066"unbalances" the circuit shown in Figure 4 whereby (with the voltage drop device VD appropriately chosen) the voltage at test point P moves outside the voltage window defined by the voltage drop device VD

0067In the embodiment shown in Figure 4, the detection means further comprises a voltage comparison means for comparing the voltage at the test point

0068P to the voltage window defined by the voltages at the opposite terminals of voltage drop device VD The voltage comparison means provides a detection signal when the voltage at test point P is outside the voltage window, thereby indicating the detection of cell reversal In the embodiment shown in Figure 4, the comparison means is implemented by a window comparator WC Window comparator WC has an upper-limit input 405 and a lower-limit input 407 Upper-limit input 405 and lower- limit input 407 are connected to the terminals of the voltage drop device VD having the higher and lower voltages, respectively These correspond to terminals 415 and 417, respectively, in Figure 4 The window comparator WC has test input 409 that is connected to test point P The window comparator WC also has a window output 411

0069The window comparator WC in Figure 4 may be implemented using a pair of operational amplifiers This is shown in Figure 5 First and second operational amplifiers 501 and 503 are connected so that the inverting input of the first operational amplifier 501 is connected to the noninverting input of the second operational amplifier 503 The connected inputs jointly form test input 409 of the window comparator WC In this embodiment, test input 409 is connected to the test point P through a current limiting resistor 510 The noninverting input of the first operational amplifier 501 is the upper-limit input 405 of the window comparator WC while the inverting input of the second operational amplifier 503 is the lower- limit input 407 The outputs of the first and second operational amplifiers are coupled together to form window output 411 In this implementation, the window output 411 is connected to the positive battery pack terminal POS of the battery pack through a current limiting resistor 512

0070Alternatively, the voltage comparison means may be implemented by a processor means which makes the appropriate voltage comparisons and provides a detection signal when the voltage at the test point P is outside the voltage window

0071The detection means shown in Figure 4 may be generalized for the case in which the battery pack is divided into N serially connected battery segments (S₁ S_N), where N is an integer greater than or equal to one This is shown in

0072Figure 6 In this case, the detection means comprises N divider networks (D, D_N) where each divider network D, is connected across the respective battery segment S, Each divider network D, comprises a first divider resistor DR1 serially connected to a second divider resistor DR2 through a voltage drop device VD, The voltage drop devices (VD, VD_N) are sized to create the proper voltage window across each voltage drop device VD, Preferably, the voltage drop across each voltage drop device VD.is less or equal to the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal (i e battery voltage_NOMINAL - battery voltage_REVERSAL) More preferably, the voltage drop devices (VD, VD_N) are sized so that the voltage drop across each voltage drop device VD, is less than or equal to the nominal battery voltage

0073The divider resistors DR1 , DR2 for each divider network D, are sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the average of the nominal voltages at opposite terminals of the respective voltage drop device VD, When the divider resistors chosen as described and with batteries at or near their nominal voltages, the voltage at each test point P, is at or near the center of the voltage window defined by the voltages on opposite terminals of the respective voltage drop device VD, (i e as shown in Figure 6, the terminals 615, and 617, of the respective voltage drop device VD,) When one of the batteries undergoes cell reversal, the voltage of this cell-reversed battery rapidly drops, and the voltage of the battery segment and battery subsegment including the cell- reversed battery drops accordingly When this occurs, the voltage at the test point located within the battery segment including the cell-reversed battery will move outside the voltage window defined by the respective voltage drop device (for example, if the cell-reversed battery is located within battery segment S₃, then the voltage at test point P₃ will move outside the voltage window defined by voltage drop device VD₃)

0074The detection means shown in Figure 6 includes a voltage comparison means which compares the voltage at each test point P, to the voltage window defined by the voltages on opposite terminals of the respective voltage drop device VD, When the voltage comparison means detects that the voltage at any of the test points P, is outside the voltage window of the respective voltage drop device

0075VD„ it provides a detection signal indicating the occurrence of cell reversal

0076Generally, the voltage comparison means may be embodied by one or more window comparators As shown in Figure 6, the voltage comparison means may be implemented using N window comparators (WC, WC_N) Each window comparator WC, has an upper-limit input 605, and a lower-limit input 607, electrically connected to the terminals 615, and 617,, respectively, of the respective voltage drop device VD, Each window comparator WC, has a test input 609, electrically connected to the respective test point P, Each window comparator WC, also has a window output 611, Each window comparator WC, may be implemented using a pair of operational amplifiers The voltage comparison means may also be implemented using a processor means which makes the aforementioned comparisons

0077Alternative embodiments of the detection means are shown in Figures 7 and 8 Figure 7 shows an embodiment of the detection means comprising N test points (P, P_N) each located at a unique junction between two of the batteries of the battery pack As previously defined, N is an integer greater than or equal to one The test points (P, P_N) are sequentially ordered from high to low voltage (where voltage is measured from the test point P, to the negative battery pack terminal) The detection means further comprises a divider network D including N+1 serially connected divider resistors (DR, DR_N+1) The divider network D is placed across the battery pack so that the "first" divider resistor DR, is connected to the positive battery pack terminal POS and the "last" divider resistor DR_N+1 is connected to the negative battery pack terminal NEG The divider resistors (DR, DR_N+1) form N resistor junctions (J, J_N) ordered so that each resistor junction J, is between the respective divider resistor DR, and the "next" divider resistor DR,₊₁ Preferably, the divider resistors (DR, DR_N+1) are sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the nominal voltage at the respective resistor junction J,

0078The embodiment of the detection means shown in Figure 7 further includes a voltage comparison means for comparing voltage at each test point P, to voltage at the respective resistor junction J, The voltage comparison means may be implemented by one or more voltage comparators As shown in Figure 7, the voltage comparison means is implemented using N voltage comparators (VC, VC_N) The voltage comparison means provides a detection signal, indicating cell reversal, when the absolute value of the difference between voltage at any test point P, and voltage at the respective resistor junction J, is greater than a predetermined value Preferably, the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after reversal More preferably, the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half the nominal battery voltage

0079Figure 8 shows yet another embodiment of the detection means In this embodiment, divider network D comprises N+1 serially connected divider resistors

0080(DR, DR_N+1) and further comprises N voltage drop devices (VD, VD_N) Each voltage drop device VD, is coupled between the respective divider resistor DR, and the next divider resistor DR,₊, In the embodiment shown in Figure 8, the divider resistors (DR, DR_N+1) are sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is the average of the nominal voltages at opposite terminals of the respective voltage drop device VD, Preferably, the voltage drop devices (VD, VD_N) are chosen so that the voltage drop across each device is less than or equal to the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal More preferably, the voltage drop across device is chosen to be less than or equal to the nominal battery voltage

0081The embodiment of the detection means shown in Figure 8 further includes a voltage comparison means which compares the voltage at each test point P₍ to the voltage window defined by nominal voltage at opposite terminals of the respective voltage drop device VD, The voltage comparison means provides a detection signal indicating cell reversal when the voltage at any test point P, is outside the voltage window of the respective voltage drop device VD, The voltage comparison means may be implemented by one or more window comparators

0082Shown in Figure 8, the voltage comparison means is implemented using N window comparators (WC, WC_N)

0083As shown in Figure 9a, the apparatus of the present invention may further comprise a protection means 910, responsive to the detection means 105, for protecting the cell-reversed battery from damage upon detection of cell reversal

0084During cell-reversal, current from the higher capacity batteries (drawn by loads connected to the battery pack) causes the positive electrode of the cell-reversed battery to over-discharge, resulting in production of hydrogen gas The gas forces open the battery vent resulting in loss of battery electrolyte and eventual destruction of the battery The protection means 910 protects the battery pack 103 by limiting the amount of current drawn from the battery pack 103 by the various loads (represented by load 101 in Figure 9a)

0085Figure 9b is a system block diagram showing how the present invention may be used when the load 101 includes an electric motor 901 The electric motor can be any voltage controlled AC or DC motor The protection means 910 comprises a motor regulating means 915 which, upon detection of cell reversal, limits the current drawn from the battery pack 103 by reducing the maximum amount of current that the electric motor 901 can draw from the battery pack 103 In one embodiment of the motor regulating means 915, the motor regulating means 915 operates by limiting the voltage applied to the electric motor 901 for powering the electric motor 901 Limiting the voltage applied to the electric motor limits the torque of the motor, thereby limiting the current drawn by the motor In the system block diagram shown in Figure 9b, the voltage necessary for powering the electric motor is applied to the electric motor via a motor control unit 920 The magnitude of the voltage applied by the motor control unit 920 is controlled by a motor control signal 930 that is provided by a motor throttle 940 Adjusting the motor throttle 940 thereby controls the motor control signal 930 which thereby controls the voltage applied to the electric motor 901 via the motor control

0086An isolation means 905 may be serially coupled between the detection means 105 and the motor regulating means 915 to isolate voltages and references between the detection means 105 and the motor regulating means 915 The isolation means 905 may be implemented by one or more opto-isolators In the embodiment shown in Figure 9b, the motor regulating means 915 is responsive to the detection means 105 through the isolation means 905

0087In one embodiment, the motor regulating means 915 operates by regulating the voltage control signal 930 transmitted from the motor throttle 930 to the motor control unit 920 Upon detection of cell reversal by the detection means 105, the motor regulating means 915 adjusts the voltage control signal 930 to limit the voltage powering the electric motor 901

0088As shown in Figure 10a, the motor throttle may be viewed as a divider network comprising a potentiometer POT1 serially coupled to a resistor R1030

0089In the embodiment shown in Figure 10a, the motor control signal 930 is simply the voltage across the potentiometer POT1 Decreasing the resistance of the potentiometer POT1 or increasing the resistance of resistor R1030 lowers the voltage across the potentiometer POT1 The motor control unit responds by lowering the voltage applied to the electric motor 901

0090As shown in Figure 10b, upon detection of cell reversal, the motor regulating means 915 effectively "increases" the resistance of resistor R1030 by coupling at least one additional resistor R1040 is series with resistor R1030 As described, this lowers the voltage across the potentiometer POT1 , thereby lowering the voltage applied to the electric motor 901 for powering the electric motor 901

0091Figure 11 shows a schematic diagram of an embodiment of the motor regulating means 915 The motor regulating means 915 comprises a relay means 1103 for switching the resistors R1040 in series with the resistor R1030 The motor regulating means 915 further comprises a relay control means 1101 for controlling the timing of the aforementioned switching The relay means 1103 is responsive to the relay control means 1101 In the embodiment shown, relay control means 1101 is electrically connected to the detection means 105 through an isolation means 905 and is responsive to the detection means 105.

0092In the embodiment shown in Figure 11 , relay means 1103 comprises one or more relays 1105, and a driver 1106 for supplying each relay 1105 with sufficient current for switching Each driver 1106 may implemented by one or more transistors

0093In the embodiment shown in Figure 11 , the relay control means 1101 comprises one or more voltage comparators 1107 Each voltage comparator 1107 has a variable input 1109, a reference input 1111 , and a comparator output 1113

0094The variable input 1109 is connected to a variable voltage source In the embodiment shown in Figure 11 , the variable voltage source is implemented by a timing resistor R1160 and a timing capacitor C1170 connected in series The variable input 1109 of each voltage comparator is connected to the junction of the timing resistor R1160 and timing capacitor C1170 The voltage at the variable input 1109 increases at a rate dependant on the values of the timing resistor

0095R1160 and the timing capacitor C1170 The values are chosen to control the timing of relay switching

0096Each reference input 1111 is connected to a reference voltage In the embodiment shown in Figure 11 , the reference voltage is provided by potentiometer POT2 connected at one end to voltage powering point V1 and at the other end to ground GND Each comparator output 1113 is connected to an input of a relay driver 1106

0097Figure 11 also shows how each voltage comparator 1107 may be implemented using an operational amplifier In this implementation, the inverting and noninverting inputs of each operational amplifier are the variable and reference inputs 1109, 1111 , respectively, of the voltage comparator 1107 The outputs of each operational amplifier are connected to current limiting resistors R1120. In the embodiment shown in Figure 11 , the detection means 105 is electrically coupled to the motor regulating means 915 through the isolation means 905 The isolation means 905 is electrically coupled to the junction between the timing resistor R1160 and timing capacitor C1170 Upon detection of cell reversal, timing capacitor C1170 charges, and the voltage at variable voltage input 1109 rises When the voltage at variable voltage input 1109 rises above that of reference input 1107, the voltage at comparator output 1113 turns on relay driver 1106, switching relay 1105 and coupling an additional resistor R 1040 in series with resistor R1030 As stated above, the isolation means 905 may be implemented using one or more opto-isolators

0098Also disclosed herein is an apparatus for monitoring a battery pack The battery pack has two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries The apparatus comprises a detection means for detecting cell reversal in said battery pack The apparatus further comprises a protection means, responsive to the detection means, for limiting current drawn from the battery pack upon detection of cell reversal In one embodiment, the protection means comprises a motor regulating means, responsive to the detection means, for limiting voltage powering an electric motor that is drawing current from the battery pack, thereby limiting current drawn by the electric motor from the battery pack upon detection of cell reversal The motor regulating means regulates a voltage control signal transmitted from a motor throttle to a motor control unit whereby, upon detection of cell reversal by the detection means, the motor regulating means adjusts the voltage control signal causing the motor control unit to limit the voltage powering the electπc motor An implementation of the voltage regulating means has been discussed above

0099Also disclosed herein is a method of detecting cell reversal in a battery pack having a plurality of serially connected rechargeable batteries The method comprises the step of dividing the battery pack into N serially connected battery segments (S, S_N) where N is an integer greater than or equal to one Generally, each battery segment includes two or more of the serially connected rechargeable batteries The number of batteries in each of the battery segments (S, S_N) need not be the same The method also comprises the step of connecting each of N divider networks (D,. D_N) across the respective of the battery segments (S,.. S_N) Hence, divider network D, is connected across battery segment S, Each divider network D, includes a first divider resistor serially connected to a second divider resistor at a resistor junction The method also comprises the step of locating each of N test points

0100(P, . P_N) at a junction between two batteries located within the respective of the battery segments (S, .S_N) Hence, test point P, is located at a junction between two batteries within battery segment S, Each test point P, divides the respective battery segment S, into a first and a second subsegment The number of batteries in the first and second subsegment need not be the same Preferably, the first and said second divider resistors of each divider network D, are be sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the nominal voltage at the resistor junction of the respective divider network D,

0101The method also comprises the steps of comparing voltage at each test point P, to voltage at the resistor junction of the respective divider network D„ and providing a detection signal when the absolute value of the difference between the voltage at any test point P, and the voltage at the resistor junction of the respective divider network D, is greater than a predetermined value Preferably, the predetermined values is less than or equal to one-half the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal. More preferably, the predetermined value is less than or equal to one-half the nominal battery voltage

0102Also disclosed herein is a method of detecting cell reversal in a battery pack having a plurality of serially connected rechargeable batteries The method comprises the step of dividing the battery pack into N serially connected battery segments (S, ,S_N) where N is an integer greater than or equal to one, each of the battery segments includes two or more serially connected rechargeable batteries The number of batteries in each of the battery segments (S, S_N) need not be the same The method also comprises the step of connecting each of N divider networks (D, . D_N) across the respective of the battery segments (S, ..S_N). Hence, each divider network D, is connected across the respective battery segment S, Each divider network D, includes a first divider resistor serially connected to a second divider resistor through a voltage drop device Preferably, each voltage drop device includes one or more voltage regulator diodes Examples of voltage regulator diodes are the Motorola LM285/LM385 series The method also includes the step of locating each of N test points (P, P_N) at a junction between two batteries within the respective of the battery segments (S, S_N) Hence, each test point P, is located at a junction between two batteries within the respective battery segment S, Each test point P, further divides the respective battery segment S, into two subsegments, a first subsegment and a second subsegment The number of batteries in each of the subsegments need not be the same

0103Preferably, the first and second divider resistors of each divider network D, are sized so that the nominal voltage at each test point P, is substantially equal to the average of the nominal voltages on opposite terminals of the voltage drop device of the respective divider network D, Preferably, the voltage drop across each voltage drop device is chosen to be less than or equal to the difference between the nominal battery voltage and the battery voltage after cell reversal More preferably, the voltage drop across each voltage drop device is chosen to be less than the nominal battery voltage The method also includes the steps of comparing voltage at each test point

0104P, to a voltage window defined by the voltages at opposite terminals of the voltage drop device of the respective divider network D„ and providing a detection signal when the voltage at any test point P, is outside the voltage window across the voltage drop device of the respective divider network D, In the discussion above, the battery pack comprises a plurality of serially connected rechargeable batteries The one or more terminal points divide the battery pack into a plurality of serially connected battery segments Each battery segment is comprised of one or more serially connected rechargeable batteries

0105The present invention is also applicable to a "generalized" battery pack configuration A "generalized" battery pack is defined herein as a battery pack in which one or more of the battery segments (S, S_N) have been replaced with a "generalized" battery segment A generalized battery segment comprises two or more regular battery segments connected in parallel (where each of the regular battery segments includes two or more serially connected batteries).

0106An example of a generalized battery pack 1201 is shown in Figure 12. It includes two generalized battery segments 1205 and 1007. Each of the generalized battery segments 1205, 1207 includes four regular battery segments

01071210 and 1212, respectively, that have been connected in parallel. Each of the battery segments 1210 includes two serially connected batteries 1214, while each of the battery segments 1212 is comprised three serially connected batteries 1214.

0108As described above, the disclosed invention detects drops in battery voltage due to cell reversal. However, the present invention can also detect drops in battery voltage occurring for reasons other than cell reversal. For example, an increase in the internal resistance of a battery (possibly due to internal overheating) may cause the voltage of the battery to drop. This voltage drop can be detected by the apparatus and methods disclosed herein.

0109While the invention has been described in connection with preferred embodiments and procedures, it is to be understood that it is not intended to limit the invention to the preferred embodiments and procedures. On the contrary, it is intended to cover all alternatives, modifications and equivalence which may be included within the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the claims appended hereinafter.